Enhancing Document-level Argument Extraction with Definition-augmented Heuristic-driven Prompting for LLMs

Overview

• This paper explores enhancing document-level argument extraction using large language models (LLMs) by incorporating definition-based prompting.
• The researchers propose a heuristic-driven prompting approach that leverages definitions to guide LLMs in extracting key arguments from documents.
• The goal is to improve the performance of LLMs on document-level argument extraction tasks.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses a method to help AI systems better understand and extract the key arguments made in longer documents, such as research papers or news articles.

The researchers found that providing the AI system with clear definitions of important concepts can improve its ability to identify the main arguments being presented. By incorporating these definition-based "prompts" into the AI's training, the researchers were able to enhance the system's performance on document-level argument extraction tasks.

The key idea is that the definitions help the AI system understand the meaning and significance of the different elements within the document, allowing it to better identify the core arguments being made. This approach aims to make AI systems more effective at summarizing the main points and reasoning presented in lengthy, complex texts.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a heuristic-driven prompting approach to enhance document-level argument extraction using large language models (LLMs). The proposed method leverages definition-augmented prompting to guide the LLM in identifying the key arguments within a given document.

The researchers first define a set of heuristics, or rules, based on linguistic and structural cues, to identify potential argument components in the text. These include indicators like the presence of modal verbs, discourse markers, and topic sentences.

The heuristics are then used to generate definition-based prompts that are provided to the LLM, along with the document text, during the extraction process. The prompts inform the LLM about the meaning and importance of the identified argument components, helping it better comprehend the overall argumentative structure of the document.

The researchers evaluate their approach on several document-level argument extraction tasks and find that the definition-augmented prompting leads to significant performance improvements compared to baseline LLM models without the heuristic-driven prompting.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to enhancing the document-level argument extraction capabilities of large language models. The use of heuristic-driven, definition-based prompts is a creative way to leverage linguistic and structural cues to guide the LLM's understanding of the argumentative structure within a text.

One potential limitation of the approach is that the heuristics used to identify argument components may not be fully generalizable or accurate across all types of documents and domains. The researchers acknowledge this and suggest that further refinement of the heuristics, or the incorporation of more advanced, context-sensitive techniques, could improve the robustness of the method.

Additionally, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the types of errors or limitations encountered by the LLM during the extraction process, which could help inform future improvements to the approach. Exploring the integration of the definition-augmented prompting with other advanced techniques, such as few-shot learning or multi-task training, may also be a fruitful area for further research.

Conclusion

This paper presents an innovative approach to enhancing the document-level argument extraction capabilities of large language models. By incorporating definition-based, heuristic-driven prompting, the researchers demonstrate significant performance improvements on argument extraction tasks compared to baseline LLM models.

The proposed method represents an important step towards developing more effective AI systems for understanding and summarizing the key arguments and reasoning presented in complex, lengthy documents. As AI continues to play an increasingly important role in information processing and decision-making, advances in this area could have far-reaching implications for fields such as academic research, policy analysis, and journalism.