Enhancing Social Decision-Making of Autonomous Vehicles: A Mixed-Strategy Game Approach With Interaction Orientation Identification

2312.11843

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/5/2024 by Jiaqi Liu, Xiao Qi, Peng Hang, Jian Sun
Enhancing Social Decision-Making of Autonomous Vehicles: A Mixed-Strategy Game Approach With Interaction Orientation Identification

Abstract

The integration of Autonomous Vehicles (AVs) into existing human-driven traffic systems poses considerable challenges, especially within environments where human and machine interactions are frequent and complex, such as at unsignalized intersections. To deal with these challenges, we introduce a novel framework predicated on dynamic and socially-aware decision-making game theory to augment the social decision-making prowess of AVs in mixed driving environments. This comprehensive framework is delineated into three primary modules: Interaction Orientation Identification, Mixed-Strategy Game Modeling, and Expert Mode Learning. We introduce 'Interaction Orientation' as a metric to evaluate the social decision-making tendencies of various agents, incorporating both environmental factors and trajectory characteristics. The mixed-strategy game model developed as part of this framework considers the evolution of future traffic scenarios and includes a utility function that balances safety, operational efficiency, and the unpredictability of environmental conditions. To adapt to real-world driving complexities, our framework utilizes a dynamic optimization framework for assimilating and learning from expert human driving strategies. These strategies are compiled into a comprehensive strategy library, serving as a reference for future decision-making processes. The proposed approach is validated through extensive driving datasets and human-in-loop driving experiments, and the results demonstrate marked enhancements in decision timing and precision.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper proposes a mixed-strategy game approach to enhance the social decision-making of autonomous vehicles (AVs).
  • The approach incorporates an interaction orientation identification (IOI) module to better understand the intentions and behaviors of other vehicles.
  • The goal is to improve the safety and efficiency of AVs in mixed traffic environments.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at how autonomous vehicles (AVs) can make better decisions when driving in mixed traffic, where they need to interact with both other AVs and human-driven vehicles. The researchers use a game theory approach to model these interactions, where the AV and the other vehicles are considered as "players" in a game.

The key idea is that the AV should not just focus on its own goals, like reaching its destination quickly. It also needs to consider the goals and behaviors of the other vehicles around it. The Interaction-Aware Vehicle Motion Planning for Collision Avoidance and Towards Scalable and Efficient Interaction-Aware Planning for Autonomous Vehicles papers discuss similar approaches for this.

To do this, the AV uses an "interaction orientation identification" (IOI) module to try to understand what the other vehicles are trying to do. This helps the AV anticipate their behavior and make better decisions about how to interact with them. For example, the AV might realize that a human-driven car is about to cut it off, and adjust its behavior accordingly.

The researchers tested this approach in simulations, and found that it led to safer and more efficient driving by the AVs, compared to other decision-making strategies. This suggests that incorporating this kind of "social awareness" into AV decision-making could be an important step towards making them better able to navigate complex traffic situations.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a mixed-strategy game approach to enhance the social decision-making of autonomous vehicles (AVs) in mixed traffic environments. The key components are:

  1. A mixed-strategy game formulation: The interactions between the AV and other vehicles are modeled as a game, where each "player" (vehicle) has its own objectives and strategies.
  2. An interaction orientation identification (IOI) module: This allows the AV to estimate the intentions and behaviors of other vehicles, enabling it to anticipate their actions.
  3. A decision-making framework: The AV uses the game model and IOI module to decide on its optimal actions, balancing its own goals with consideration for the other vehicles.

The researchers evaluated this approach in simulation, comparing it to other decision-making strategies for AVs. They found that the mixed-strategy game approach with IOI led to safer and more efficient driving, with the AV better able to navigate complex traffic situations while accounting for the behaviors of other vehicles.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach for improving the social decision-making of AVs. The use of game theory and the interaction orientation identification module are interesting ideas that could help AVs better navigate mixed traffic environments.

However, the paper does not fully address some potential limitations and concerns. For example, the simulation environment may not fully capture the complexity of real-world traffic situations, and the accuracy of the IOI module in predicting human driver behavior is not thoroughly evaluated.

Additionally, the game-theoretic approach relies on certain assumptions, such as the ability to accurately model the objectives and strategies of other vehicles. In reality, human drivers may not behave in a strictly rational or predictable manner, which could pose challenges for this approach.

Further research and real-world testing would be needed to better understand the practical implications and limitations of this approach. Incorporating low-cost frameworks for decentralized autonomous intersection management could also be an interesting area for exploration.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel mixed-strategy game approach to enhance the social decision-making of autonomous vehicles in mixed traffic environments. By incorporating an interaction orientation identification module, the AV can better understand the intentions and behaviors of other vehicles, allowing it to make more informed and socially-aware decisions.

The results from the simulation experiments suggest that this approach can lead to safer and more efficient driving by AVs, which could have important implications for the deployment of autonomous vehicles in the real world. However, further research and real-world testing is needed to fully understand the limitations and practical applicability of this approach.

Overall, the paper contributes to the ongoing efforts to improve the safety of mixed traffic environments through the development of more socially-intelligent autonomous vehicles.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

🤷

GTP-UDrive: Unified Game-Theoretic Trajectory Planner and Decision-Maker for Autonomous Driving in Mixed Traffic Environments

Nouhed Naidja (L2S, VeDeCom), Guillaume Sandou (L2S), St'ephane Font (L2S), Marc Revilloud

YC

0

Reddit

0

Understanding the interdependence between autonomous and human-operated vehicles remains an ongoing challenge, with significant implications for the safety and feasibility of autonomous driving.This interdependence arises from inherent interactions among road users.Thus, it is crucial for Autonomous Vehicles (AVs) to understand and analyze the intentions of human-driven vehicles, and to display behavior comprehensible to other traffic participants.To this end, this paper presents GTP-UDRIVE, a unified game-theoretic trajectory planner and decision-maker considering a mixed-traffic environment. Our model considers the intentions of other vehicles in the decision-making process and provides the AV with a human-like trajectory, based on the clothoid interpolation technique.% This study investigates a solver based on Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) that quickly converges to an optimal decision.Among highly interactive traffic scenarios, the intersection crossing is particularly challenging. Hence, we choose to demonstrate the feasibility and effectiveness of our method in real traffic conditions, using an experimental autonomous vehicle at an unsignalized intersection. Testing results reveal that our approach is suitable for 1) Making decisions and generating trajectories simultaneously. 2) Describing the vehicle's trajectory as a piecewise clothoid and enforcing geometric constraints. 3) Reducing search space dimensionality for the trajectory optimization problem.

Read more

6/21/2024

Human-Machine Interaction in Automated Vehicles: Reducing Voluntary Driver Intervention

Human-Machine Interaction in Automated Vehicles: Reducing Voluntary Driver Intervention

Xinzhi Zhong, Yang Zhou, Varshini Kamaraj, Zhenhao Zhou, Wissam Kontar, Dan Negrut, John D. Lee, Soyoung Ahn

YC

0

Reddit

0

This paper develops a novel car-following control method to reduce voluntary driver interventions and improve traffic stability in Automated Vehicles (AVs). Through a combination of experimental and empirical analysis, we show how voluntary driver interventions can instigate substantial traffic disturbances that are amplified along the traffic upstream. Motivated by these findings, we present a framework for driver intervention based on evidence accumulation (EA), which describes the evolution of the driver's distrust in automation, ultimately resulting in intervention. Informed through the EA framework, we propose a deep reinforcement learning (DRL)-based car-following control for AVs that is strategically designed to mitigate unnecessary driver intervention and improve traffic stability. Numerical experiments are conducted to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed control model.

Read more

4/10/2024

Enhancing Safety in Mixed Traffic: Learning-Based Modeling and Efficient Control of Autonomous and Human-Driven Vehicles

Enhancing Safety in Mixed Traffic: Learning-Based Modeling and Efficient Control of Autonomous and Human-Driven Vehicles

Jie Wang, Yash Vardhan Pant, Lei Zhao, Micha{l} Antkiewicz, Krzysztof Czarnecki

YC

0

Reddit

0

With the increasing presence of autonomous vehicles (AVs) on public roads, developing robust control strategies to navigate the uncertainty of human-driven vehicles (HVs) is crucial. This paper introduces an advanced method for modeling HV behavior, combining a first-principles model with Gaussian process (GP) learning to enhance velocity prediction accuracy and provide a measurable uncertainty. We validated this innovative HV model using real-world data from field experiments and applied it to develop a GP-enhanced model predictive control (GP-MPC) strategy. This strategy aims to improve safety in mixed vehicle platoons by integrating uncertainty assessment into distance constraints. Comparative simulation studies with a conventional model predictive control (MPC) approach demonstrated that our GP-MPC strategy ensures more reliable safe distancing and fosters efficient vehicular dynamics, achieving notably higher speeds within the platoon. By incorporating a sparse GP technique in HV modeling and adopting a dynamic GP prediction within the MPC framework, we significantly reduced the computation time of GP-MPC, marking it only 4.6% higher than that of the conventional MPC. This represents a substantial improvement, making the process about 100 times faster than our preliminary work without these approximations. Our findings underscore the effectiveness of learning-based HV modeling in enhancing both safety and operational efficiency in mixed-traffic environments, paving the way for more harmonious AV-HV interactions.

Read more

4/11/2024

↗️

Comprehensive Autonomous Vehicle Optimal Routing With Dynamic Heuristics

Ragav V, Jesher Joshua M, Syed Ibrahim S P

YC

0

Reddit

0

Auto manufacturers and research groups are working on autonomous driving for long period and achieved significant progress. Autonomous vehicles (AV) are expected to transform road traffic reduction from current conditions, avoiding accidents and congestion. As the implementation of an autonomous vehicle ecosystem includes complex automotive technology, ethics, passenger behaviour, traffic management policies and liability etc., the maturity of AV solutions are still evolving. The proposed model to improve AV user experience, uses a hybrid AV Network of multiple connected autonomous vehicles which communicate with each other in an environment shared by human driven vehicles. The proposed Optimal AV Network (OAVN) solution provides better coordination and optimization of autonomous vehicles, improved Transportation efficiency, improved passenger comfort and safety, real-time dynamic adaption of traffic & road conditions along with improved in-cabin assistance with inputs from various sensors. The true optimal solution for this problem, is to devise an automated guidance system for vehicles in an AV network, to reach destinations in best possible routes along with passenger comfort and safety. A custom informed search model is proposed along with other heuristic goals for better user experience. The results are analysed and compared to evaluate the effectiveness of the solution and identify gaps and future enhancements.

Read more

5/28/2024