Efficient and Responsible Adaptation of Large Language Models for Robust Top-k Recommendations

Read original: arXiv:2405.00824 - Published 5/3/2024 by Kirandeep Kaur, Chirag Shah

💬

Overview

Conventional recommendation systems (RSs) are typically optimized to improve performance metrics across all training samples.
This makes it difficult for data-driven RSs to cater to diverse users with varying properties, leading to performance disparities among sub-populations.
While recent studies have shown promise in adapting large language models (LLMs) for recommendations, long user queries can degrade LLM performance and increase costs.
To address this, the paper proposes a hybrid task allocation framework that combines the capabilities of LLMs and traditional RSs to improve robustness to sub-populations.

Plain English Explanation

Recommendation systems (RSs) are used to suggest products, services, or content to users based on their preferences and behaviors. Typically, these systems are designed to maximize overall performance metrics, such as accuracy or engagement. However, this one-size-fits-all approach can lead to some users receiving suboptimal recommendations, particularly those with unique or less common preferences.

The paper argues that this performance disparity among different user populations can make RSs less robust and reliable. To address this, the researchers propose a hybrid approach that combines the strengths of two types of recommendation systems: traditional RSs and large language models (LLMs).

Traditional RSs are good at quickly processing large amounts of data and making recommendations based on patterns in user behavior. However, they may struggle to cater to users with niche interests or complex needs. On the other hand, LLMs are powerful language-understanding models that can provide more personalized recommendations, but they may become overwhelmed by lengthy user queries or have higher associated costs.

The hybrid framework proposed in the paper aims to strike a balance by strategically allocating tasks between the traditional RS and the LLM. First, it identifies users who are receiving suboptimal recommendations from the traditional RS. For these "weak" users, the system then uses the LLM to generate personalized recommendations, contextualizing each user's interaction history as a unique task.

By combining the strengths of both approaches, the researchers aim to improve the overall robustness and performance of the recommendation system, particularly for underserved user sub-populations, without disproportionately increasing costs or processing times.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a hybrid task allocation framework that integrates the capabilities of traditional recommendation algorithms, such as collaborative filtering and learning-to-rank models, with the power of large language models (LLMs) to address the challenges of serving diverse user populations.

The key elements of the proposed approach are:

Identification of Weak Users: The system first identifies users who receive suboptimal ranking performance from the traditional RS. These "weak" users are the focus of the hybrid framework.
In-Context Learning for Weak Users: For the identified weak users, the system uses an in-context learning approach, where each user's interaction history is contextualized as a distinct ranking task and presented to an LLM. This allows the LLM to provide more personalized recommendations for these users.
Hybrid Task Allocation: The framework strategically assigns tasks to either the traditional RS or the LLM, leveraging the strengths of each approach to improve overall system performance and robustness.

The researchers evaluate their hybrid framework by incorporating various recommendation algorithms and two different LLMs, both open-source and closed-source. The results on three real-world datasets show a significant reduction in the number of weak users and an improvement in the overall robustness of the recommendation system (approximately 12%) without disproportionately increasing costs.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a thoughtful approach to addressing the performance disparities among different user sub-populations in recommendation systems. By integrating traditional recommendation algorithms and large language models, the proposed hybrid framework aims to provide more personalized and robust recommendations, particularly for users who may be underserved by conventional RSs.

One potential limitation of the approach is the reliance on accurately identifying "weak" users who would benefit most from the LLM-based recommendations. The effectiveness of this user segmentation process could be an area for further research and refinement.

Additionally, while the paper demonstrates the potential benefits of the hybrid framework, the authors do not provide a detailed analysis of the tradeoffs between the increased performance and the additional computational and monetary costs associated with the LLM-based recommendations. Understanding these tradeoffs would be crucial for assessing the practical feasibility and scalability of the approach.

Furthermore, the paper does not address the potential ethical implications of using LLMs, which have been known to exhibit biases and generate problematic content in some cases. Exploring ways to ensure the responsible and accountable use of LLMs within recommendation systems would be an important area for future research.

Conclusion

The paper presents a promising hybrid task allocation framework that combines the strengths of traditional recommendation algorithms and large language models to improve the robustness of recommendation systems, particularly for underserved user sub-populations. By strategically assigning tasks to the most appropriate component, the framework aims to provide more personalized and effective recommendations without disproportionately increasing costs or processing times.

The research highlights the importance of addressing performance disparities in recommendation systems and offers a novel approach to tackling this challenge. As the use of large language models in various applications continues to evolve, the insights from this study could inform the development of more inclusive and responsible recommendation systems that cater to the diverse needs of users.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

💬

Efficient and Responsible Adaptation of Large Language Models for Robust Top-k Recommendations

Kirandeep Kaur, Chirag Shah

Conventional recommendation systems (RSs) are typically optimized to enhance performance metrics uniformly across all training samples. This makes it hard for data-driven RSs to cater to a diverse set of users due to the varying properties of these users. The performance disparity among various populations can harm the model's robustness with respect to sub-populations. While recent works have shown promising results in adapting large language models (LLMs) for recommendation to address hard samples, long user queries from millions of users can degrade the performance of LLMs and elevate costs, processing times and inference latency. This challenges the practical applicability of LLMs for recommendations. To address this, we propose a hybrid task allocation framework that utilizes the capabilities of both LLMs and traditional RSs. By adopting a two-phase approach to improve robustness to sub-populations, we promote a strategic assignment of tasks for efficient and responsible adaptation of LLMs. Our strategy works by first identifying the weak and inactive users that receive a suboptimal ranking performance by RSs. Next, we use an in-context learning approach for such users, wherein each user interaction history is contextualized as a distinct ranking task and given to an LLM. We test our hybrid framework by incorporating various recommendation algorithms -- collaborative filtering and learning-to-rank recommendation models -- and two LLMs -- both open and close-sourced. Our results on three real-world datasets show a significant reduction in weak users and improved robustness of RSs to sub-populations $(approx12%)$ and overall performance without disproportionately escalating costs.

5/3/2024

💬

Adapting Large Language Models by Integrating Collaborative Semantics for Recommendation

Bowen Zheng, Yupeng Hou, Hongyu Lu, Yu Chen, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ming Chen, Ji-Rong Wen

Recently, large language models (LLMs) have shown great potential in recommender systems, either improving existing recommendation models or serving as the backbone. However, there exists a large semantic gap between LLMs and recommender systems, since items to be recommended are often indexed by discrete identifiers (item ID) out of the LLM's vocabulary. In essence, LLMs capture language semantics while recommender systems imply collaborative semantics, making it difficult to sufficiently leverage the model capacity of LLMs for recommendation. To address this challenge, in this paper, we propose a new LLM-based recommendation model called LC-Rec, which can better integrate language and collaborative semantics for recommender systems. Our approach can directly generate items from the entire item set for recommendation, without relying on candidate items. Specifically, we make two major contributions in our approach. For item indexing, we design a learning-based vector quantization method with uniform semantic mapping, which can assign meaningful and non-conflicting IDs (called item indices) for items. For alignment tuning, we propose a series of specially designed tuning tasks to enhance the integration of collaborative semantics in LLMs. Our fine-tuning tasks enforce LLMs to deeply integrate language and collaborative semantics (characterized by the learned item indices), so as to achieve an effective adaptation to recommender systems. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, showing that our approach can outperform a number of competitive baselines including traditional recommenders and existing LLM-based recommenders. Our code is available at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/LC-Rec/.

4/22/2024

Enhancing Recommendation Diversity by Re-ranking with Large Language Models

Diego Carraro, Derek Bridge

It has long been recognized that it is not enough for a Recommender System (RS) to provide recommendations based only on their relevance to users. Among many other criteria, the set of recommendations may need to be diverse. Diversity is one way of handling recommendation uncertainty and ensuring that recommendations offer users a meaningful choice. The literature reports many ways of measuring diversity and improving the diversity of a set of recommendations, most notably by re-ranking and selecting from a larger set of candidate recommendations. Driven by promising insights from the literature on how to incorporate versatile Large Language Models (LLMs) into the RS pipeline, in this paper we show how LLMs can be used for diversity re-ranking. We begin with an informal study that verifies that LLMs can be used for re-ranking tasks and do have some understanding of the concept of item diversity. Then, we design a more rigorous methodology where LLMs are prompted to generate a diverse ranking from a candidate ranking using various prompt templates with different re-ranking instructions in a zero-shot fashion. We conduct comprehensive experiments testing state-of-the-art LLMs from the GPT and Llama families. We compare their re-ranking capabilities with random re-ranking and various traditional re-ranking methods from the literature. We open-source the code of our experiments for reproducibility. Our findings suggest that the trade-offs (in terms of performance and costs, among others) of LLM-based re-rankers are superior to those of random re-rankers but, as yet, inferior to the ones of traditional re-rankers. However, the LLM approach is promising. LLMs exhibit improved performance on many natural language processing and recommendation tasks and lower inference costs. Given these trends, we can expect LLM-based re-ranking to become more competitive soon.

6/19/2024

Large Language Models Enhanced Collaborative Filtering

Zhongxiang Sun, Zihua Si, Xiaoxue Zang, Kai Zheng, Yang Song, Xiao Zhang, Jun Xu

Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have attracted considerable interest among researchers to leverage these models to enhance Recommender Systems (RSs). Existing work predominantly utilizes LLMs to generate knowledge-rich texts or utilizes LLM-derived embeddings as features to improve RSs. Although the extensive world knowledge embedded in LLMs generally benefits RSs, the application can only take limited number of users and items as inputs, without adequately exploiting collaborative filtering information. Considering its crucial role in RSs, one key challenge in enhancing RSs with LLMs lies in providing better collaborative filtering information through LLMs. In this paper, drawing inspiration from the in-context learning and chain of thought reasoning in LLMs, we propose the Large Language Models enhanced Collaborative Filtering (LLM-CF) framework, which distils the world knowledge and reasoning capabilities of LLMs into collaborative filtering. We also explored a concise and efficient instruction-tuning method, which improves the recommendation capabilities of LLMs while preserving their general functionalities (e.g., not decreasing on the LLM benchmark). Comprehensive experiments on three real-world datasets demonstrate that LLM-CF significantly enhances several backbone recommendation models and consistently outperforms competitive baselines, showcasing its effectiveness in distilling the world knowledge and reasoning capabilities of LLM into collaborative filtering.

7/25/2024