Evaluation Study on SAM 2 for Class-agnostic Instance-level Segmentation

Read original: arXiv:2409.02567 - Published 9/5/2024 by Tiantian Zhang, Zhangjun Zhou, Jialun Pei
Total Score

0

Evaluation Study on SAM 2 for Class-agnostic Instance-level Segmentation

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper provides an evaluation study on the Segment Anything Model 2 (SAM 2), a large vision foundation model for class-agnostic instance-level segmentation.
  • The study examines SAM 2's performance on various tasks, including segmenting objects, people, and other entities in images without relying on predefined object classes.
  • The researchers compare SAM 2 to other state-of-the-art segmentation models and assess its capabilities and limitations.

Plain English Explanation

The paper evaluates a powerful new AI model called Segment Anything Model 2 (SAM 2), which can identify and outline individual objects, people, and other entities in images. Unlike traditional object detection models that are limited to predefined object categories, SAM 2 can segment any kind of visual element in a "class-agnostic" way.

The researchers put SAM 2 through a series of experiments to assess its performance on different tasks, such as detecting camouflaged objects, segmenting 3D medical scans, and maintaining robustness against adversarial attacks. They compare SAM 2's capabilities to other state-of-the-art segmentation models to understand its strengths and weaknesses.

Overall, the findings suggest that SAM 2 is a powerful tool for visual understanding, with the ability to segment a wide range of objects and entities without relying on predefined categories. However, the researchers also identify some limitations and areas for improvement in terms of robustness and generalization.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents an evaluation of the Segment Anything Model 2 (SAM 2), a large-scale vision foundation model designed for class-agnostic instance-level segmentation. Unlike traditional object detection models that are limited to predefined object categories, SAM 2 aims to segment any visual element in an image, regardless of its class.

The researchers conducted a series of experiments to assess SAM 2's performance on various tasks, including segmenting objects, people, and other entities in natural images, as well as its ability to handle more specialized scenarios such as detecting camouflaged objects, segmenting 3D medical scans, and maintaining robustness against adversarial attacks. The researchers compared SAM 2's performance to other state-of-the-art segmentation models to gain insights into its capabilities and limitations.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of SAM 2, highlighting its strengths as a powerful class-agnostic instance segmentation model. However, the researchers also acknowledge several limitations and areas for further improvement.

One key limitation noted is the model's vulnerability to adversarial attacks, which can cause significant performance degradation. This is an important consideration for real-world deployment, as models need to be robust to a variety of challenges.

Additionally, the researchers suggest that further research is needed to improve SAM 2's generalization capabilities and to explore its potential applications in specialized domains, such as medical imaging and autonomous systems.

Conclusion

This paper provides a thorough evaluation of the Segment Anything Model 2 (SAM 2), a large-scale vision foundation model for class-agnostic instance-level segmentation. The findings suggest that SAM 2 is a powerful tool for visual understanding, with the ability to segment a wide range of objects and entities without relying on predefined categories.

While the model shows impressive performance on various tasks, the researchers also identify limitations in terms of robustness and generalization. Further research and development in these areas could help unlock the full potential of SAM 2 and other advanced segmentation models, with important implications for a wide range of applications, from medical imaging to autonomous systems.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Evaluation Study on SAM 2 for Class-agnostic Instance-level Segmentation
Total Score

0

Evaluation Study on SAM 2 for Class-agnostic Instance-level Segmentation

Tiantian Zhang, Zhangjun Zhou, Jialun Pei

Segment Anything Model (SAM) has demonstrated powerful zero-shot segmentation performance in natural scenes. The recently released Segment Anything Model 2 (SAM2) has further heightened researchers' expectations towards image segmentation capabilities. To evaluate the performance of SAM2 on class-agnostic instance-level segmentation tasks, we adopt different prompt strategies for SAM2 to cope with instance-level tasks for three relevant scenarios: Salient Instance Segmentation (SIS), Camouflaged Instance Segmentation (CIS), and Shadow Instance Detection (SID). In addition, to further explore the effectiveness of SAM2 in segmenting granular object structures, we also conduct detailed tests on the high-resolution Dichotomous Image Segmentation (DIS) benchmark to assess the fine-grained segmentation capability. Qualitative and quantitative experimental results indicate that the performance of SAM2 varies significantly across different scenarios. Besides, SAM2 is not particularly sensitive to segmenting high-resolution fine details. We hope this technique report can drive the emergence of SAM2-based adapters, aiming to enhance the performance ceiling of large vision models on class-agnostic instance segmentation tasks.

Read more

9/5/2024

Is SAM 2 Better than SAM in Medical Image Segmentation?
Total Score

0

Is SAM 2 Better than SAM in Medical Image Segmentation?

Sourya Sengupta, Satrajit Chakrabarty, Ravi Soni

The Segment Anything Model (SAM) has demonstrated impressive performance in zero-shot promptable segmentation on natural images. The recently released Segment Anything Model 2 (SAM 2) claims to outperform SAM on images and extends the model's capabilities to video segmentation. Evaluating the performance of this new model in medical image segmentation, specifically in a zero-shot promptable manner, is crucial. In this work, we conducted extensive studies using multiple datasets from various imaging modalities to compare the performance of SAM and SAM 2. We employed two point-prompt strategies: (i) multiple positive prompts where one prompt is placed near the centroid of the target structure, while the remaining prompts are randomly placed within the structure, and (ii) combined positive and negative prompts where one positive prompt is placed near the centroid of the target structure, and two negative prompts are positioned outside the structure, maximizing the distance from the positive prompt and from each other. The evaluation encompassed 24 unique organ-modality combinations, including abdominal structures, cardiac structures, fetal head images, skin lesions and polyp images across 11 publicly available MRI, CT, ultrasound, dermoscopy, and endoscopy datasets. Preliminary results based on 2D images indicate that while SAM 2 may perform slightly better in a few cases, it does not generally surpass SAM for medical image segmentation. Notably, SAM 2 performs worse than SAM in lower contrast imaging modalities, such as CT and ultrasound. However, for MRI images, SAM 2 performs on par with or better than SAM. Like SAM, SAM 2 also suffers from over-segmentation issues, particularly when the boundaries of the target organ are fuzzy.

Read more

8/14/2024

Evaluating SAM2's Role in Camouflaged Object Detection: From SAM to SAM2
Total Score

0

Evaluating SAM2's Role in Camouflaged Object Detection: From SAM to SAM2

Lv Tang, Bo Li

The Segment Anything Model (SAM), introduced by Meta AI Research as a generic object segmentation model, quickly garnered widespread attention and significantly influenced the academic community. To extend its application to video, Meta further develops Segment Anything Model 2 (SAM2), a unified model capable of both video and image segmentation. SAM2 shows notable improvements over its predecessor in terms of applicable domains, promptable segmentation accuracy, and running speed. However, this report reveals a decline in SAM2's ability to perceive different objects in images without prompts in its auto mode, compared to SAM. Specifically, we employ the challenging task of camouflaged object detection to assess this performance decrease, hoping to inspire further exploration of the SAM model family by researchers. The results of this paper are provided in url{https://github.com/luckybird1994/SAMCOD}.

Read more

8/1/2024

A Short Review and Evaluation of SAM2's Performance in 3D CT Image Segmentation
Total Score

0

A Short Review and Evaluation of SAM2's Performance in 3D CT Image Segmentation

Yufan He, Pengfei Guo, Yucheng Tang, Andriy Myronenko, Vishwesh Nath, Ziyue Xu, Dong Yang, Can Zhao, Daguang Xu, Wenqi Li

Since the release of Segment Anything 2 (SAM2), the medical imaging community has been actively evaluating its performance for 3D medical image segmentation. However, different studies have employed varying evaluation pipelines, resulting in conflicting outcomes that obscure a clear understanding of SAM2's capabilities and potential applications. We shortly review existing benchmarks and point out that the SAM2 paper clearly outlines a zero-shot evaluation pipeline, which simulates user clicks iteratively for up to eight iterations. We reproduced this interactive annotation simulation on 3D CT datasets and provided the results and code~url{https://github.com/Project-MONAI/VISTA}. Our findings reveal that directly applying SAM2 on 3D medical imaging in a zero-shot manner is far from satisfactory. It is prone to generating false positives when foreground objects disappear, and annotating more slices cannot fully offset this tendency. For smaller single-connected objects like kidney and aorta, SAM2 performs reasonably well but for most organs it is still far behind state-of-the-art 3D annotation methods. More research and innovation are needed for 3D medical imaging community to use SAM2 correctly.

Read more

8/22/2024