Elucidating the theoretical underpinnings of surrogate gradient learning in spiking neural networks

Overview

• Training spiking neural networks to approximate complex functions is important for studying the brain and developing neuromorphic computing.
• However, the binary nature of spikes poses a challenge for direct gradient-based training.
• Surrogate gradients have been empirically successful, but their theoretical foundation has been unclear.
• This paper investigates the relation of surrogate gradients to two other theoretical approaches: smoothed probabilistic models and stochastic automatic differentiation.

Plain English Explanation

Spiking neural networks, which mimic the way neurons in the brain communicate using electrical pulses or "spikes," are important for understanding how the brain processes information and for developing neuromorphic computing systems that work more like the brain. However, the binary nature of these spikes makes it challenging to directly train these networks using gradient-based methods, which are commonly used to train other types of neural networks.

To get around this problem, researchers have used a technique called "surrogate gradients," which provides a way to approximate the gradients during training. While surrogate gradients have been shown to work well in practice, their theoretical justification has been unclear. This paper explores the connection between surrogate gradients and two other theoretical approaches: smoothed probabilistic models and stochastic automatic differentiation.

The key insight is that stochastic automatic differentiation, which is designed to handle the randomness inherent in spiking neural networks, can provide the theoretical foundation for surrogate gradients. The paper also shows that surrogate gradients in deterministic networks are a special case of this more general framework.

Overall, this work helps to solidify the theoretical underpinnings of the widely used surrogate gradient approach, providing a more robust theoretical basis for training spiking neural networks.

Technical Explanation

The paper investigates the theoretical foundations of using "surrogate gradients" to train spiking neural networks, which are an important model for understanding information processing in the brain and developing neuromorphic computing systems.

The binary nature of spikes in spiking neural networks makes it challenging to directly apply gradient-based training methods, which are commonly used for other types of neural networks. Surrogate gradients have been shown to work well empirically, but their theoretical justification has been unclear.

The authors explore two theoretically well-founded approaches and their relation to surrogate gradients:

1. Smoothed probabilistic models: These models provide gradients equivalent to surrogate gradients in single neurons, but are impractical for training deep spiking neural networks due to the lack of support for automatic differentiation.

2. Stochastic automatic differentiation: This approach is compatible with the discrete randomness inherent in spiking neural networks, but has not previously been applied to spiking neural network training.

The key finding is that stochastic automatic differentiation provides the missing theoretical basis for surrogate gradients in stochastic spiking neural networks. The authors also show that surrogate gradients in deterministic networks correspond to a particular asymptotic case of this more general framework.

Furthermore, the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of surrogate gradients in stochastic multi-layer spiking neural networks through numerical experiments. Finally, the authors show that surrogate gradients are not conservative fields and, therefore, are not gradients of a surrogate loss function.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a solid theoretical foundation for the widely used surrogate gradient approach to training spiking neural networks, addressing an important gap in the existing literature. By connecting surrogate gradients to well-established techniques like smoothed probabilistic models and stochastic automatic differentiation, the authors have strengthened the theoretical underpinnings of this practical method.

One potential limitation of the work is that it focuses primarily on the theoretical analysis and does not extensively explore the practical implications or real-world applications of the surrogate gradient framework. While the numerical experiments demonstrate its effectiveness, further research may be needed to fully understand the performance and limitations of surrogate gradients in diverse spiking neural network architectures and tasks.

Additionally, the paper does not address potential issues related to the scalability or computational efficiency of the stochastic automatic differentiation approach, which could be important considerations for training large-scale spiking neural networks. Exploring these practical aspects may be a fruitful area for future research.

Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field by providing a more rigorous theoretical basis for surrogate gradients in spiking neural networks, paving the way for further advancements in this important area of research.

Conclusion

This paper investigates the theoretical foundations of using surrogate gradients to train spiking neural networks, which are crucial for understanding information processing in the brain and developing neuromorphic computing systems. By connecting surrogate gradients to smoothed probabilistic models and stochastic automatic differentiation, the authors have provided a solid theoretical basis for this widely used practical technique.

The key insights are that stochastic automatic differentiation can provide the missing theoretical justification for surrogate gradients in stochastic spiking neural networks, and that surrogate gradients in deterministic networks are a special case of this more general framework. This work helps to strengthen the theoretical underpinnings of spiking neural network training and opens up new avenues for further research in this important field.