Evaluating the Explainable AI Method Grad-CAM for Breath Classification on Newborn Time Series Data
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper evaluates the use of Grad-CAM, an explainable AI (XAI) method, for classifying newborn respiratory patterns from time series data.
- The researchers investigate the reliability and interpretability of Grad-CAM's explanations for the model's predictions on this healthcare application.
- Key findings include insights into Grad-CAM's ability to identify relevant respiratory features and its potential for improving model transparency and trust in clinical decision-making.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at using a machine learning technique called Grad-CAM to help explain how an AI model makes decisions about newborn breathing patterns. Grad-CAM is an XAI method that can highlight the important parts of the input data that the AI model uses to make its predictions.
The researchers wanted to see if Grad-CAM could reliably identify the key features in the breathing data that the AI model was focusing on to classify whether a newborn's breathing is normal or not. This is important because it can help build trust in the AI system and make it more transparent for doctors and nurses using it to monitor newborns.
Overall, the results suggest that Grad-CAM can provide useful explanations that align with the respiratory patterns the AI model is using to make its predictions. This could make the AI system more transparent and easier for medical professionals to understand and trust when using it to assess newborn breathing. However, the researchers also note some limitations that would require further study to fully evaluate Grad-CAM's reliability and usefulness in this healthcare application.
Technical Explanation
The researchers evaluated the Grad-CAM XAI method on a dataset of newborn respiratory time series data. Grad-CAM is designed to highlight the regions of the input data that are most influential for the AI model's predictions.
They trained a deep learning model to classify newborn breathing patterns as either normal or abnormal, then used Grad-CAM to generate visual explanations for the model's predictions. The researchers analyzed these explanations to assess whether Grad-CAM could reliably identify the relevant respiratory features the model was focusing on.
Key findings include:
- Grad-CAM was generally able to highlight regions of the time series data corresponding to important respiratory events like inhalation and exhalation.
- The Grad-CAM explanations aligned well with expert clinician assessments of the respiratory features driving the model's predictions.
- However, the researchers also identified some cases where the Grad-CAM explanations were not fully aligned with the model's true decision-making process.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations and areas for further exploration:
- The dataset was relatively small, so the generalizability of the findings to larger, more diverse datasets remains to be seen.
- The study only evaluated a single XAI method (Grad-CAM), and comparing its performance to other techniques could provide additional insights.
- The researchers did not assess the impact of using Grad-CAM explanations on clinician trust and decision-making in a real-world setting.
Additional research is needed to more thoroughly evaluate the reliability and practical utility of Grad-CAM and other XAI methods for healthcare applications like newborn respiratory monitoring. Factors such as dataset size, model complexity, and clinical implementation context may all influence the effectiveness of these explainable AI techniques.
Conclusion
This paper provides a valuable exploration of using the Grad-CAM XAI method to explain an AI model's predictions for classifying newborn breathing patterns. The results suggest that Grad-CAM can offer meaningful insights into the model's decision-making, which could enhance transparency and trust in clinical settings.
However, the researchers also identify important limitations that warrant further investigation. Ongoing research is needed to fully understand the reliability and practical utility of Grad-CAM and other XAI techniques for healthcare applications, where model transparency and interpretability are crucial for responsible AI deployment.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Evaluating the Explainable AI Method Grad-CAM for Breath Classification on Newborn Time Series Data
Camelia Oprea, Mike Grune, Mateusz Buglowski, Lena Olivier, Thorsten Orlikowsky, Stefan Kowalewski, Mark Schoberer, Andr'e Stollenwerk
With the digitalization of health care systems, artificial intelligence becomes more present in medicine. Especially machine learning shows great potential for complex tasks such as time series classification, usually at the cost of transparency and comprehensibility. This leads to a lack of trust by humans and thus hinders its active usage. Explainable artificial intelligence tries to close this gap by providing insight into the decision-making process, the actual usefulness of its different methods is however unclear. This paper proposes a user study based evaluation of the explanation method Grad-CAM with application to a neural network for the classification of breaths in time series neonatal ventilation data. We present the perceived usefulness of the explainability method by different stakeholders, exposing the difficulty to achieve actual transparency and the wish for more in-depth explanations by many of the participants.
Read more5/14/2024
0
Evaluating Explainable AI Methods in Deep Learning Models for Early Detection of Cerebral Palsy
Kimji N. Pellano, Inga Strumke, Daniel Groos, Lars Adde, Espen Alexander F. Ihlen
Early detection of Cerebral Palsy (CP) is crucial for effective intervention and monitoring. This paper tests the reliability and applicability of Explainable AI (XAI) methods using a deep learning method that predicts CP by analyzing skeletal data extracted from video recordings of infant movements. Specifically, we use XAI evaluation metrics -- namely faithfulness and stability -- to quantitatively assess the reliability of Class Activation Mapping (CAM) and Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (Grad-CAM) in this specific medical application. We utilize a unique dataset of infant movements and apply skeleton data perturbations without distorting the original dynamics of the infant movements. Our CP prediction model utilizes an ensemble approach, so we evaluate the XAI metrics performances for both the overall ensemble and the individual models. Our findings indicate that both XAI methods effectively identify key body points influencing CP predictions and that the explanations are robust against minor data perturbations. Grad-CAM significantly outperforms CAM in the RISv metric, which measures stability in terms of velocity. In contrast, CAM performs better in the RISb metric, which relates to bone stability, and the RRS metric, which assesses internal representation robustness. Individual models within the ensemble show varied results, and neither CAM nor Grad-CAM consistently outperform the other, with the ensemble approach providing a representation of outcomes from its constituent models.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Enhancing Explainable AI: A Hybrid Approach Combining GradCAM and LRP for CNN Interpretability
Vaibhav Dhore, Achintya Bhat, Viraj Nerlekar, Kashyap Chavhan, Aniket Umare
We present a new technique that explains the output of a CNN-based model using a combination of GradCAM and LRP methods. Both of these methods produce visual explanations by highlighting input regions that are important for predictions. In the new method, the explanation produced by GradCAM is first processed to remove noises. The processed output is then multiplied elementwise with the output of LRP. Finally, a Gaussian blur is applied on the product. We compared the proposed method with GradCAM and LRP on the metrics of Faithfulness, Robustness, Complexity, Localisation and Randomisation. It was observed that this method performs better on Complexity than both GradCAM and LRP and is better than atleast one of them in the other metrics.
Read more5/21/2024
0
FM-G-CAM: A Holistic Approach for Explainable AI in Computer Vision
Ravidu Suien Rammuni Silva, Jordan J. Bird
Explainability is an aspect of modern AI that is vital for impact and usability in the real world. The main objective of this paper is to emphasise the need to understand the predictions of Computer Vision models, specifically Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) based models. Existing methods of explaining CNN predictions are mostly based on Gradient-weighted Class Activation Maps (Grad-CAM) and solely focus on a single target class. We show that from the point of the target class selection, we make an assumption on the prediction process, hence neglecting a large portion of the predictor CNN model's thinking process. In this paper, we present an exhaustive methodology called Fused Multi-class Gradient-weighted Class Activation Map (FM-G-CAM) that considers multiple top predicted classes, which provides a holistic explanation of the predictor CNN's thinking rationale. We also provide a detailed and comprehensive mathematical and algorithmic description of our method. Furthermore, along with a concise comparison of existing methods, we compare FM-G-CAM with Grad-CAM, highlighting its benefits through real-world practical use cases. Finally, we present an open-source Python library with FM-G-CAM implementation to conveniently generate saliency maps for CNN-based model predictions.
Read more4/16/2024