An Empirical Study on Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for MultiModal Large Language Models
2406.05130
0
0
Abstract
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) fine-tuned with multimodal instruction datasets have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in multimodal tasks. However, fine-tuning all parameters of MLLMs has become challenging as they usually contain billions of parameters. To address this issue, we study parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods for MLLMs. We aim to identify effective methods for enhancing the performance of MLLMs in scenarios where only a limited number of parameters are trained. This paper conducts empirical studies using four popular PEFT methods to fine-tune the LLM component of open-source MLLMs. We present a comprehensive analysis that encompasses various aspects, including the impact of PEFT methods on various models, parameters and location of the PEFT module, size of fine-tuning data, model stability based on PEFT methods, MLLM's generalization, and hallucination. We evaluated four PEFT methods on seven datasets from two different categories: unseen and seen datasets. Across all experiments, we show that the adapter is the best-performing PEFT method. At the same time, fine-tuning the connector layers leads to improved performance in most MLLMs. Code and data are available at https://github.com/alenai97/PEFT-MLLM.git.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques for multimodal large language models, which can be used to adapt these powerful models to specific tasks or domains while requiring far fewer trainable parameters than traditional fine-tuning.
- The researchers conduct an extensive empirical study to evaluate the performance and efficiency of various parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods across a range of multimodal tasks, including image classification, visual question answering, and text-to-image generation.
- The findings provide valuable insights into the trade-offs and best practices for parameter-efficient fine-tuning of multimodal large language models, which can help practitioners more effectively leverage these powerful models in low-resource settings.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 and BERT have shown impressive capabilities across a wide range of tasks, from natural language processing to multimodal applications that combine text, images, and other data. However, fully fine-tuning these massive models for a specific task can be computationally expensive and require a large amount of training data.
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques offer a potential solution by allowing you to adapt LLMs to new tasks while only updating a small subset of the model's parameters. This can dramatically reduce the computational and data requirements compared to traditional fine-tuning approaches.
In this study, the researchers evaluate the performance of several parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods on a variety of multimodal tasks, such as image classification, visual question answering, and text-to-image generation. They compare the efficiency and accuracy of these techniques to traditional fine-tuning, providing guidance on when and how to use parameter-efficient methods for the best results.
The key takeaway is that parameter-efficient fine-tuning can be a powerful tool for adapting large, powerful language models to new applications, especially when you have limited computational resources or training data. By selectively updating only a small portion of the model's parameters, you can achieve impressive performance gains while dramatically reducing the cost and complexity of the fine-tuning process.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents an empirical study on parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) techniques for adapting multimodal large language models (LLMs) to specific tasks. The researchers evaluate several PEFT methods, including LoRA, Prefix Tuning, and Prompt Tuning, across a range of multimodal tasks such as image classification, visual question answering, and text-to-image generation.
The experiments are designed to assess the trade-offs between the parameter efficiency, task performance, and inference latency of the different PEFT methods compared to traditional fine-tuning. The researchers use several multimodal benchmark datasets, including COCO, Visual Genome, and LAION-400M, to evaluate the techniques.
The key findings from the study include:
- PEFT methods can achieve comparable or even superior task performance to traditional fine-tuning, while requiring orders of magnitude fewer trainable parameters.
- The performance and efficiency of PEFT methods can vary significantly depending on the task, dataset, and architectural details of the LLM.
- Prompt Tuning and LoRA tend to be the most parameter-efficient techniques, while Prefix Tuning can offer better task performance in some cases.
- There is often a trade-off between parameter efficiency and inference latency, with more parameter-efficient methods sometimes incurring higher computational costs during inference.
The researchers provide detailed analyses and recommendations on when and how to apply different PEFT techniques based on the specific requirements of a given application. The insights from this comprehensive empirical study can help practitioners more effectively leverage powerful multimodal LLMs in low-resource settings.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-designed empirical evaluation of parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques for multimodal large language models. The researchers have carefully selected a diverse range of tasks and datasets to ensure the findings are broadly applicable, and their analysis of the trade-offs between parameter efficiency, task performance, and inference latency is particularly insightful.
One potential limitation of the study is the reliance on a fixed set of PEFT methods, as there may be other techniques or architectural variations that could further improve the efficiency-performance trade-off. Additionally, the study does not delve deeply into the underlying mechanisms or theoretical foundations of the PEFT methods, which could provide further insights into their strengths and weaknesses.
It would also be valuable to see the researchers explore the impact of different model architectures, pretraining datasets, and task-specific fine-tuning approaches on the PEFT performance. This could help practitioners better understand how to optimize the PEFT process for their specific use cases.
Overall, this paper makes a significant contribution to the understanding of parameter-efficient fine-tuning for multimodal large language models. The findings and recommendations provide a solid foundation for further research and practical applications in this rapidly evolving field.
Conclusion
This comprehensive empirical study on parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) techniques for multimodal large language models offers valuable insights for practitioners and researchers alike. The researchers' careful evaluation of various PEFT methods across a diverse range of tasks demonstrates the potential for these techniques to dramatically reduce the computational and data requirements for adapting powerful LLMs to new applications, while still maintaining competitive task performance.
The key takeaways from this work include the importance of considering the trade-offs between parameter efficiency, task performance, and inference latency when selecting a PEFT approach, as well as the need to tailor the fine-tuning process to the specific requirements of the target task and dataset. By providing a detailed empirical analysis and practical recommendations, this paper lays the groundwork for more widespread adoption of PEFT methods in real-world applications of multimodal large language models.
As the field of AI continues to evolve rapidly, research like this that explores techniques for making powerful models more accessible and efficient will be crucial for expanding the use of these technologies in a wide range of domains and settings. The insights and findings presented in this paper represent an important step forward in realizing the full potential of multimodal large language models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Unlocking Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Low-Resource Language Translation
Tong Su, Xin Peng, Sarubi Thillainathan, David Guzm'an, Surangika Ranathunga, En-Shiun Annie Lee
0
0
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods are increasingly vital in adapting large-scale pre-trained language models for diverse tasks, offering a balance between adaptability and computational efficiency. They are important in Low-Resource Language (LRL) Neural Machine Translation (NMT) to enhance translation accuracy with minimal resources. However, their practical effectiveness varies significantly across different languages. We conducted comprehensive empirical experiments with varying LRL domains and sizes to evaluate the performance of 8 PEFT methods with in total of 15 architectures using the SacreBLEU score. We showed that 6 PEFT architectures outperform the baseline for both in-domain and out-domain tests and the Houlsby+Inversion adapter has the best performance overall, proving the effectiveness of PEFT methods.
4/8/2024
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Large Models: A Comprehensive Survey
Zeyu Han, Chao Gao, Jinyang Liu, Jeff Zhang, Sai Qian Zhang
0
0
Large models represent a groundbreaking advancement in multiple application fields, enabling remarkable achievements across various tasks. However, their unprecedented scale comes with significant computational costs. These models, often consisting of billions of parameters, require vast amounts of computational resources for execution. Especially, the expansive scale and computational demands pose considerable challenges when customizing them for particular downstream tasks, particularly over the hardware platforms constrained by computational capabilities. Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) provides a practical solution by efficiently adapt the large models over the various downstream tasks. In particular, PEFT refers to the process of adjusting the parameters of a pre-trained large models to adapt it to a specific task while minimizing the number of additional parameters introduced or computational resources required. This approach is particularly important when dealing with large language models with high parameter counts, as fine-tuning these models from scratch can be computationally expensive and resource-intensive, posing considerable challenges in the supporting system platform design. In this survey, we present comprehensive studies of various PEFT algorithms, examining their performance and computational overhead. Moreover, we provide an overview of applications developed using different PEFT algorithms and discuss common techniques employed to mitigate computation costs for PEFT. In addition to the algorithmic perspective, we overview various real-world system designs to investigate the implementation costs associated with different PEFT algorithms. This survey serves as an indispensable resource for researchers aiming to understand both the PEFT algorithm and its system implementation, offering detailed insights into recent advancements and practical applications.
4/30/2024
💬
Empirical Studies of Parameter Efficient Methods for Large Language Models of Code and Knowledge Transfer to R
Amirreza Esmaeili, Iman Saberi, Fatemeh H. Fard
0
0
Recently, Large Langauge Models (LLMs) have gained a lot of attention in the Software Engineering (SE) community. LLMs or their variants pre-trained on code are used for many SE tasks. A main approach for adapting LLMs to the downstream task is to fine-tune the models. However, with having billions-parameters-LLMs, fine-tuning the models is not practical. An alternative approach is using Parameter Efficient Fine Tuning (PEFT), in which the model parameters are frozen and only a few added parameters are trained. Though the LLMs are used for programming languages such as Python and Java widely, their capability for low-resource languages is limited. In this work, we empirically study PEFT methods, LoRA and Compacter, on CodeT5 and CodeLlama. We will assess their performance compared to fully fine-tuned models, whether they can be used for knowledge transfer from natural language models to code (using T5 and Llama models), and their ability to adapt the learned knowledge to an unseen language. For the unseen language, we aim to study R, as it has a wide community. The adaptability with less computational costs makes LLMs accessible in scenarios where heavy computational resources are not available. Moreover, studying R opens new opportunities for using LLMs for other languages. We anticipate our findings to showcase the capabilities of PEFT for code LLMs for R and reveal the improvement areas.
5/6/2024
Light-PEFT: Lightening Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning via Early Pruning
Naibin Gu, Peng Fu, Xiyu Liu, Bowen Shen, Zheng Lin, Weiping Wang
0
0
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) has emerged as the predominant technique for fine-tuning in the era of large language models. However, existing PEFT methods still have inadequate training efficiency. Firstly, the utilization of large-scale foundation models during the training process is excessively redundant for certain fine-tuning tasks. Secondly, as the model size increases, the growth in trainable parameters of empirically added PEFT modules becomes non-negligible and redundant, leading to inefficiency. To achieve task-specific efficient fine-tuning, we propose the Light-PEFT framework, which includes two methods: Masked Early Pruning of the Foundation Model and Multi-Granularity Early Pruning of PEFT. The Light-PEFT framework allows for the simultaneous estimation of redundant parameters in both the foundation model and PEFT modules during the early stage of training. These parameters can then be pruned for more efficient fine-tuning. We validate our approach on GLUE, SuperGLUE, QA tasks, and various models. With Light-PEFT, parameters of the foundation model can be pruned by up to over 40%, while still controlling trainable parameters to be only 25% of the original PEFT method. Compared to utilizing the PEFT method directly, Light-PEFT achieves training and inference speedup, reduces memory usage, and maintains comparable performance and the plug-and-play feature of PEFT.
6/7/2024