Expert Insight-Enhanced Follow-up Chest X-Ray Summary Generation

Read original: arXiv:2405.00344 - Published 5/7/2024 by Zhichuan Wang, Kinhei Lee, Qiao Deng, Tiffany Y. So, Wan Hang Chiu, Yeung Yu Hui, Bingjing Zhou, Edward S. Hui

🛸

Overview

This study proposes a transformer-based framework to automatically generate follow-up summaries for chest X-ray radiology reports.
The key focus is on capturing changes in disease progression or device placement compared to previous X-ray examinations, which is a challenging task that has not been well-addressed by prior work.
The researchers introduce two novel mechanisms - expert soft guidance and masked entity modeling loss - to incorporate medical domain expertise and improve the fidelity of the generated summaries.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the competitive performance of the proposed approach compared to state-of-the-art methods.

Plain English Explanation

Radiology reports for chest X-rays often need to describe not only the current findings, but also any changes or progression of diseases or medical devices since the previous X-ray exam. While most prior research has focused on summarizing the current X-ray findings, this study tackles the more challenging task of generating summaries that capture the changes over time.

The researchers developed a transformer-based model that is specifically designed for this follow-up summary generation task. To make the model more accurate, they incorporated two new techniques:

Expert soft guidance: The model is guided by a pre-trained classifier that can identify the presence and severity of specific medical conditions. This helps the model understand the significance of different abnormalities.
Masked entity modeling loss: The model is trained to pay close attention to the key medical terms and concepts, ensuring it accurately reflects the language and terminology used by radiologists.

Through extensive testing, the researchers showed that their model performs as well as or better than the current state-of-the-art approaches for generating follow-up radiology report summaries. This is an important advancement, as being able to automatically summarize changes over time can save radiologists a significant amount of time and effort.

Technical Explanation

The core of the proposed framework is a transformer-based architecture, which is well-suited for the text generation task of producing follow-up radiology report summaries. To enhance the fidelity of the generated summaries, the researchers introduced two novel mechanisms:

Expert soft guidance: The researchers leveraged a pre-trained disease classifier model, similar to the approach used in the Disease Labeler for Chinese Chest X-Ray Reports, to provide expert-level guidance to the summary generation model. This classifier outputs the presence and severity of various medical conditions, which is then used as an additional input to the transformer model to ensure it properly captures the significance of different abnormalities.
Masked entity modeling loss: Inspired by techniques like Bootstrapping Chest CT Image Understanding by Distilling and Systematic Review of Deep Learning-Based Research in Radiology, the researchers designed a specialized loss function that encourages the model to accurately identify and represent the medical entities (e.g., disease names, anatomical terms) present in the reports. This helps the model better understand and utilize the specialized medical vocabulary.

The researchers conducted extensive experiments to evaluate their proposed framework, comparing its performance to state-of-the-art models for follow-up radiology report summarization. The results demonstrate that their approach is competitive with or exceeds the current best-performing methods, highlighting the value of incorporating expert-level domain knowledge and specialized training objectives.

Critical Analysis

The researchers have made a valuable contribution by tackling the challenging problem of generating follow-up summaries for radiology reports, which has received relatively little attention compared to summarizing the current X-ray findings. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

The study only evaluates the model's performance on a single dataset, so it would be important to validate the approach on additional datasets to ensure its robustness and generalizability.
While the expert soft guidance and masked entity modeling loss techniques show promise, it's unclear how much they individually contribute to the model's performance. A more detailed ablation study could provide deeper insights.
The paper does not address the potential for biases or errors in the pre-trained disease classifier model, which could be propagated to the summary generation model. Exploring ways to mitigate such issues would be an important next step.
The researchers mention that their approach is competitive with or exceeds state-of-the-art methods, but they do not provide a direct comparison of the model's performance on specific metrics. A more detailed comparison would help readers better understand the magnitude of the improvements.

Overall, this study represents a valuable step forward in the field of automatic radiology report generation, particularly for the understudied task of follow-up summary generation. The proposed techniques and insights could inspire further research to enhance the accuracy and reliability of these systems, which could ultimately improve the efficiency and quality of radiological diagnosis and treatment.

Conclusion

This study presents a transformer-based framework for automatically generating follow-up summaries of chest X-ray radiology reports, focusing on capturing changes in disease progression or medical device placement compared to previous examinations. The researchers introduce two novel mechanisms - expert soft guidance and masked entity modeling loss - to incorporate medical domain expertise and improve the fidelity of the generated summaries.

Extensive experiments demonstrate that the proposed approach is competitive with or exceeds the state-of-the-art methods for this task. This is an important advancement, as being able to automatically summarize changes over time can significantly streamline the radiology reporting process and potentially improve the quality of patient care.

While the study has some limitations, it represents a valuable contribution to the field of automatic radiology report generation and could inspire further research to enhance the accuracy and reliability of these systems, ultimately benefiting radiologists, clinicians, and patients.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🛸

Expert Insight-Enhanced Follow-up Chest X-Ray Summary Generation

Zhichuan Wang, Kinhei Lee, Qiao Deng, Tiffany Y. So, Wan Hang Chiu, Yeung Yu Hui, Bingjing Zhou, Edward S. Hui

A chest X-ray radiology report describes abnormal findings not only from X-ray obtained at current examination, but also findings on disease progression or change in device placement with reference to the X-ray from previous examination. Majority of the efforts on automatic generation of radiology report pertain to reporting the former, but not the latter, type of findings. To the best of the authors' knowledge, there is only one work dedicated to generating summary of the latter findings, i.e., follow-up summary. In this study, we therefore propose a transformer-based framework to tackle this task. Motivated by our observations on the significance of medical lexicon on the fidelity of summary generation, we introduce two mechanisms to bestow expert insight to our model, namely expert soft guidance and masked entity modeling loss. The former mechanism employs a pretrained expert disease classifier to guide the presence level of specific abnormalities, while the latter directs the model's attention toward medical lexicon. Extensive experiments were conducted to demonstrate that the performance of our model is competitive with or exceeds the state-of-the-art.

5/7/2024

Improving Expert Radiology Report Summarization by Prompting Large Language Models with a Layperson Summary

Xingmeng Zhao, Tongnian Wang, Anthony Rios

Radiology report summarization (RRS) is crucial for patient care, requiring concise Impressions from detailed Findings. This paper introduces a novel prompting strategy to enhance RRS by first generating a layperson summary. This approach normalizes key observations and simplifies complex information using non-expert communication techniques inspired by doctor-patient interactions. Combined with few-shot in-context learning, this method improves the model's ability to link general terms to specific findings. We evaluate this approach on the MIMIC-CXR, CheXpert, and MIMIC-III datasets, benchmarking it against 7B/8B parameter state-of-the-art open-source large language models (LLMs) like Meta-Llama-3-8B-Instruct. Our results demonstrate improvements in summarization accuracy and accessibility, particularly in out-of-domain tests, with improvements as high as 5% for some metrics.

6/21/2024

🧠

Summarizing Radiology Reports Findings into Impressions

Raul Salles de Padua, Imran Qureshi

Patient hand-off and triage are two fundamental problems in health care. Often doctors must painstakingly summarize complex findings to efficiently communicate with specialists and quickly make decisions on which patients have the most urgent cases. In pursuit of these challenges, we present (1) a model with state-of-art radiology report summarization performance using (2) a novel method for augmenting medical data, and (3) an analysis of the model limitations and radiology knowledge gain. We also provide a data processing pipeline for future models developed on the the MIMIC CXR dataset. Our best performing model was a fine-tuned BERT-to-BERT encoder-decoder with 58.75/100 ROUGE-L F1, which outperformed specialized checkpoints with more sophisticated attention mechanisms. We investigate these aspects in this work.

5/14/2024

📊

Longitudinal Data and a Semantic Similarity Reward for Chest X-Ray Report Generation

Aaron Nicolson, Jason Dowling, Bevan Koopman

Radiologists face high burnout rates, partially due to the increasing volume of Chest X-rays (CXRs) requiring interpretation and reporting. Automated CXR report generation holds promise for reducing this burden and improving patient care. While current models show potential, their diagnostic accuracy is limited. Our proposed CXR report generator integrates elements of the radiologist workflow and introduces a novel reward for reinforcement learning. Our approach leverages longitudinal data from a patient's prior CXR study and effectively handles cases where no prior study exist, thus mirroring the radiologist's workflow. In contrast, existing models typically lack this flexibility, often requiring prior studies for the model to function optimally. Our approach also incorporates all CXRs from a patient's study and distinguishes between report sections through section embeddings. Our reward for reinforcement learning leverages CXR-BERT, which forces our model to learn the clinical semantics of radiology reporting. We conduct experiments on publicly available datasets -- MIMIC-CXR and Open-i IU X-ray -- with metrics shown to more closely correlate with radiologists' assessment of reporting. Results from our study demonstrate that the proposed model generates reports that are more aligned with radiologists' reports than state-of-the-art models, such as those utilising large language models, reinforcement learning, and multi-task learning. The proposed model improves the diagnostic accuracy of CXR report generation, which could one day reduce radiologists' workload and enhance patient care. Our Hugging Face checkpoint (https://huggingface.co/aehrc/cxrmate) and code (https://github.com/aehrc/cxrmate) are publicly available.

6/21/2024