Human-Machine Interaction in Automated Vehicles: Reducing Voluntary Driver Intervention
2404.05832
0
0
Abstract
This paper develops a novel car-following control method to reduce voluntary driver interventions and improve traffic stability in Automated Vehicles (AVs). Through a combination of experimental and empirical analysis, we show how voluntary driver interventions can instigate substantial traffic disturbances that are amplified along the traffic upstream. Motivated by these findings, we present a framework for driver intervention based on evidence accumulation (EA), which describes the evolution of the driver's distrust in automation, ultimately resulting in intervention. Informed through the EA framework, we propose a deep reinforcement learning (DRL)-based car-following control for AVs that is strategically designed to mitigate unnecessary driver intervention and improve traffic stability. Numerical experiments are conducted to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed control model.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the issue of voluntary driver intervention in automated vehicles and its impact on traffic flow.
- The researchers use evidence accumulation modeling to understand how drivers decide to intervene and the resulting effects on traffic patterns.
- The findings provide insights into reducing unnecessary driver interventions, which can help improve the efficiency and safety of automated vehicle systems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at what happens when drivers of automated vehicles choose to take control of the vehicle, even when the automation is working properly. When drivers do this voluntarily, it can disrupt the flow of traffic and reduce the benefits of having automated vehicles on the road.
The researchers used a specific type of mathematical model, called evidence accumulation modeling, to study how drivers make the decision to intervene. This model helps explain the psychological factors that influence a driver's choice to take over from the automated system.
By understanding these decision-making processes, the researchers hope to find ways to reduce unnecessary driver interventions. This could lead to smoother, more efficient traffic patterns and help realize the full potential of automated vehicle technology. The goal is to have the automation work reliably enough that drivers feel comfortable letting it handle the driving most of the time.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents an evidence accumulation modeling approach to analyze the decision-making process behind voluntary driver interventions in automated vehicles. This builds on previous research on learning-based modeling of human-autonomous vehicle interaction and interaction-aware vehicle motion planning for collision avoidance.
The researchers conducted experiments to collect data on driver interventions in a simulated automated driving environment. They then used an evidence accumulation model to characterize how drivers accumulate evidence over time to decide whether to take control of the vehicle. The model captures factors like the driver's confidence in the automation, their risk tolerance, and the perceived urgency of the situation.
By analyzing the model parameters, the researchers were able to identify patterns in when and why drivers choose to intervene. The findings suggest opportunities to improve the safety of mixed traffic through learning-based models and enhance social decision-making in autonomous vehicles to better anticipate and accommodate driver behavior.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a detailed and well-designed study on a important issue for the adoption of automated vehicle technology. The evidence accumulation modeling approach offers a rigorous framework for understanding the psychological factors behind driver intervention decisions.
However, the study is limited to a simulated driving environment, which may not fully capture the complexity and variability of real-world driving conditions. There is an opportunity for further research using AI-augmented automation in real driving prediction and industrial applications to validate and expand upon the findings.
Additionally, the paper acknowledges that the model does not account for all possible influences on driver behavior, such as individual differences, environmental factors, and the evolving nature of trust in automation. Incorporating a more comprehensive set of variables could lead to richer insights and more robust solutions.
Conclusion
This paper makes an important contribution to the understanding of voluntary driver interventions in automated vehicles and their impact on traffic flow. The evidence accumulation modeling approach provides a strong theoretical foundation for analyzing driver decision-making and identifying opportunities to reduce unnecessary interventions.
By addressing this issue, the research helps pave the way for more seamless integration of automated vehicles into the transportation system, ultimately enhancing safety, efficiency, and the user experience. As autonomous driving technology continues to evolve, studies like this will be crucial for unlocking the full potential of this transformative innovation.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Enhancing Safety in Mixed Traffic: Learning-Based Modeling and Efficient Control of Autonomous and Human-Driven Vehicles
Jie Wang, Yash Vardhan Pant, Lei Zhao, Micha{l} Antkiewicz, Krzysztof Czarnecki
0
0
With the increasing presence of autonomous vehicles (AVs) on public roads, developing robust control strategies to navigate the uncertainty of human-driven vehicles (HVs) is crucial. This paper introduces an advanced method for modeling HV behavior, combining a first-principles model with Gaussian process (GP) learning to enhance velocity prediction accuracy and provide a measurable uncertainty. We validated this innovative HV model using real-world data from field experiments and applied it to develop a GP-enhanced model predictive control (GP-MPC) strategy. This strategy aims to improve safety in mixed vehicle platoons by integrating uncertainty assessment into distance constraints. Comparative simulation studies with a conventional model predictive control (MPC) approach demonstrated that our GP-MPC strategy ensures more reliable safe distancing and fosters efficient vehicular dynamics, achieving notably higher speeds within the platoon. By incorporating a sparse GP technique in HV modeling and adopting a dynamic GP prediction within the MPC framework, we significantly reduced the computation time of GP-MPC, marking it only 4.6% higher than that of the conventional MPC. This represents a substantial improvement, making the process about 100 times faster than our preliminary work without these approximations. Our findings underscore the effectiveness of learning-based HV modeling in enhancing both safety and operational efficiency in mixed-traffic environments, paving the way for more harmonious AV-HV interactions.
4/11/2024
📈
Improving safety in mixed traffic: A learning-based model predictive control for autonomous and human-driven vehicle platooning
Jie Wang, Zhihao Jiang, Yash Vardhan Pant
0
0
As autonomous vehicles (AVs) become more common on public roads, their interaction with human-driven vehicles (HVs) in mixed traffic is inevitable. This requires new control strategies for AVs to handle the unpredictable nature of HVs. This study focused on safe control in mixed-vehicle platoons consisting of both AVs and HVs, particularly during longitudinal car-following scenarios. We introduce a novel model that combines a conventional first-principles model with a Gaussian process (GP) machine learning-based model to better predict HV behavior. Our results showed a significant improvement in predicting HV speed, with a 35.64% reduction in the root mean square error compared with the use of the first-principles model alone. We developed a new control strategy called GP-MPC, which uses the proposed HV model for safer distance management between vehicles in the mixed platoon. The GP-MPC strategy effectively utilizes the capacity of the GP model to assess uncertainties, thereby significantly enhancing safety in challenging traffic scenarios, such as emergency braking scenarios. In simulations, the GP-MPC strategy outperformed the baseline MPC method, offering better safety and more efficient vehicle movement in mixed traffic.
4/3/2024
Autonomous vehicle decision and control through reinforcement learning with traffic flow randomization
Yuan Lin, Antai Xie, Xiao Liu
0
0
Most of the current studies on autonomous vehicle decision-making and control tasks based on reinforcement learning are conducted in simulated environments. The training and testing of these studies are carried out under rule-based microscopic traffic flow, with little consideration of migrating them to real or near-real environments to test their performance. It may lead to a degradation in performance when the trained model is tested in more realistic traffic scenes. In this study, we propose a method to randomize the driving style and behavior of surrounding vehicles by randomizing certain parameters of the car-following model and the lane-changing model of rule-based microscopic traffic flow in SUMO. We trained policies with deep reinforcement learning algorithms under the domain randomized rule-based microscopic traffic flow in freeway and merging scenes, and then tested them separately in rule-based microscopic traffic flow and high-fidelity microscopic traffic flow. Results indicate that the policy trained under domain randomization traffic flow has significantly better success rate and calculative reward compared to the models trained under other microscopic traffic flows.
4/22/2024
Deep Reinforcement Learning for Advanced Longitudinal Control and Collision Avoidance in High-Risk Driving Scenarios
Dianwei Chen, Yaobang Gong, Xianfeng Yang
0
0
Existing Advanced Driver Assistance Systems primarily focus on the vehicle directly ahead, often overlooking potential risks from following vehicles. This oversight can lead to ineffective handling of high risk situations, such as high speed, closely spaced, multi vehicle scenarios where emergency braking by one vehicle might trigger a pile up collision. To overcome these limitations, this study introduces a novel deep reinforcement learning based algorithm for longitudinal control and collision avoidance. This proposed algorithm effectively considers the behavior of both leading and following vehicles. Its implementation in simulated high risk scenarios, which involve emergency braking in dense traffic where traditional systems typically fail, has demonstrated the algorithm ability to prevent potential pile up collisions, including those involving heavy duty vehicles.
5/1/2024