An Exploration Study of Mixed-initiative Query Reformulation in Conversational Passage Retrieval
0
๐งช
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The researchers aimed to reproduce multi-stage retrieval pipelines and explore the potential benefits of involving mixed-initiative interaction in conversational passage retrieval scenarios.
- They proposed a mixed-initiative query reformulation module as a replacement for neural reformulation methods.
- The module generates appropriate questions based on ambiguities in raw queries and reformulates the queries based on user feedback.
- The researchers also adopted various ranking methods, including BM25, TCT-ColBERT, MonoT5, and DuoT5, in their multi-stage retrieval pipelines.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers were interested in improving how conversational search systems retrieve relevant information for users. They wanted to explore a new approach called "mixed-initiative interaction," where the system and the user work together to refine the search query.
Typically, search systems use automated methods to reformulate queries, but the researchers thought involving the user might lead to better results. So, they designed an algorithm that could generate questions about ambiguities in the user's original query, and then use the user's responses to reformulate the query.
For the actual search process, the researchers used a combination of different ranking techniques, including some that rely on keyword matching (BM25) and others that use neural networks to understand the meaning of the query and the content (TCT-ColBERT, MonoT5, DuoT5).
The researchers tested their approach on datasets from previous competitions, and found that their mixed-initiative query reformulation method improved the search results compared to other automated reformulation techniques.
Technical Explanation
The researchers proposed a mixed-initiative query reformulation module as a replacement for neural reformulation methods in the first ranking stage of their multi-stage retrieval pipelines. This module generates appropriate questions related to ambiguities in raw queries and reformulates the queries based on user feedback.
For the first ranking stage, the researchers adopted a sparse ranking function, BM25, and a dense retrieval method, TCT-ColBERT. For the second-ranking step, they used a pointwise reranker, MonoT5, and a pairwise reranker, DuoT5.
Experiments on the TREC CAsT 2021 and TREC CAsT 2022 datasets showed the effectiveness of the mixed-initiative-based query reformulation method in improving retrieval performance compared to other reformulators, such as the neural reformulator CANARD-T5 and the rule-based reformulator historical query reformulator (HQE).
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledged that their mixed-initiative query reformulation approach relies on user feedback, which may not always be available or reliable. They also noted that the performance of their system could be further improved by incorporating other techniques, such as capability-aware prompt reformulation, zero-shot LLM ensemble prompting, or pseudo-relevance feedback methods.
While the researchers demonstrated the effectiveness of their mixed-initiative approach, further research is needed to understand the limitations and potential biases of this method, particularly in real-world conversational search scenarios where user interactions may be more complex and unpredictable.
Conclusion
The researchers presented a novel mixed-initiative query reformulation approach for conversational passage retrieval, which involves generating clarifying questions and incorporating user feedback to improve search results. The approach was found to outperform other reformulation methods in experiments on TREC CAsT datasets.
This research highlights the potential benefits of involving users in the query reformulation process, but also raises questions about the scalability and reliability of such an approach in real-world conversational search scenarios. Further advancements in iterative conversational query reformulation and related techniques could lead to more robust and user-friendly conversational search systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
๐งช
0
An Exploration Study of Mixed-initiative Query Reformulation in Conversational Passage Retrieval
Dayu Yang, Yue Zhang, Hui Fang
In this paper, we report our methods and experiments for the TREC Conversational Assistance Track (CAsT) 2022. In this work, we aim to reproduce multi-stage retrieval pipelines and explore one of the potential benefits of involving mixed-initiative interaction in conversational passage retrieval scenarios: reformulating raw queries. Before the first ranking stage of a multi-stage retrieval pipeline, we propose a mixed-initiative query reformulation module, which achieves query reformulation based on the mixed-initiative interaction between the users and the system, as the replacement for the neural reformulation method. Specifically, we design an algorithm to generate appropriate questions related to the ambiguities in raw queries, and another algorithm to reformulate raw queries by parsing users' feedback and incorporating it into the raw query. For the first ranking stage of our multi-stage pipelines, we adopt a sparse ranking function: BM25, and a dense retrieval method: TCT-ColBERT. For the second-ranking step, we adopt a pointwise reranker: MonoT5, and a pairwise reranker: DuoT5. Experiments on both TREC CAsT 2021 and TREC CAsT 2022 datasets show the effectiveness of our mixed-initiative-based query reformulation method on improving retrieval performance compared with two popular reformulators: a neural reformulator: CANARD-T5 and a rule-based reformulator: historical query reformulator(HQE).
Read more4/23/2024
โ๏ธ
0
A Surprisingly Simple yet Effective Multi-Query Rewriting Method for Conversational Passage Retrieval
Ivica Kostric, Krisztian Balog
Conversational passage retrieval is challenging as it often requires the resolution of references to previous utterances and needs to deal with the complexities of natural language, such as coreference and ellipsis. To address these challenges, pre-trained sequence-to-sequence neural query rewriters are commonly used to generate a single de-contextualized query based on conversation history. Previous research shows that combining multiple query rewrites for the same user utterance has a positive effect on retrieval performance. We propose the use of a neural query rewriter to generate multiple queries and show how to integrate those queries in the passage retrieval pipeline efficiently. The main strength of our approach lies in its simplicity: it leverages how the beam search algorithm works and can produce multiple query rewrites at no additional cost. Our contributions further include devising ways to utilize multi-query rewrites in both sparse and dense first-pass retrieval. We demonstrate that applying our approach on top of a standard passage retrieval pipeline delivers state-of-the-art performance without sacrificing efficiency.
Read more6/28/2024
0
Conversational Query Reformulation with the Guidance of Retrieved Documents
Jeonghyun Park, Hwanhee Lee
Conversational search seeks to retrieve relevant passages for the given questions in conversational question answering. Conversational Query Reformulation (CQR) improves conversational search by refining the original queries into de-contextualized forms to resolve the issues in the original queries, such as omissions and coreferences. Previous CQR methods focus on imitating human written queries which may not always yield meaningful search results for the retriever. In this paper, we introduce GuideCQR, a framework that refines queries for CQR by leveraging key information from the initially retrieved documents. Specifically, GuideCQR extracts keywords and generates expected answers from the retrieved documents, then unifies them with the queries after filtering to add useful information that enhances the search process. Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed method achieves state-of-the-art performance across multiple datasets, outperforming previous CQR methods. Additionally, we show that GuideCQR can get additional performance gains in conversational search using various types of queries, even for queries written by humans.
Read more9/23/2024
๐
0
IterCQR: Iterative Conversational Query Reformulation with Retrieval Guidance
Yunah Jang, Kang-il Lee, Hyunkyung Bae, Hwanhee Lee, Kyomin Jung
Conversational search aims to retrieve passages containing essential information to answer queries in a multi-turn conversation. In conversational search, reformulating context-dependent conversational queries into stand-alone forms is imperative to effectively utilize off-the-shelf retrievers. Previous methodologies for conversational query reformulation frequently depend on human-annotated rewrites. However, these manually crafted queries often result in sub-optimal retrieval performance and require high collection costs. To address these challenges, we propose Iterative Conversational Query Reformulation (IterCQR), a methodology that conducts query reformulation without relying on human rewrites. IterCQR iteratively trains the conversational query reformulation (CQR) model by directly leveraging information retrieval (IR) signals as a reward. Our IterCQR training guides the CQR model such that generated queries contain necessary information from the previous dialogue context. Our proposed method shows state-of-the-art performance on two widely-used datasets, demonstrating its effectiveness on both sparse and dense retrievers. Moreover, IterCQR exhibits superior performance in challenging settings such as generalization on unseen datasets and low-resource scenarios.
Read more4/9/2024