Evolutionary Computation and Explainable AI: A Roadmap to Transparent Intelligent Systems
2406.07811
0
0
Abstract
AI methods are finding an increasing number of applications, but their often black-box nature has raised concerns about accountability and trust. The field of explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) has emerged in response to the need for human understanding of AI models. Evolutionary computation (EC), as a family of powerful optimization and learning tools, has significant potential to contribute to XAI. In this paper, we provide an introduction to XAI and review various techniques in current use for explaining machine learning (ML) models. We then focus on how EC can be used in XAI, and review some XAI approaches which incorporate EC techniques. Additionally, we discuss the application of XAI principles within EC itself, examining how these principles can shed some light on the behavior and outcomes of EC algorithms in general, on the (automatic) configuration of these algorithms, and on the underlying problem landscapes that these algorithms optimize. Finally, we discuss some open challenges in XAI and opportunities for future research in this field using EC. Our aim is to demonstrate that EC is well-suited for addressing current problems in explainability and to encourage further exploration of these methods to contribute to the development of more transparent and trustworthy ML models and EC algorithms.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the intersection of evolutionary computation and explainable AI (XAI) to develop more transparent and interpretable intelligent systems.
- It outlines a roadmap for advancing the field of XAI, focusing on the role of evolutionary algorithms in improving the explainability of AI models.
- Key topics include the limitations of current XAI approaches, the potential of evolutionary techniques to enhance model interpretability, and the future research directions in this area.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses how we can make AI systems more understandable and transparent by drawing inspiration from the field of evolutionary computation. Today, many AI models are complex "black boxes" that are difficult for humans to comprehend. This can be problematic, as we often want to know how and why an AI system arrived at a particular decision or output.
The researchers argue that evolutionary algorithms - which mimic the process of natural selection to optimize solutions - could hold the key to building more explainable AI. By evolving AI models that are inherently interpretable, we may be able to create intelligent systems that can clearly explain their reasoning and decision-making process. This could have important implications for building trust in AI, as well as ensuring these systems are accountable and aligned with human values.
The paper outlines a roadmap for integrating evolutionary computation and XAI, highlighting areas like Solving Enigma: Deriving Optimal Explanations for Deep Networks, The Future of Human-Centric Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI), and Evolutionary Computation in the Era of Large Language Models: A Survey. By drawing on these emerging research directions, the authors aim to chart a path towards more transparent and trustworthy AI systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by acknowledging the growing importance of explainable AI (XAI) in developing intelligent systems that are transparent and accountable. However, the authors note that current XAI approaches have significant limitations, often failing to provide complete, accurate, and readily interpretable explanations.
To address this challenge, the researchers propose leveraging the principles of evolutionary computation to enhance the explainability of AI models. They suggest that by evolving inherently interpretable model architectures, rather than relying on post-hoc explanation methods, we can create intelligent systems that are more transparent and aligned with human understanding.
The paper outlines several key research directions in this area, including Explainable Generative AI (GenXAI) - the development of generative models that can provide clear and intuitive explanations of their outputs. The authors also discuss the potential of evolutionary techniques to improve the interpretability of large language models, which have become ubiquitous in AI but are often opaque "black boxes."
Through a comprehensive review of the literature and a thoughtful discussion of the challenges and opportunities, the researchers present a roadmap for integrating evolutionary computation and XAI to build a new generation of transparent and trustworthy intelligent systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the integration of evolutionary computation and XAI, highlighting the potential of this approach to address some of the key limitations of current explainable AI systems. The authors provide a thorough overview of the relevant literature and outline a clear research agenda for advancing this field.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into some of the potential challenges and drawbacks of this approach. For example, the researchers do not discuss the computational complexity and scalability issues that may arise when evolving highly interpretable model architectures, particularly for large-scale or real-time applications.
Additionally, the paper could have further explored the trade-offs between model interpretability and performance, as well as the potential societal implications of more transparent AI systems. While the authors acknowledge the importance of trust and accountability, they could have engaged more critically with the ethical and philosophical questions surrounding the deployment of such systems.
Despite these minor criticisms, the paper presents a compelling and well-researched vision for the future of explainable AI, and the authors' roadmap provides a valuable framework for guiding future research in this rapidly evolving field.
Conclusion
This paper offers a thought-provoking exploration of the synergies between evolutionary computation and explainable AI, outlining a roadmap for developing more transparent and interpretable intelligent systems. By leveraging the principles of natural selection to evolve inherently explainable model architectures, the researchers suggest we can create AI that is better aligned with human understanding and more accountable to the people and societies it serves.
While the paper acknowledges some of the challenges and limitations of this approach, it presents a compelling case for further research and innovation in this area. As AI continues to permeate ever more aspects of our lives, the need for explainable and trustworthy systems has never been greater. The ideas put forth in this paper could help pave the way for a future where AI is not just powerful, but also transparent and responsive to human values and concerns.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
👨🏫
Applications of Explainable artificial intelligence in Earth system science
Feini Huang, Shijie Jiang, Lu Li, Yongkun Zhang, Ye Zhang, Ruqing Zhang, Qingliang Li, Danxi Li, Wei Shangguan, Yongjiu Dai
0
0
In recent years, artificial intelligence (AI) rapidly accelerated its influence and is expected to promote the development of Earth system science (ESS) if properly harnessed. In application of AI to ESS, a significant hurdle lies in the interpretability conundrum, an inherent problem of black-box nature arising from the complexity of AI algorithms. To address this, explainable AI (XAI) offers a set of powerful tools that make the models more transparent. The purpose of this review is twofold: First, to provide ESS scholars, especially newcomers, with a foundational understanding of XAI, serving as a primer to inspire future research advances; second, to encourage ESS professionals to embrace the benefits of AI, free from preconceived biases due to its lack of interpretability. We begin with elucidating the concept of XAI, along with typical methods. We then delve into a review of XAI applications in the ESS literature, highlighting the important role that XAI has played in facilitating communication with AI model decisions, improving model diagnosis, and uncovering scientific insights. We identify four significant challenges that XAI faces within the ESS, and propose solutions. Furthermore, we provide a comprehensive illustration of multifaceted perspectives. Given the unique challenges in ESS, an interpretable hybrid approach that seamlessly integrates AI with domain-specific knowledge appears to be a promising way to enhance the utility of AI in ESS. A visionary outlook for ESS envisions a harmonious blend where process-based models govern the known, AI models explore the unknown, and XAI bridges the gap by providing explanations.
6/19/2024
Solving the enigma: Deriving optimal explanations of deep networks
Michail Mamalakis, Antonios Mamalakis, Ingrid Agartz, Lynn Egeland M{o}rch-Johnsen, Graham Murray, John Suckling, Pietro Lio
0
0
The accelerated progress of artificial intelligence (AI) has popularized deep learning models across domains, yet their inherent opacity poses challenges, notably in critical fields like healthcare, medicine and the geosciences. Explainable AI (XAI) has emerged to shed light on these black box models, helping decipher their decision making process. Nevertheless, different XAI methods yield highly different explanations. This inter-method variability increases uncertainty and lowers trust in deep networks' predictions. In this study, for the first time, we propose a novel framework designed to enhance the explainability of deep networks, by maximizing both the accuracy and the comprehensibility of the explanations. Our framework integrates various explanations from established XAI methods and employs a non-linear explanation optimizer to construct a unique and optimal explanation. Through experiments on multi-class and binary classification tasks in 2D object and 3D neuroscience imaging, we validate the efficacy of our approach. Our explanation optimizer achieved superior faithfulness scores, averaging 155% and 63% higher than the best performing XAI method in the 3D and 2D applications, respectively. Additionally, our approach yielded lower complexity, increasing comprehensibility. Our results suggest that optimal explanations based on specific criteria are derivable and address the issue of inter-method variability in the current XAI literature.
5/17/2024
The future of human-centric eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) is not post-hoc explanations
Vinitra Swamy, Jibril Frej, Tanja Kaser
0
0
Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) plays a crucial role in enabling human understanding and trust in deep learning systems. As models get larger, more ubiquitous, and pervasive in aspects of daily life, explainability is necessary to minimize adverse effects of model mistakes. Unfortunately, current approaches in human-centric XAI (e.g. predictive tasks in healthcare, education, or personalized ads) tend to rely on a single post-hoc explainer, whereas recent work has identified systematic disagreement between post-hoc explainers when applied to the same instances of underlying black-box models. In this paper, we therefore present a call for action to address the limitations of current state-of-the-art explainers. We propose a shift from post-hoc explainability to designing interpretable neural network architectures. We identify five needs of human-centric XAI (real-time, accurate, actionable, human-interpretable, and consistent) and propose two schemes for interpretable-by-design neural network workflows (adaptive routing with InterpretCC and temporal diagnostics with I2MD). We postulate that the future of human-centric XAI is neither in explaining black-boxes nor in reverting to traditional, interpretable models, but in neural networks that are intrinsically interpretable.
5/29/2024
🧠
New!Multimodal Explainable Artificial Intelligence: A Comprehensive Review of Methodological Advances and Future Research Directions
Nikolaos Rodis, Christos Sardianos, Panagiotis Radoglou-Grammatikis, Panagiotis Sarigiannidis, Iraklis Varlamis, Georgios Th. Papadopoulos
0
0
Despite the fact that Artificial Intelligence (AI) has boosted the achievement of remarkable results across numerous data analysis tasks, however, this is typically accompanied by a significant shortcoming in the exhibited transparency and trustworthiness of the developed systems. In order to address the latter challenge, the so-called eXplainable AI (XAI) research field has emerged, which aims, among others, at estimating meaningful explanations regarding the employed model reasoning process. The current study focuses on systematically analyzing the recent advances in the area of Multimodal XAI (MXAI), which comprises methods that involve multiple modalities in the primary prediction and explanation tasks. In particular, the relevant AI-boosted prediction tasks and publicly available datasets used for learning/evaluating explanations in multimodal scenarios are initially described. Subsequently, a systematic and comprehensive analysis of the MXAI methods of the literature is provided, taking into account the following key criteria: a) The number of the involved modalities (in the employed AI module), b) The processing stage at which explanations are generated, and c) The type of the adopted methodology (i.e. the actual mechanism and mathematical formalization) for producing explanations. Then, a thorough analysis of the metrics used for MXAI methods evaluation is performed. Finally, an extensive discussion regarding the current challenges and future research directions is provided.
7/2/2024