Exploring the Feasibility of Multimodal Chatbot AI as Copilot in Pathology Diagnostics: Generalist Model's Pitfall
0
🤖
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Pathology images are crucial for diagnosing and managing various diseases by visualizing cellular and tissue-level abnormalities.
- Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), particularly multimodal models like ChatGPT, have shown promise in transforming medical image analysis.
- However, there remains a significant gap in integrating pathology image data with these AI models for clinical applications.
- This study benchmarks the performance of GPT on pathology images, assessing their diagnostic accuracy and efficiency in real-world clinical records.
Plain English Explanation
Pathology images, which show detailed pictures of cells and tissues, are essential for doctors to diagnose and treat various diseases. Recent AI models have demonstrated impressive abilities in analyzing medical images, but they have not been widely used with pathology images in real-world clinical settings.
This study tested how well a popular AI model called GPT performed on pathology images. The researchers looked at how accurate and efficient GPT was at diagnosing different diseases based on these images, using data from actual patient records. They found that GPT struggled the most with bone diseases and performed fairly well with other types of diseases. While GPT could generally identify abnormalities in the images, it had trouble with the precise medical terminology and struggled to fully integrate the image and text information.
The study highlights the limitations of current generalist AI models like GPT when it comes to working with specialized medical data like pathology images. More work is needed to improve the integration of pathology images and advanced AI systems to better support clinical decision-making.
Technical Explanation
This study benchmarks the performance of the GPT language model on pathology images, assessing its diagnostic accuracy and efficiency in real-world clinical records. Pathology images are crucial for visualizing cellular and tissue-level abnormalities to aid in the diagnosis and management of various diseases.
The researchers evaluated GPT's capabilities in interpreting pathology images across four major disease categories: bone, gastrointestinal, genitourinary, and breast. They found that GPT exhibited significant deficits in accurately diagnosing bone diseases, while demonstrating a fair-level performance for diseases in the other three systems.
Despite offering satisfactory annotations of abnormalities in the pathology images, GPT consistently underperformed in terms of terminology accuracy and multimodal integration. Specifically, the model struggled to correctly interpret immunohistochemistry results and diagnose metastatic cancers.
These findings highlight the limitations of current generalist language models, such as GPT, when applied to specialized medical domains like pathology. The study contributes to the ongoing efforts to integrate pathology image data with advanced AI systems to improve clinical decision-making and patient outcomes.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the challenges of applying generalist AI models to specialized medical domains like pathology. While the researchers acknowledge the limitations of the GPT model, they do not delve deeply into the potential reasons for its poor performance on certain disease categories, such as bone diseases.
Additionally, the study could have benefited from a more comprehensive analysis of the specific types of errors or biases exhibited by the GPT model in its pathology image interpretations. This information could help guide the development of more specialized or tailored AI models for pathology image analysis.
Furthermore, the study does not explore potential strategies or approaches for improving the integration of pathology images and advanced language models, such as through fine-tuning, domain-specific pretraining, or the incorporation of additional modalities (e.g., clinical notes, patient metadata) to enhance the model's performance and clinical relevance.
Despite these limitations, the study highlights the need for continued research and development in the intersection of pathology and AI, with the ultimate goal of improving patient care and outcomes.
Conclusion
This study demonstrates the limitations of a generalist language model like GPT when applied to the specialized domain of pathology image analysis. While GPT was able to provide satisfactory annotations of abnormalities in the images, it struggled with terminology accuracy and the integration of visual and textual information, particularly in diagnosing certain disease categories like bone diseases.
The findings underscore the need for more specialized, tailored AI models that can effectively leverage pathology image data to support clinical decision-making and improve patient care. Ongoing research and development in this area will be crucial for advancing the integration of advanced AI technologies with specialized medical domains like pathology.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤖
0
Exploring the Feasibility of Multimodal Chatbot AI as Copilot in Pathology Diagnostics: Generalist Model's Pitfall
Mianxin Liu, Jianfeng Wu, Fang Yan, Hongjun Li, Wei Wang, Shaoting Zhang, Zhe Wang
Pathology images are crucial for diagnosing and managing various diseases by visualizing cellular and tissue-level abnormalities. Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), particularly multimodal models like ChatGPT, have shown promise in transforming medical image analysis through capabilities such as medical vision-language question answering. However, there remains a significant gap in integrating pathology image data with these AI models for clinical applications. This study benchmarks the performance of GPT on pathology images, assessing their diagnostic accuracy and efficiency in real-word clinical records. We observe significant deficits of GPT in bone diseases and a fair-level performance in diseases from other three systems. Despite offering satisfactory abnormality annotations, GPT exhibits consistent disadvantage in terminology accuracy and multimodal integration. Specifically, we demonstrate GPT's failures in interpreting immunohistochemistry results and diagnosing metastatic cancers. This study highlight the weakness of current generalist GPT model and contribute to the integration of pathology and advanced AI.
Read more9/25/2024
🤖
0
Specialty-Oriented Generalist Medical AI for Chest CT Screening
Chuang Niu, Qing Lyu, Christopher D. Carothers, Parisa Kaviani, Josh Tan, Pingkun Yan, Mannudeep K. Kalra, Christopher T. Whitlow, Ge Wang
Modern medical records include a vast amount of multimodal free text clinical data and imaging data from radiology, cardiology, and digital pathology. Fully mining such big data requires multitasking; otherwise, occult but important aspects may be overlooked, adversely affecting clinical management and population healthcare. Despite remarkable successes of AI in individual tasks with single-modal data, the progress in developing generalist medical AI remains relatively slow to combine multimodal data for multitasks because of the dual challenges of data curation and model architecture. The data challenge involves querying and curating multimodal structured and unstructured text, alphanumeric, and especially 3D tomographic scans on an individual patient level for real-time decisions and on a scale to estimate population health statistics. The model challenge demands a scalable and adaptable network architecture to integrate multimodal datasets for diverse clinical tasks. Here we propose the first-of-its-kind medical multimodal-multitask foundation model (M3FM) with application in lung cancer screening and related tasks. After we curated a comprehensive multimodal multitask dataset consisting of 49 clinical data types including 163,725 chest CT series and 17 medical tasks involved in LCS, we develop a multimodal question-answering framework as a unified training and inference strategy to synergize multimodal information and perform multiple tasks via free-text prompting. M3FM consistently outperforms the state-of-the-art single-modal task-specific models, identifies multimodal data elements informative for clinical tasks and flexibly adapts to new tasks with a small out-of-distribution dataset. As a specialty-oriented generalist medical AI model, M3FM paves the way for similar breakthroughs in other areas of medicine, closing the gap between specialists and the generalist.
Read more4/16/2024
0
Potential of Multimodal Large Language Models for Data Mining of Medical Images and Free-text Reports
Yutong Zhang, Yi Pan, Tianyang Zhong, Peixin Dong, Kangni Xie, Yuxiao Liu, Hanqi Jiang, Zhengliang Liu, Shijie Zhao, Tuo Zhang, Xi Jiang, Dinggang Shen, Tianming Liu, Xin Zhang
Medical images and radiology reports are crucial for diagnosing medical conditions, highlighting the importance of quantitative analysis for clinical decision-making. However, the diversity and cross-source heterogeneity of these data challenge the generalizability of current data-mining methods. Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have recently transformed many domains, significantly affecting the medical field. Notably, Gemini-Vision-series (Gemini) and GPT-4-series (GPT-4) models have epitomized a paradigm shift in Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) for computer vision, showcasing their potential in the biomedical domain. In this study, we evaluated the performance of the Gemini, GPT-4, and 4 popular large models for an exhaustive evaluation across 14 medical imaging datasets, including 5 medical imaging categories (dermatology, radiology, dentistry, ophthalmology, and endoscopy), and 3 radiology report datasets. The investigated tasks encompass disease classification, lesion segmentation, anatomical localization, disease diagnosis, report generation, and lesion detection. Our experimental results demonstrated that Gemini-series models excelled in report generation and lesion detection but faces challenges in disease classification and anatomical localization. Conversely, GPT-series models exhibited proficiency in lesion segmentation and anatomical localization but encountered difficulties in disease diagnosis and lesion detection. Additionally, both the Gemini series and GPT series contain models that have demonstrated commendable generation efficiency. While both models hold promise in reducing physician workload, alleviating pressure on limited healthcare resources, and fostering collaboration between clinical practitioners and artificial intelligence technologies, substantial enhancements and comprehensive validations remain imperative before clinical deployment.
Read more7/9/2024
0
PathInsight: Instruction Tuning of Multimodal Datasets and Models for Intelligence Assisted Diagnosis in Histopathology
Xiaomin Wu, Rui Xu, Pengchen Wei, Wenkang Qin, Peixiang Huang, Ziheng Li, Lin Luo
Pathological diagnosis remains the definitive standard for identifying tumors. The rise of multimodal large models has simplified the process of integrating image analysis with textual descriptions. Despite this advancement, the substantial costs associated with training and deploying these complex multimodal models, together with a scarcity of high-quality training datasets, create a significant divide between cutting-edge technology and its application in the clinical setting. We had meticulously compiled a dataset of approximately 45,000 cases, covering over 6 different tasks, including the classification of organ tissues, generating pathology report descriptions, and addressing pathology-related questions and answers. We have fine-tuned multimodal large models, specifically LLaVA, Qwen-VL, InternLM, with this dataset to enhance instruction-based performance. We conducted a qualitative assessment of the capabilities of the base model and the fine-tuned model in performing image captioning and classification tasks on the specific dataset. The evaluation results demonstrate that the fine-tuned model exhibits proficiency in addressing typical pathological questions. We hope that by making both our models and datasets publicly available, they can be valuable to the medical and research communities.
Read more8/14/2024