Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop: On the Benefit of Fine-Tuning Kernel Schedulers with Coordinate Descent
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores a novel approach to fine-tuning kernel schedulers using coordinate descent, which can help optimize the performance of tensor programs.
- The proposed method, called "Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop," combines exploration and exploitation strategies to efficiently search the parameter space and find optimal kernel configurations.
- The researchers demonstrate the benefits of their approach through experiments on a range of tensor programs, showing improvements in both runtime and energy efficiency compared to existing techniques.
Plain English Explanation
In the world of high-performance computing, the kernel scheduler - the component that manages the allocation of computational tasks to hardware resources - plays a crucial role in optimizing the performance of tensor programs, which are a type of mathematical model used in machine learning and other scientific applications. [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/optimal-kernel-orchestration-tensor-programs-korch]
The authors of this paper have developed a new approach to fine-tuning kernel schedulers, which involves using a technique called "coordinate descent." This method allows the system to systematically explore different combinations of parameters (like the number of threads or the size of the work queue) to find the optimal configuration for a given tensor program.
The researchers call their approach "Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop," which is a metaphor for the way it combines two key strategies: exploration, where the system tries out a wide range of different configurations to understand the search space, and exploitation, where it hones in on the most promising areas to find the best solution. [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/optimal-kernel-tuning-parameter-prediction-using-deep]
Through experiments on a variety of tensor programs, the researchers have shown that their fine-tuning approach can lead to significant improvements in both runtime and energy efficiency, compared to existing kernel scheduling techniques. This is an important finding, as optimizing the performance of tensor programs is crucial for many cutting-edge applications, such as [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/neural-optimizer-equation-decay-function-learning-rate] deep learning and [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/center-sensitive-kernel-optimization-efficient-device-incremental] scientific computing.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a novel approach to fine-tuning kernel schedulers for tensor programs, called "Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop." The key idea is to use a coordinate descent optimization algorithm to efficiently search the parameter space and find the optimal kernel configuration.
The researchers first define a set of tunable parameters for the kernel scheduler, such as the number of threads, the size of the work queue, and the scheduling policy. They then formulate the problem of finding the optimal configuration as a multidimensional optimization task, where the goal is to minimize the runtime or energy consumption of the tensor program.
To solve this optimization problem, the authors employ a coordinate descent approach, which iteratively optimizes each parameter while holding the others fixed. This allows the system to explore a wide range of configurations (the "storm") while gradually converging on the optimal solution (the "raindrop").
The researchers evaluate their approach on a range of tensor programs, including [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/task-scheduling-optimization-from-tensor-network-perspective] task scheduling optimization and kernel tuning parameter prediction. Their experiments show that the "Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop" method outperforms existing kernel scheduling techniques in terms of both runtime and energy efficiency, with improvements of up to 30% in some cases.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to fine-tuning kernel schedulers for tensor programs, and the experimental results are promising. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research that could be considered:
-
Scalability: The paper focuses on a relatively small set of tunable parameters for the kernel scheduler. It would be interesting to see how the approach scales as the dimensionality of the optimization problem increases, with a larger number of parameters to tune.
-
Generalizability: The experiments in the paper are conducted on a limited set of tensor programs. It would be valuable to evaluate the "Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop" method on a wider range of applications and hardware platforms to assess its broader applicability.
-
Complexity vs. Performance: The coordinate descent approach adds some computational overhead to the kernel scheduling process. The authors could explore ways to balance the complexity of the optimization algorithm with the potential performance gains, to ensure that the method remains practical for real-world deployment.
-
Interaction with Other Optimization Techniques: The paper does not discuss how the proposed fine-tuning approach might interact with or complement other optimization techniques, such as neural network-based parameter prediction [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/optimal-kernel-tuning-parameter-prediction-using-deep] or center-sensitive kernel optimization [https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/center-sensitive-kernel-optimization-efficient-device-incremental]. Exploring these synergies could lead to even more effective optimization strategies.
Overall, the "Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop" method represents a promising step forward in the field of kernel scheduler optimization for tensor programs, and the authors have presented a well-designed study to support their claims. Further research and real-world deployment will help to validate the broader applicability and impact of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach to fine-tuning kernel schedulers for tensor programs, called "Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop." The key innovation is the use of a coordinate descent optimization algorithm to efficiently search the parameter space and find the optimal kernel configuration.
The researchers demonstrate the benefits of their approach through extensive experiments, showing improvements in both runtime and energy efficiency compared to existing kernel scheduling techniques. This is an important finding, as optimizing the performance of tensor programs is crucial for many cutting-edge applications in machine learning, scientific computing, and beyond.
While the paper presents a compelling solution, there are a few areas for potential improvement and further research, such as scalability, generalizability, and integration with other optimization techniques. Overall, the "Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop" method represents a significant step forward in the field of kernel scheduler optimization and has the potential to drive further advancements in the performance of tensor programs.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Explore as a Storm, Exploit as a Raindrop: On the Benefit of Fine-Tuning Kernel Schedulers with Coordinate Descent
Michael Canesche, Gaurav Verma, Fernando Magno Quintao Pereira
Machine-learning models consist of kernels, which are algorithms applying operations on tensors -- data indexed by a linear combination of natural numbers. Examples of kernels include convolutions, transpositions, and vectorial products. There are many ways to implement a kernel. These implementations form the kernel's optimization space. Kernel scheduling is the problem of finding the best implementation, given an objective function -- typically execution speed. Kernel optimizers such as Ansor, Halide, and AutoTVM solve this problem via search heuristics, which combine two phases: exploration and exploitation. The first step evaluates many different kernel optimization spaces. The latter tries to improve the best implementations by investigating a kernel within the same space. For example, Ansor combines kernel generation through sketches for exploration and leverages an evolutionary algorithm to exploit the best sketches. In this work, we demonstrate the potential to reduce Ansor's search time while enhancing kernel quality by incorporating Droplet Search, an AutoTVM algorithm, into Ansor's exploration phase. The approach involves limiting the number of samples explored by Ansor, selecting the best, and exploiting it with a coordinate descent algorithm. By applying this approach to the first 300 kernels that Ansor generates, we usually obtain better kernels in less time than if we let Ansor analyze 10,000 kernels. This result has been replicated in 20 well-known deep-learning models (AlexNet, ResNet, VGG, DenseNet, etc.) running on four architectures: an AMD Ryzen 7 (x86), an NVIDIA A100 tensor core, an NVIDIA RTX 3080 GPU, and an ARM A64FX. A patch with this combined approach was approved in Ansor in February 2024. As evidence of the generality of this search methodology, a similar patch, achieving equally good results, was submitted to TVM's MetaSchedule in June 2024.
Read more7/16/2024
0
Optimal Kernel Orchestration for Tensor Programs with Korch
Muyan Hu, Ashwin Venkatram, Shreyashri Biswas, Balamurugan Marimuthu, Bohan Hou, Gabriele Oliaro, Haojie Wang, Liyan Zheng, Xupeng Miao, Jidong Zhai
Kernel orchestration is the task of mapping the computation defined in different operators of a deep neural network (DNN) to the execution of GPU kernels on modern hardware platforms. Prior approaches optimize kernel orchestration by greedily applying operator fusion, which fuses the computation of multiple operators into a single kernel, and miss a variety of optimization opportunities in kernel orchestration. This paper presents Korch, a tensor program optimizer that discovers optimal kernel orchestration strategies for tensor programs. Instead of directly fusing operators, Korch first applies operator fission to decompose tensor operators into a small set of basic tensor algebra primitives. This decomposition enables a diversity of fine-grained, inter-operator optimizations. Next, Korch optimizes kernel orchestration by formalizing it as a constrained optimization problem, leveraging an off-the-shelf binary linear programming solver to discover an optimal orchestration strategy, and generating an executable that can be directly deployed on modern GPU platforms. Evaluation on a variety of DNNs shows that Korch outperforms existing tensor program optimizers by up to 1.7x on V100 GPUs and up to 1.6x on A100 GPUs. Korch is publicly available at https://github.com/humuyan/Korch.
Read more6/17/2024
0
Optimal Kernel Tuning Parameter Prediction using Deep Sequence Models
Khawir Mahmood, Jehandad Khan, Hammad Afzal
GPU kernels have come to the forefront of comput- ing due to their utility in varied fields, from high-performance computing to machine learning. A typical GPU compute kernel is invoked millions, if not billions of times in a typical application, which makes their performance highly critical. Due to the unknown nature of the optimization surface, an exhaustive search is required to discover the global optimum, which is infeasible due to the possible exponential number of parameter combinations. In this work, we propose a methodology that uses deep sequence- to-sequence models to predict the optimal tuning parameters governing compute kernels. This work considers the prediction of kernel parameters as a sequence to the sequence translation problem, borrowing models from the Natural Language Process- ing (NLP) domain. Parameters describing the input, output and weight tensors are considered as the input language to the model that emits the corresponding kernel parameters. In essence, the model translates the problem parameter language to kernel parameter language. The core contributions of this work are: a) Proposing that a sequence to sequence model can accurately learn the performance dynamics of a GPU compute kernel b) A novel network architecture which predicts the kernel tuning parameters for GPU kernels, c) A constrained beam search which incorporates the physical limits of the GPU hardware as well as other expert knowledge reducing the search space. The proposed algorithm can achieve more than 90% accuracy on various convolutional kernels in MIOpen, the AMD machine learning primitives library. As a result, the proposed technique can reduce the development time and compute resources required to tune unseen input configurations, resulting in shorter development cycles, reduced development costs, and better user experience.
Read more4/17/2024
0
Neural Optimizer Equation, Decay Function, and Learning Rate Schedule Joint Evolution
Brandon Morgan, Dean Hougen
A major contributor to the quality of a deep learning model is the selection of the optimizer. We propose a new dual-joint search space in the realm of neural optimizer search (NOS), along with an integrity check, to automate the process of finding deep learning optimizers. Our dual-joint search space simultaneously allows for the optimization of not only the update equation, but also internal decay functions and learning rate schedules for optimizers. We search the space using our proposed mutation-only, particle-based genetic algorithm able to be massively parallelized for our domain-specific problem. We evaluate our candidate optimizers on the CIFAR-10 dataset using a small ConvNet. To assess generalization, the final optimizers were then transferred to large-scale image classification on CIFAR- 100 and TinyImageNet, while also being fine-tuned on Flowers102, Cars196, and Caltech101 using EfficientNetV2Small. We found multiple optimizers, learning rate schedules, and Adam variants that outperformed Adam, as well as other standard deep learning optimizers, across the image classification tasks.
Read more4/11/2024