On the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate and convergence rate under gradient descent for multi-class logistic regression
0
↗️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper revisits the problem of the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate for multi-class logistic regression.
- It shows that assigning positive probability to every class in the sample dataset can ensure the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate.
- The notion of data separability is not needed, unlike the classical setup of multi-class logistic regression.
- The paper provides a general and constructive estimate of the convergence rate to the maximum likelihood estimate when gradient descent is used as the optimizer.
- The approaches used in this article rely on a simple operator-theoretic framework.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a problem in multi-class logistic regression, which is a type of machine learning model used for classification tasks. Specifically, the paper looks at the existence of the "maximum likelihood estimate" - a way of finding the best set of parameters for the model.
The researchers found that one way to ensure the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate is by making sure that each class in the dataset has a positive probability of being selected. This is different from the traditional approach, where each data sample belongs to only one class.
Additionally, the paper provides a way to estimate how quickly the maximum likelihood estimate can be reached when using a popular optimization method called gradient descent. This estimate involves bounding the "condition number" of the Hessian, which is a mathematical concept related to the curvature of the function being optimized.
The key ideas in this paper rely on a simple mathematical framework called "operator theory," which allows the researchers to analyze the problem in a general and systematic way.
Technical Explanation
The paper addresses the problem of the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate (MLE) for multi-class logistic regression, a widely used machine learning model for classification tasks. The researchers show that one way to ensure the existence of the MLE is by assigning positive probability to every class in the sample dataset, which is in contrast to the classical setup of multi-class logistic regression where each data sample belongs to one class.
The paper also provides a general and constructive estimate of the convergence rate to the MLE when gradient descent is used as the optimizer. This estimate involves bounding the condition number of the Hessian of the maximum likelihood function, which is a measure of the curvature of the function being optimized. By bounding the condition number, the researchers can provide guarantees on the rate of convergence to the MLE, as described in this paper on high-probability convergence bounds for nonlinear stochastic gradient.
The approaches used in this paper rely on a simple operator-theoretic framework, which allows the researchers to analyze the problem in a general and systematic way. This contrasts with the more specialized techniques used in this paper on faster margin maximization rates for generic adversarially robust or this paper on diffusion-based generative models and their error bounds.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a novel and well-structured approach to the problem of the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate for multi-class logistic regression. The researchers' use of a simple operator-theoretic framework is a strength, as it allows them to analyze the problem in a general and systematic way.
One potential limitation of the research is that it relies on the assumption of positive probability for each class in the sample dataset. While this ensures the existence of the MLE, it may not always be the case in real-world scenarios. The researchers do not discuss the implications or potential workarounds for situations where this assumption does not hold.
Additionally, the paper focuses solely on the convergence rate of the gradient descent optimizer. While this is an important aspect, the researchers do not provide a comparative analysis with other optimization methods, such as those described in this paper on optimization landscape of maximum mean discrepancy. A broader comparison could help readers better understand the relative strengths and weaknesses of the proposed approach.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the understanding of multi-class logistic regression and the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate. However, further research may be needed to address the limitations and explore alternative scenarios beyond the specific assumptions made in this work.
Conclusion
The paper revisits the problem of the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate for multi-class logistic regression. It shows that assigning positive probability to every class in the sample dataset can ensure the existence of the MLE, without the need for data separability. The researchers also provide a general and constructive estimate of the convergence rate to the MLE when using gradient descent as the optimizer.
The approaches used in this paper rely on a simple operator-theoretic framework, which allows for a systematic analysis of the problem. While the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field, it also highlights the need for further research to address potential limitations and explore alternative scenarios beyond the specific assumptions made in this work.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
↗️
0
On the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate and convergence rate under gradient descent for multi-class logistic regression
Dwight Nwaigwe, Marek Rychlik
We revisit the problem of the existence of the maximum likelihood estimate for multi-class logistic regression. We show that one method of ensuring its existence is by assigning positive probability to every class in the sample dataset. The notion of data separability is not needed, which is in contrast to the classical set up of multi-class logistic regression in which each data sample belongs to one class. We also provide a general and constructive estimate of the convergence rate to the maximum likelihood estimate when gradient descent is used as the optimizer. Our estimate involves bounding the condition number of the Hessian of the maximum likelihood function. The approaches used in this article rely on a simple operator-theoretic framework.
Read more5/9/2024
0
Gradient Descent on Logistic Regression with Non-Separable Data and Large Step Sizes
Si Yi Meng, Antonio Orvieto, Daniel Yiming Cao, Christopher De Sa
We study gradient descent (GD) dynamics on logistic regression problems with large, constant step sizes. For linearly-separable data, it is known that GD converges to the minimizer with arbitrarily large step sizes, a property which no longer holds when the problem is not separable. In fact, the behaviour can be much more complex -- a sequence of period-doubling bifurcations begins at the critical step size $2/lambda$, where $lambda$ is the largest eigenvalue of the Hessian at the solution. Using a smaller-than-critical step size guarantees convergence if initialized nearby the solution: but does this suffice globally? In one dimension, we show that a step size less than $1/lambda$ suffices for global convergence. However, for all step sizes between $1/lambda$ and the critical step size $2/lambda$, one can construct a dataset such that GD converges to a stable cycle. In higher dimensions, this is actually possible even for step sizes less than $1/lambda$. Our results show that although local convergence is guaranteed for all step sizes less than the critical step size, global convergence is not, and GD may instead converge to a cycle depending on the initialization.
Read more6/10/2024
0
Toward Global Convergence of Gradient EM for Over-Parameterized Gaussian Mixture Models
Weihang Xu, Maryam Fazel, Simon S. Du
We study the gradient Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm for Gaussian Mixture Models (GMM) in the over-parameterized setting, where a general GMM with $n>1$ components learns from data that are generated by a single ground truth Gaussian distribution. While results for the special case of 2-Gaussian mixtures are well-known, a general global convergence analysis for arbitrary $n$ remains unresolved and faces several new technical barriers since the convergence becomes sub-linear and non-monotonic. To address these challenges, we construct a novel likelihood-based convergence analysis framework and rigorously prove that gradient EM converges globally with a sublinear rate $O(1/sqrt{t})$. This is the first global convergence result for Gaussian mixtures with more than $2$ components. The sublinear convergence rate is due to the algorithmic nature of learning over-parameterized GMM with gradient EM. We also identify a new emerging technical challenge for learning general over-parameterized GMM: the existence of bad local regions that can trap gradient EM for an exponential number of steps.
Read more7/2/2024
🏷️
0
Classification with Deep Neural Networks and Logistic Loss
Zihan Zhang, Lei Shi, Ding-Xuan Zhou
Deep neural networks (DNNs) trained with the logistic loss (i.e., the cross entropy loss) have made impressive advancements in various binary classification tasks. However, generalization analysis for binary classification with DNNs and logistic loss remains scarce. The unboundedness of the target function for the logistic loss is the main obstacle to deriving satisfactory generalization bounds. In this paper, we aim to fill this gap by establishing a novel and elegant oracle-type inequality, which enables us to deal with the boundedness restriction of the target function, and using it to derive sharp convergence rates for fully connected ReLU DNN classifiers trained with logistic loss. In particular, we obtain optimal convergence rates (up to log factors) only requiring the Holder smoothness of the conditional class probability $eta$ of data. Moreover, we consider a compositional assumption that requires $eta$ to be the composition of several vector-valued functions of which each component function is either a maximum value function or a Holder smooth function only depending on a small number of its input variables. Under this assumption, we derive optimal convergence rates (up to log factors) which are independent of the input dimension of data. This result explains why DNN classifiers can perform well in practical high-dimensional classification problems. Besides the novel oracle-type inequality, the sharp convergence rates given in our paper also owe to a tight error bound for approximating the natural logarithm function near zero (where it is unbounded) by ReLU DNNs. In addition, we justify our claims for the optimality of rates by proving corresponding minimax lower bounds. All these results are new in the literature and will deepen our theoretical understanding of classification with DNNs.
Read more4/23/2024