Enhancing Mutual Trustworthiness in Federated Learning for Data-Rich Smart Cities
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a framework for enhancing mutual trustworthiness in federated learning for smart cities.
- It combines game theory, reputation systems, and bootstrapping techniques to address issues of trust and incentives in federated learning.
- The proposed approach aims to foster collaboration and data sharing among IoT devices and service providers in data-rich smart city environments.
Plain English Explanation
Federated learning is a way for different devices or organizations to train machine learning models together without sharing their private data. This is useful for smart cities, where many devices like sensors and phones can contribute data to improve services. However, there are challenges around building trust and ensuring everyone benefits fairly.
This paper introduces a new framework to address these challenges. It uses game theory to model the interactions between devices and service providers, creating incentives for them to cooperate and share data. The framework also includes a reputation system to track the trustworthiness of participants over time. By combining these techniques with "bootstrapping" methods, the framework helps new participants build trust and get involved, even if they don't have much data at first.
The goal is to foster a collaborative environment in smart cities, where devices and services can work together efficiently and securely to improve things like traffic management, environmental monitoring, and emergency response. The framework aims to ensure that everyone who contributes data or computing power to the federated learning system is rewarded fairly.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a framework called "Enhancing Mutual Trustworthiness in Federated Learning for Data-Rich Smart Cities" that combines game theory, reputation systems, and bootstrapping techniques to address trust and incentive challenges in federated learning for smart city applications.
The framework models the interactions between IoT devices and service providers as a non-cooperative game, where each participant aims to maximize its own utility. It defines payoff functions that incentivize devices to truthfully report data and service providers to train accurate models and provide fair rewards. A reputation system tracks the trustworthiness of participants over time, which influences their future payoffs.
To onboard new participants, the framework incorporates bootstrapping techniques that allow devices with limited data to still contribute and build trust. This includes mechanisms for service providers to offer initial rewards and for devices to demonstrate their value through simulated interactions.
The authors evaluate their framework through theoretical analysis and simulations, demonstrating its ability to enhance mutual trustworthiness, promote data sharing, and improve the performance of federated learning models in smart city scenarios. They also discuss potential limitations, such as the need for a central authority to manage the reputation system.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a comprehensive framework that addresses important challenges in applying federated learning to data-rich smart city environments. By incorporating game theory, reputation systems, and bootstrapping, the authors have developed a thoughtful approach to fostering trust and collaboration among diverse participants.
One potential limitation discussed in the paper is the need for a central authority to manage the reputation system. This could raise concerns about a single point of failure or centralized control. The authors mention that decentralized alternatives, such as blockchain-based systems, may be an area for future research.
Another consideration is the potential for gaming or manipulation of the reputation system. While the authors have designed incentive structures to discourage such behavior, it would be important to thoroughly evaluate the resilience of the system to adversarial attacks or strategic exploitation.
Additionally, the paper focuses on the technical aspects of the framework, but does not delve deeply into the broader societal implications or ethical considerations of federated learning in smart city contexts. Issues around data privacy, algorithmic bias, and the equitable distribution of benefits should be carefully examined as this technology matures.
Overall, the proposed framework represents a valuable contribution to the field of federated learning, with the potential to enable more trustworthy and effective collaboration in data-rich smart city environments. Further research and real-world deployments will be crucial to refining and validating the approach.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel framework for enhancing mutual trustworthiness in federated learning for smart cities. By combining game theory, reputation systems, and bootstrapping techniques, the framework addresses key challenges around trust, incentives, and collaboration among IoT devices and service providers.
The framework's ability to foster a collaborative environment and ensure fair rewards for data contributors could significantly improve the performance and adoption of federated learning in smart city applications. This has the potential to unlock a wide range of benefits, such as better traffic management, environmental monitoring, and emergency response.
As the use of federated learning in smart cities continues to evolve, this research provides an important step forward in addressing the trust and incentive challenges that have hindered wider deployment. Further exploration of the framework's real-world implications and resilience to potential abuses will be crucial next steps.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Enhancing Mutual Trustworthiness in Federated Learning for Data-Rich Smart Cities
Osama Wehbi, Sarhad Arisdakessian, Mohsen Guizani, Omar Abdel Wahab, Azzam Mourad, Hadi Otrok, Hoda Al khzaimi, Bassem Ouni
Federated learning is a promising collaborative and privacy-preserving machine learning approach in data-rich smart cities. Nevertheless, the inherent heterogeneity of these urban environments presents a significant challenge in selecting trustworthy clients for collaborative model training. The usage of traditional approaches, such as the random client selection technique, poses several threats to the system's integrity due to the possibility of malicious client selection. Primarily, the existing literature focuses on assessing the trustworthiness of clients, neglecting the crucial aspect of trust in federated servers. To bridge this gap, in this work, we propose a novel framework that addresses the mutual trustworthiness in federated learning by considering the trust needs of both the client and the server. Our approach entails: (1) Creating preference functions for servers and clients, allowing them to rank each other based on trust scores, (2) Establishing a reputation-based recommendation system leveraging multiple clients to assess newly connected servers, (3) Assigning credibility scores to recommending devices for better server trustworthiness measurement, (4) Developing a trust assessment mechanism for smart devices using a statistical Interquartile Range (IQR) method, (5) Designing intelligent matching algorithms considering the preferences of both parties. Based on simulation and experimental results, our approach outperforms baseline methods by increasing trust levels, global model accuracy, and reducing non-trustworthy clients in the system.
Read more5/2/2024
0
Proximity-based Self-Federated Learning
Davide Domini, Gianluca Aguzzi, Nicolas Farabegoli, Mirko Viroli, Lukas Esterle
In recent advancements in machine learning, federated learning allows a network of distributed clients to collaboratively develop a global model without needing to share their local data. This technique aims to safeguard privacy, countering the vulnerabilities of conventional centralized learning methods. Traditional federated learning approaches often rely on a central server to coordinate model training across clients, aiming to replicate the same model uniformly across all nodes. However, these methods overlook the significance of geographical and local data variances in vast networks, potentially affecting model effectiveness and applicability. Moreover, relying on a central server might become a bottleneck in large networks, such as the ones promoted by edge computing. Our paper introduces a novel, fully-distributed federated learning strategy called proximity-based self-federated learning that enables the self-organised creation of multiple federations of clients based on their geographic proximity and data distribution without exchanging raw data. Indeed, unlike traditional algorithms, our approach encourages clients to share and adjust their models with neighbouring nodes based on geographic proximity and model accuracy. This method not only addresses the limitations posed by diverse data distributions but also enhances the model's adaptability to different regional characteristics creating specialized models for each federation. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach through simulations on well-known datasets, showcasing its effectiveness over the conventional centralized federated learning framework.
Read more7/18/2024
0
Fed-Credit: Robust Federated Learning with Credibility Management
Jiayan Chen, Zhirong Qian, Tianhui Meng, Xitong Gao, Tian Wang, Weijia Jia
Aiming at privacy preservation, Federated Learning (FL) is an emerging machine learning approach enabling model training on decentralized devices or data sources. The learning mechanism of FL relies on aggregating parameter updates from individual clients. However, this process may pose a potential security risk due to the presence of malicious devices. Existing solutions are either costly due to the use of compute-intensive technology, or restrictive for reasons of strong assumptions such as the prior knowledge of the number of attackers and how they attack. Few methods consider both privacy constraints and uncertain attack scenarios. In this paper, we propose a robust FL approach based on the credibility management scheme, called Fed-Credit. Unlike previous studies, our approach does not require prior knowledge of the nodes and the data distribution. It maintains and employs a credibility set, which weighs the historical clients' contributions based on the similarity between the local models and global model, to adjust the global model update. The subtlety of Fed-Credit is that the time decay and attitudinal value factor are incorporated into the dynamic adjustment of the reputation weights and it boasts a computational complexity of O(n) (n is the number of the clients). We conducted extensive experiments on the MNIST and CIFAR-10 datasets under 5 types of attacks. The results exhibit superior accuracy and resilience against adversarial attacks, all while maintaining comparatively low computational complexity. Among these, on the Non-IID CIFAR-10 dataset, our algorithm exhibited performance enhancements of 19.5% and 14.5%, respectively, in comparison to the state-of-the-art algorithm when dealing with two types of data poisoning attacks.
Read more5/21/2024
0
From Optimization to Generalization: Fair Federated Learning against Quality Shift via Inter-Client Sharpness Matching
Nannan Wu, Zhuo Kuang, Zengqiang Yan, Li Yu
Due to escalating privacy concerns, federated learning has been recognized as a vital approach for training deep neural networks with decentralized medical data. In practice, it is challenging to ensure consistent imaging quality across various institutions, often attributed to equipment malfunctions affecting a minority of clients. This imbalance in image quality can cause the federated model to develop an inherent bias towards higher-quality images, thus posing a severe fairness issue. In this study, we pioneer the identification and formulation of this new fairness challenge within the context of the imaging quality shift. Traditional methods for promoting fairness in federated learning predominantly focus on balancing empirical risks across diverse client distributions. This strategy primarily facilitates fair optimization across different training data distributions, yet neglects the crucial aspect of generalization. To address this, we introduce a solution termed Federated learning with Inter-client Sharpness Matching (FedISM). FedISM enhances both local training and global aggregation by incorporating sharpness-awareness, aiming to harmonize the sharpness levels across clients for fair generalization. Our empirical evaluations, conducted using the widely-used ICH and ISIC 2019 datasets, establish FedISM's superiority over current state-of-the-art federated learning methods in promoting fairness. Code is available at https://github.com/wnn2000/FFL4MIA.
Read more4/30/2024