Enhancing Trustworthiness and Minimising Bias Issues in Leveraging Social Media Data for Disaster Management Response
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Explores ways to enhance the trustworthiness and minimize bias issues when using social media data for disaster management response
- Focuses on improving the reliability and fairness of social media data analysis during emergency situations
- Discusses strategies to address challenges related to the veracity, representativeness, and fairness of social media data
Plain English Explanation
During disaster situations, emergency responders and officials often turn to social media data to understand the on-the-ground impacts and coordinate relief efforts. However, there are concerns about the trustworthiness and potential biases inherent in social media data. This paper investigates methods to enhance the reliability and fairness of using social media data for disaster management.
The researchers discuss strategies to address the challenges of verifying social media content, ensuring the data is representative of the affected population, and mitigating algorithmic biases. By improving the trustworthiness and minimizing biases in social media data analysis, emergency responders can make more informed decisions and deliver aid more effectively during crises.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a multi-faceted approach to enhancing the trustworthiness and minimizing bias issues when leveraging social media data for disaster management response.
First, the researchers discuss techniques for verifying the veracity of social media content, such as cross-checking with official sources and employing credibility assessment models. They also explore methods to ensure the data is representative of the affected population, including targeted data collection, demographic analysis, and bias correction techniques.
Additionally, the paper addresses the issue of algorithmic bias, which can arise from the underlying data or machine learning models used to analyze social media content. The researchers propose strategies to identify and mitigate these biases, such as fairness-aware model training, bias auditing, and the incorporation of human-in-the-loop approaches.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-rounded approach to enhancing the trustworthiness and minimizing bias issues in social media data for disaster management. However, the authors acknowledge that some challenges may still persist, such as the difficulty of verifying information in real-time and the potential for undiscovered biases in the data or algorithms.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the practical implementation of the proposed strategies, which may require further research and experimentation to validate their effectiveness in real-world disaster scenarios. There is also a need to explore the ethical implications of data collection and analysis during emergencies, and to ensure that the rights and privacy of affected individuals are protected.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive approach to enhancing the trustworthiness and minimizing bias issues in leveraging social media data for disaster management response. By addressing the challenges of content verification, data representativeness, and algorithmic fairness, the researchers aim to improve the reliability and effectiveness of social media-based decision-making during crises.
The strategies outlined in this paper have the potential to significantly enhance the utilization of social media data in disaster management, ultimately leading to more informed and equitable emergency response efforts. However, continued research and practical implementation will be necessary to fully realize the benefits of this approach.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Enhancing Trustworthiness and Minimising Bias Issues in Leveraging Social Media Data for Disaster Management Response
Samia Abid, Bhupesh Kumar Mishra, Dhavalkumar Thakker, Nishikant Mishra
Disaster events often unfold rapidly, necessitating a swift and effective response. Developing action plans, resource allocation, and resolution of help requests in disaster scenarios is time-consuming and complex since disaster-relevant information is often uncertain. Leveraging real-time data can significantly deal with data uncertainty and enhance disaster response efforts. To deal with real-time data uncertainty, social media appeared as an alternative effective source of real-time data as there has been extensive use of social media during and after the disasters. However, it also brings forth challenges regarding trustworthiness and bias in these data. To fully leverage social media data for disaster management, it becomes crucial to mitigate biases that may arise due to specific disaster types or regional contexts. Additionally, the presence of misinformation within social media data raises concerns about the reliability of data sources, potentially impeding actionable insights and leading to improper resource utilization. To overcome these challenges, our research aimed to investigate how to ensure trustworthiness and address biases in social media data. We aim to investigate and identify the factors that can be used to enhance trustworthiness and minimize bias to make an efficient and scalable disaster management system utilizing real-time social media posts, identify disaster-related keywords, and assess the severity of the disaster. By doing so, the integration of real-time social data can improve the speed and accuracy of disaster management systems
Read more9/4/2024
0
A Named Entity Recognition and Topic Modeling-based Solution for Locating and Better Assessment of Natural Disasters in Social Media
Ayaz Mehmood, Muhammad Tayyab Zamir, Muhammad Asif Ayub, Nasir Ahmad, Kashif Ahmad
Over the last decade, similar to other application domains, social media content has been proven very effective in disaster informatics. However, due to the unstructured nature of the data, several challenges are associated with disaster analysis in social media content. To fully explore the potential of social media content in disaster informatics, access to relevant content and the correct geo-location information is very critical. In this paper, we propose a three-step solution to tackling these challenges. Firstly, the proposed solution aims to classify social media posts into relevant and irrelevant posts followed by the automatic extraction of location information from the posts' text through Named Entity Recognition (NER) analysis. Finally, to quickly analyze the topics covered in large volumes of social media posts, we perform topic modeling resulting in a list of top keywords, that highlight the issues discussed in the tweet. For the Relevant Classification of Twitter Posts (RCTP), we proposed a merit-based fusion framework combining the capabilities of four different models namely BERT, RoBERTa, Distil BERT, and ALBERT obtaining the highest F1-score of 0.933 on a benchmark dataset. For the Location Extraction from Twitter Text (LETT), we evaluated four models namely BERT, RoBERTa, Distil BERTA, and Electra in an NER framework obtaining the highest F1-score of 0.960. For topic modeling, we used the BERTopic library to discover the hidden topic patterns in the relevant tweets. The experimental results of all the components of the proposed end-to-end solution are very encouraging and hint at the potential of social media content and NLP in disaster management.
Read more5/3/2024
💬
0
CrisisSense-LLM: Instruction Fine-Tuned Large Language Model for Multi-label Social Media Text Classification in Disaster Informatics
Kai Yin, Chengkai Liu, Ali Mostafavi, Xia Hu
In the field of crisis/disaster informatics, social media is increasingly being used for improving situational awareness to inform response and relief efforts. Efficient and accurate text classification tools have been a focal area of investigation in crisis informatics. However, current methods mostly rely on single-label text classification models, which fails to capture different insights embedded in dynamic and multifaceted disaster-related social media data. This study introduces a novel approach to disaster text classification by enhancing a pre-trained Large Language Model (LLM) through instruction fine-tuning targeted for multi-label classification of disaster-related tweets. Our methodology involves creating a comprehensive instruction dataset from disaster-related tweets, which is then used to fine-tune an open-source LLM, thereby embedding it with disaster-specific knowledge. This fine-tuned model can classify multiple aspects of disaster-related information simultaneously, such as the type of event, informativeness, and involvement of human aid, significantly improving the utility of social media data for situational awareness in disasters. The results demonstrate that this approach enhances the categorization of critical information from social media posts, thereby facilitating a more effective deployment for situational awareness during emergencies. This research paves the way for more advanced, adaptable, and robust disaster management tools, leveraging the capabilities of LLMs to improve real-time situational awareness and response strategies in disaster scenarios.
Read more6/26/2024
🗣️
0
Flood of Techniques and Drought of Theories: Emotion Mining in Disasters
Soheil Shapouri, Saber Soleymani, Saed Rezayi
Emotion mining has become a crucial tool for understanding human emotions during disasters, leveraging the extensive data generated on social media platforms. This paper aims to summarize existing research on emotion mining within disaster contexts, highlighting both significant discoveries and persistent issues. On the one hand, emotion mining techniques have achieved acceptable accuracy enabling applications such as rapid damage assessment and mental health surveillance. On the other hand, with many studies adopting data-driven approaches, several methodological issues remain. These include arbitrary emotion classification, ignoring biases inherent in data collection from social media, such as the overrepresentation of individuals from higher socioeconomic status on Twitter, and the lack of application of theoretical frameworks like cross-cultural comparisons. These problems can be summarized as a notable lack of theory-driven research and ignoring insights from social and behavioral sciences. This paper underscores the need for interdisciplinary collaboration between computer scientists and social scientists to develop more robust and theoretically grounded approaches in emotion mining. By addressing these gaps, we aim to enhance the effectiveness and reliability of emotion mining methodologies, ultimately contributing to improved disaster preparedness, response, and recovery. Keywords: emotion mining, sentiment analysis, natural disasters, psychology, technological disasters
Read more9/4/2024