Large Language Models Spot Phishing Emails with Surprising Accuracy: A Comparative Analysis of Performance
0
💬
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Phishing is a prevalent cybercrime tactic that continues to threaten individuals, businesses, and organizations in the digital age.
- Cybercriminals use sophisticated social engineering techniques and modern technology to exploit trust and security.
- This paper aims to analyze the effectiveness of 15 Large Language Models (LLMs) in detecting phishing emails, focusing on a set of 419 Scam emails.
- The experiment found that ChatGPT 3.5, GPT-3.5-Turbo-Instruct, and ChatGPT were the most effective models in detecting phishing emails.
Plain English Explanation
Phishing is a type of cybercrime where criminals try to trick people into revealing sensitive information, like passwords or financial details. They often disguise themselves as trusted sources, like a bank or a company, and use tactics like urgency, fear, and social pressure to get people to click on links or share information.
This research paper looked at how well 15 different AI models, called Large Language Models (LLMs), could detect phishing emails. The researchers tested the models on a set of 419 fake emails (known as "scam emails") to see which ones were best at identifying them as phishing attempts.
The results showed that ChatGPT 3.5, GPT-3.5-Turbo-Instruct, and ChatGPT were the most effective at detecting the phishing emails. These models were able to analyze the content and context of the emails to determine if they were legitimate or part of a scam.
Technical Explanation
The researchers in this paper explored the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) in identifying phishing emails. They tested 15 different LLM models, including ChatGPT 3.5, GPT-3.5-Turbo-Instruct, and ChatGPT, on a dataset of 419 scam emails.
The experiment was designed to evaluate the models' ability to accurately detect phishing attempts by analyzing the text content and metadata of the email samples. The researchers predefined a set of criteria to assess the emails and determine if they were phishing attempts.
The results showed that ChatGPT 3.5, GPT-3.5-Turbo-Instruct, and ChatGPT were the most effective in accurately identifying the phishing emails. These models were able to leverage their natural language understanding capabilities to effectively distinguish the characteristics of legitimate and phishing emails.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge some caveats and limitations in their study. The sample size of 419 emails, while substantial, may not be representative of the full range of phishing techniques used by cybercriminals. Additionally, the predefined criteria used to assess the emails may not capture all the nuances and evolving tactics employed in phishing attacks.
Further research could explore the performance of these LLMs on larger and more diverse datasets, as well as investigate the potential for using sequential deep learning models to detect phishing. Additionally, it would be valuable to understand the specific mechanisms and features these LLMs use to identify phishing attempts, as this could inform the development of more robust and adaptable anti-phishing solutions.
Conclusion
This research paper demonstrates the potential of Large Language Models, such as ChatGPT 3.5, GPT-3.5-Turbo-Instruct, and ChatGPT, in detecting phishing emails. By leveraging their natural language processing capabilities, these models can effectively identify the characteristics of phishing attempts, which can be a valuable tool in the ongoing fight against cybercrime.
As the threat of phishing continues to evolve, the insights from this study highlight the need for ongoing research and innovation in the field of cybersecurity. By exploring the capabilities of advanced AI models, researchers and practitioners can develop more effective strategies to protect individuals, businesses, and organizations from the damaging consequences of phishing attacks.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
0
Large Language Models Spot Phishing Emails with Surprising Accuracy: A Comparative Analysis of Performance
Het Patel, Umair Rehman, Farkhund Iqbal
Phishing, a prevalent cybercrime tactic for decades, remains a significant threat in today's digital world. By leveraging clever social engineering elements and modern technology, cybercrime targets many individuals, businesses, and organizations to exploit trust and security. These cyber-attackers are often disguised in many trustworthy forms to appear as legitimate sources. By cleverly using psychological elements like urgency, fear, social proof, and other manipulative strategies, phishers can lure individuals into revealing sensitive and personalized information. Building on this pervasive issue within modern technology, this paper aims to analyze the effectiveness of 15 Large Language Models (LLMs) in detecting phishing attempts, specifically focusing on a randomized set of 419 Scam emails. The objective is to determine which LLMs can accurately detect phishing emails by analyzing a text file containing email metadata based on predefined criteria. The experiment concluded that the following models, ChatGPT 3.5, GPT-3.5-Turbo-Instruct, and ChatGPT, were the most effective in detecting phishing emails.
Read more6/10/2024
0
Utilizing Large Language Models to Optimize the Detection and Explainability of Phishing Websites
Sayak Saha Roy, Shirin Nilizadeh
In this paper, we introduce PhishLang, an open-source, lightweight language model specifically designed for phishing website detection through contextual analysis of the website. Unlike traditional heuristic or machine learning models that rely on static features and struggle to adapt to new threats, and deep learning models that are computationally intensive, our model leverages MobileBERT, a fast and memory-efficient variant of the BERT architecture, to learn granular features characteristic of phishing attacks. PhishLang operates with minimal data preprocessing and offers performance comparable to leading deep learning anti-phishing tools, while being significantly faster and less resource-intensive. Over a 3.5-month testing period, PhishLang successfully identified 25,796 phishing URLs, many of which were undetected by popular antiphishing blocklists, thus demonstrating its potential to enhance current detection measures. Capitalizing on PhishLang's resource efficiency, we release the first open-source fully client-side Chromium browser extension that provides inference locally without requiring to consult an online blocklist and can be run on low-end systems with no impact on inference times. Our implementation not only outperforms prevalent (server-side) phishing tools, but is significantly more effective than the limited commercial client-side measures available. Furthermore, we study how PhishLang can be integrated with GPT-3.5 Turbo to create explainable blocklisting -- which, upon detection of a website, provides users with detailed contextual information about the features that led to a website being marked as phishing.
Read more9/11/2024
0
SecureNet: A Comparative Study of DeBERTa and Large Language Models for Phishing Detection
Sakshi Mahendru, Tejul Pandit
Phishing, whether through email, SMS, or malicious websites, poses a major threat to organizations by using social engineering to trick users into revealing sensitive information. It not only compromises company's data security but also incurs significant financial losses. In this paper, we investigate whether the remarkable performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) can be leveraged for particular task like text classification, particularly detecting malicious content and compare its results with state-of-the-art Deberta V3 (DeBERTa using ELECTRA-Style Pre-Training with Gradient-Disentangled Embedding Sharing) model. We systematically assess the potential and limitations of both approaches using comprehensive public datasets comprising diverse data sources such as email, HTML, URL, SMS, and synthetic data generation. Additionally, we demonstrate how LLMs can generate convincing phishing emails, making it harder to spot scams and evaluate the performance of both models in this context. Our study delves further into the challenges encountered by DeBERTa V3 during its training phases, fine-tuning methodology and transfer learning processes. Similarly, we examine the challenges associated with LLMs and assess their respective performance. Among our experimental approaches, the transformer-based DeBERTa method emerged as the most effective, achieving a test dataset (HuggingFace phishing dataset) recall (sensitivity) of 95.17% closely followed by GPT-4 providing a recall of 91.04%. We performed additional experiments with other datasets on the trained DeBERTa V3 model and LLMs like GPT 4 and Gemini 1.5. Based on our findings, we provide valuable insights into the effectiveness and robustness of these advanced language models, offering a detailed comparative analysis that can inform future research efforts in strengthening cybersecurity measures for detecting and mitigating phishing threats.
Read more6/12/2024
💬
0
Multimodal Large Language Models for Phishing Webpage Detection and Identification
Jehyun Lee, Peiyuan Lim, Bryan Hooi, Dinil Mon Divakaran
To address the challenging problem of detecting phishing webpages, researchers have developed numerous solutions, in particular those based on machine learning (ML) algorithms. Among these, brand-based phishing detection that uses models from Computer Vision to detect if a given webpage is imitating a well-known brand has received widespread attention. However, such models are costly and difficult to maintain, as they need to be retrained with labeled dataset that has to be regularly and continuously collected. Besides, they also need to maintain a good reference list of well-known websites and related meta-data for effective performance. In this work, we take steps to study the efficacy of large language models (LLMs), in particular the multimodal LLMs, in detecting phishing webpages. Given that the LLMs are pretrained on a large corpus of data, we aim to make use of their understanding of different aspects of a webpage (logo, theme, favicon, etc.) to identify the brand of a given webpage and compare the identified brand with the domain name in the URL to detect a phishing attack. We propose a two-phase system employing LLMs in both phases: the first phase focuses on brand identification, while the second verifies the domain. We carry out comprehensive evaluations on a newly collected dataset. Our experiments show that the LLM-based system achieves a high detection rate at high precision; importantly, it also provides interpretable evidence for the decisions. Our system also performs significantly better than a state-of-the-art brand-based phishing detection system while demonstrating robustness against two known adversarial attacks.
Read more8/13/2024