Evaluating Pedestrian Trajectory Prediction Methods with Respect to Autonomous Driving
2308.05194
0
0
🔮
Abstract
In this paper, we assess the state of the art in pedestrian trajectory prediction within the context of generating single trajectories, a critical aspect aligning with the requirements in autonomous systems. The evaluation is conducted on the widely-used ETH/UCY dataset where the Average Displacement Error (ADE) and the Final Displacement Error (FDE) are reported. Alongside this, we perform an ablation study to investigate the impact of the observed motion history on prediction performance. To evaluate the scalability of each approach when confronted with varying amounts of agents, the inference time of each model is measured. Following a quantitative analysis, the resulting predictions are compared in a qualitative manner, giving insight into the strengths and weaknesses of current approaches. The results demonstrate that although a constant velocity model (CVM) provides a good approximation of the overall dynamics in the majority of cases, additional features need to be incorporated to reflect common pedestrian behavior observed. Therefore, this study presents a data-driven analysis with the intent to guide the future development of pedestrian trajectory prediction algorithms.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper evaluates the state of the art in pedestrian trajectory prediction, a critical aspect for autonomous systems.
- The evaluation is conducted on the widely-used ETH/UCY dataset, measuring the Average Displacement Error (ADE) and Final Displacement Error (FDE).
- The authors perform an ablation study to understand the impact of observed motion history on prediction performance.
- They also assess the scalability of each approach by measuring the inference time as the number of agents varies.
- Both quantitative and qualitative analyses are presented to provide insights into the strengths and weaknesses of current approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines the current methods for predicting the future paths of pedestrians, which is an important capability for autonomous systems like self-driving cars. The researchers tested these methods on a widely-used dataset of pedestrian movements and looked at two key metrics: the average error in predicting the pedestrian's position over time (ADE), and the error in predicting their final position (FDE).
They also investigated how the amount of information about the pedestrian's past movements affected the prediction accuracy. Additionally, they measured how long it took each method to make a prediction, to see how well they would scale as the number of pedestrians increases.
The results show that a simple "constant velocity" model can provide a good overall approximation of pedestrian movements in many cases. However, more advanced models that incorporate additional information about typical pedestrian behaviors are needed to improve the accuracy. The paper provides a data-driven analysis to help guide the future development of pedestrian trajectory prediction algorithms for autonomous systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates the state of the art in pedestrian trajectory prediction, a critical component for autonomous systems. The authors conduct their evaluation on the widely-used ETH/UCY dataset, reporting the Average Displacement Error (ADE) and Final Displacement Error (FDE) as performance metrics.
To investigate the impact of observed motion history on prediction performance, the authors perform an ablation study. They also assess the scalability of each approach by measuring the inference time as the number of agents varies.
The quantitative analysis is complemented by a qualitative comparison of the resulting predictions, providing insights into the strengths and weaknesses of current approaches. The results demonstrate that while a constant velocity model (CVM) can provide a good approximation in many cases, additional features are needed to fully capture common pedestrian behaviors.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and data-driven analysis of the state of pedestrian trajectory prediction, highlighting the need for more advanced models that can better capture the complexities of human movement. The authors acknowledge the limitations of the study, such as the use of a single dataset, and suggest that further research is needed to explore the generalization of these findings.
One potential area for improvement could be the incorporation of uncertainty quantification in the prediction models, which could provide valuable insights into the reliability of the forecasts. Additionally, the authors could consider exploring the fairness implications of these prediction algorithms, as they may have significant societal impacts when deployed in autonomous systems.
Overall, the paper presents a comprehensive evaluation of pedestrian trajectory prediction, setting the stage for future research to further enhance the capabilities of autonomous systems in safely navigating complex urban environments.
Conclusion
This paper provides a thorough assessment of the state of the art in pedestrian trajectory prediction, a crucial capability for autonomous systems. The authors' data-driven analysis reveals that while simple models can provide a good overall approximation, more advanced techniques are needed to capture the nuances of human movement. The findings from this study can inform the development of future pedestrian prediction algorithms, ultimately contributing to the advancement of autonomous systems and their safe integration into our communities.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
A survey on robustness in trajectory prediction for autonomous vehicles
Jeroen Hagenus, Frederik Baymler Mathiesen, Julian F. Schumann, Arkady Zgonnikov
0
0
Autonomous vehicles rely on accurate trajectory prediction to inform decision-making processes related to navigation and collision avoidance. However, current trajectory prediction models show signs of overfitting, which may lead to unsafe or suboptimal behavior. To address these challenges, this paper presents a comprehensive framework that categorizes and assesses the definitions and strategies used in the literature on evaluating and improving the robustness of trajectory prediction models. This involves a detailed exploration of various approaches, including data slicing methods, perturbation techniques, model architecture changes, and post-training adjustments. In the literature, we see many promising methods for increasing robustness, which are necessary for safe and reliable autonomous driving.
4/23/2024
🔮
A Cognitive-Driven Trajectory Prediction Model for Autonomous Driving in Mixed Autonomy Environment
Haicheng Liao, Zhenning Li, Chengyue Wang, Bonan Wang, Hanlin Kong, Yanchen Guan, Guofa Li, Zhiyong Cui, Chengzhong Xu
0
0
As autonomous driving technology progresses, the need for precise trajectory prediction models becomes paramount. This paper introduces an innovative model that infuses cognitive insights into trajectory prediction, focusing on perceived safety and dynamic decision-making. Distinct from traditional approaches, our model excels in analyzing interactions and behavior patterns in mixed autonomy traffic scenarios. It represents a significant leap forward, achieving marked performance improvements on several key datasets. Specifically, it surpasses existing benchmarks with gains of 16.2% on the Next Generation Simulation (NGSIM), 27.4% on the Highway Drone (HighD), and 19.8% on the Macao Connected Autonomous Driving (MoCAD) dataset. Our proposed model shows exceptional proficiency in handling corner cases, essential for real-world applications. Moreover, its robustness is evident in scenarios with missing or limited data, outperforming most of the state-of-the-art baselines. This adaptability and resilience position our model as a viable tool for real-world autonomous driving systems, heralding a new standard in vehicle trajectory prediction for enhanced safety and efficiency.
4/29/2024
🔮
Uncertainty-Aware Pedestrian Trajectory Prediction via Distributional Diffusion
Yao Liu, Zesheng Ye, Rui Wang, Binghao Li, Quan Z. Sheng, Lina Yao
0
0
Tremendous efforts have been put forth on predicting pedestrian trajectory with generative models to accommodate uncertainty and multi-modality in human behaviors. An individual's inherent uncertainty, e.g., change of destination, can be masked by complex patterns resulting from the movements of interacting pedestrians. However, latent variable-based generative models often entangle such uncertainty with complexity, leading to limited either latent expressivity or predictive diversity. In this work, we propose to separately model these two factors by implicitly deriving a flexible latent representation to capture intricate pedestrian movements, while integrating predictive uncertainty of individuals with explicit bivariate Gaussian mixture densities over their future locations. More specifically, we present a model-agnostic uncertainty-aware pedestrian trajectory prediction framework, parameterizing sufficient statistics for the mixture of Gaussians that jointly comprise the multi-modal trajectories. We further estimate these parameters of interest by approximating a denoising process that progressively recovers pedestrian movements from noise. Unlike previous studies, we translate the predictive stochasticity to explicit distributions, allowing it to readily generate plausible future trajectories indicating individuals' self-uncertainty. Moreover, our framework is compatible with different neural net architectures. We empirically show the performance gains over state-of-the-art even with lighter backbones, across most scenes on two public benchmarks.
5/14/2024
Uncertainty-Aware DRL for Autonomous Vehicle Crowd Navigation in Shared Space
Mahsa Golchoubian, Moojan Ghafurian, Kerstin Dautenhahn, Nasser Lashgarian Azad
0
0
Safe, socially compliant, and efficient navigation of low-speed autonomous vehicles (AVs) in pedestrian-rich environments necessitates considering pedestrians' future positions and interactions with the vehicle and others. Despite the inevitable uncertainties associated with pedestrians' predicted trajectories due to their unobserved states (e.g., intent), existing deep reinforcement learning (DRL) algorithms for crowd navigation often neglect these uncertainties when using predicted trajectories to guide policy learning. This omission limits the usability of predictions when diverging from ground truth. This work introduces an integrated prediction and planning approach that incorporates the uncertainties of predicted pedestrian states in the training of a model-free DRL algorithm. A novel reward function encourages the AV to respect pedestrians' personal space, decrease speed during close approaches, and minimize the collision probability with their predicted paths. Unlike previous DRL methods, our model, designed for AV operation in crowded spaces, is trained in a novel simulation environment that reflects realistic pedestrian behaviour in a shared space with vehicles. Results show a 40% decrease in collision rate and a 15% increase in minimum distance to pedestrians compared to the state of the art model that does not account for prediction uncertainty. Additionally, the approach outperforms model predictive control methods that incorporate the same prediction uncertainties in terms of both performance and computational time, while producing trajectories closer to human drivers in similar scenarios.
5/24/2024