An efficient domain-independent approach for supervised keyphrase extraction and ranking

Overview

• This paper presents a supervised learning approach for automatically extracting keyphrases from single documents.
• The proposed solution uses simple statistical and positional features of candidate phrases, without relying on external knowledge bases or pre-trained language models.
• The ranking component is a lightweight ensemble model.
• Evaluation on benchmark datasets shows the approach achieves significantly higher accuracy than several state-of-the-art baselines, including unsupervised deep learning models, and is competitive with some supervised deep learning models.
• Despite the supervised nature, the solution bears advantages of unsupervised approaches as it does not rely on any corpus of golden keywords or external knowledge.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a method for automatically identifying important phrases, known as keyphrases, within a single document. Unlike some other approaches that rely on large language models or external databases of information, this method uses only simple statistics and the position of potential keyphrases within the document itself.

The key idea is to look at features like how often a phrase appears, where it appears in the document, and other basic characteristics, and then use a machine learning model to rank the most important phrases. This ranking model is a relatively lightweight combination of simpler models, rather than a complex deep learning system.

When tested on standard benchmark datasets, this simple approach was able to outperform many state-of-the-art deep learning-based unsupervised keyphrase extraction methods. It even matched the performance of some supervised deep learning models, while avoiding the need for a large corpus of example keyphrases or external knowledge sources.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a supervised learning approach for automatic keyphrase extraction from single documents. The proposed solution uses a set of simple statistical and positional features of candidate phrases, without relying on any external knowledge base or pre-trained language models.

The feature set includes metrics like term frequency, inverse document frequency, position of the first and last occurrences of the phrase, and whether the phrase appears in the title or abstract. These features are then used to train a lightweight ensemble model, combining several base rankers, to score and rank the candidate keyphrases.

Evaluation on benchmark datasets like SemEval and Inspec shows that this approach significantly outperforms several state-of-the-art unsupervised keyphrase extraction baselines, including deep learning-based models. It also performs competitively with some supervised deep learning-based models.

Critical Analysis

The paper highlights the surprising effectiveness of a relatively simple supervised approach for keyphrase extraction, compared to more complex unsupervised and deep learning-based methods. This suggests that carefully engineered features can be a powerful alternative to relying solely on large pre-trained models or external knowledge sources.

However, the authors acknowledge that their solution still requires a corpus of documents with annotated keyphrases for training the supervised model. While this is less onerous than requiring a knowledge base, it may limit the applicability of the approach in domains where such training data is not readily available.

Additionally, the paper does not provide a deeper analysis of the types of documents or domains where this approach may be most effective. It would be valuable to understand the characteristics of the text that enable the simple statistical and positional features to be so successful, and whether there are any limitations or biases in the types of keyphrases that can be effectively extracted.

Overall, the research presented in this paper offers a promising alternative to more complex keyphrase extraction methods, and encourages further exploration of the tradeoffs between model complexity, reliance on external resources, and extraction performance.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that a supervised learning approach using simple statistical and positional features can be surprisingly effective for automatically extracting keyphrases from single documents. The proposed solution outperforms many state-of-the-art unsupervised and deep learning-based methods, while avoiding the need for large language models or external knowledge bases.

The findings suggest that careful feature engineering can be a powerful alternative to more complex deep learning approaches, particularly in domains where annotated training data is available. This work contributes to the ongoing exploration of effective and efficient information extraction techniques that balance performance and resource requirements.