Feasibility of Federated Learning from Client Databases with Different Brain Diseases and MRI Modalities
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the feasibility of using federated learning to train a model on MRI data from multiple medical institutions with different brain diseases and MRI modalities.
- Federated learning is a technique that allows multiple parties to collaboratively train a machine learning model without sharing their raw data.
- The study aims to assess the potential benefits and challenges of this approach compared to traditional centralized training.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at whether it's possible to use a technique called federated learning to train an AI model on brain MRI scans from different hospitals and medical centers. In federated learning, the hospitals would each train the model on their own data, then share the model updates with a central server, rather than sending the raw scan data itself.
This could be useful because hospitals often have restrictions on sharing patient data, but they may be willing to contribute to a shared AI model. The researchers wanted to see if this federated approach could work even when the hospitals have patients with different brain diseases and use different types of MRI scans.
The key idea is that the model would learn general features of brain anatomy and pathology by combining the knowledge from these diverse datasets, without any one hospital having to share sensitive patient information. This could lead to more powerful AI tools for diagnosing and monitoring brain conditions, while respecting patient privacy.
Technical Explanation
The paper examines the feasibility of using federated learning to train a multi-modal brain MRI segmentation model from data distributed across multiple medical institutions. The researchers used a U-Net architecture and trained it in a federated manner, with each client (hospital) updating the shared model independently on their local data.
The experiments were conducted using MRI scans from four different brain disease datasets: Alzheimer's, multiple sclerosis, brain tumors, and traumatic brain injury. These datasets had varied MRI modalities, including T1-weighted, T2-weighted, FLAIR, and diffusion-weighted images.
The federated learning approach was compared to a centralized training baseline, where all data was pooled together. The results showed that the federated model achieved comparable or even better performance than the centralized model, demonstrating the feasibility and potential benefits of this joint learning approach.
Furthermore, the researchers explored the use of foundation models to initialize the model, which led to improved performance and faster convergence compared to random initialization.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough investigation of the feasibility of federated learning for multi-modal brain MRI analysis, addressing an important challenge in the field of medical AI. By considering diverse datasets with different disease types and imaging modalities, the researchers have demonstrated the potential of this approach to leverage data from multiple sources while respecting patient privacy.
However, the study is limited to a relatively small number of datasets, and the researchers acknowledge that further validation on a larger scale would be necessary to fully assess the generalizability of their findings. Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential challenges and limitations of federated learning, such as the impact of data heterogeneity, communication overhead, or the stability of the training process.
Conclusion
The paper presents a promising approach to leveraging federated learning for multi-modal brain MRI analysis, demonstrating the feasibility of this technique even when dealing with data from different medical institutions and diverse brain diseases. This could lead to the development of more powerful and inclusive AI models for healthcare applications, while respecting patient privacy. Further research is needed to fully understand the practical implications and scalability of this approach, but this study lays an important foundation for future work in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Feasibility of Federated Learning from Client Databases with Different Brain Diseases and MRI Modalities
Felix Wagner, Wentian Xu, Pramit Saha, Ziyun Liang, Daniel Whitehouse, David Menon, Virginia Newcombe, Natalie Voets, J. Alison Noble, Konstantinos Kamnitsas
Segmentation models for brain lesions in MRI are commonly developed for a specific disease and trained on data with a predefined set of MRI modalities. Each such model cannot segment the disease using data with a different set of MRI modalities, nor can it segment any other type of disease. Moreover, this training paradigm does not allow a model to benefit from learning from heterogeneous databases that may contain scans and segmentation labels for different types of brain pathologies and diverse sets of MRI modalities. Additionally, the sensitivity of patient data often prevents centrally aggregating data, necessitating a decentralized approach. Is it feasible to use Federated Learning (FL) to train a single model on client databases that contain scans and labels of different brain pathologies and diverse sets of MRI modalities? We demonstrate promising results by combining appropriate, simple, and practical modifications to the model and training strategy: Designing a model with input channels that cover the whole set of modalities available across clients, training with random modality drop, and exploring the effects of feature normalization methods. Evaluation on 7 brain MRI databases with 5 different diseases shows that such FL framework can train a single model that is shown to be very promising in segmenting all disease types seen during training. Importantly, it is able to segment these diseases in new databases that contain sets of modalities different from those in training clients. These results demonstrate, for the first time, the feasibility and effectiveness of using Federated Learning to train a single 3D segmentation model on decentralised data with diverse brain diseases and MRI modalities, a necessary step towards leveraging heterogeneous real-world databases. Code will be made available at: https://github.com/FelixWag/FL-MultiDisease-MRI
Read more7/23/2024
0
Feasibility and benefits of joint learning from MRI databases with different brain diseases and modalities for segmentation
Wentian Xu, Matthew Moffat, Thalia Seale, Ziyun Liang, Felix Wagner, Daniel Whitehouse, David Menon, Virginia Newcombe, Natalie Voets, Abhirup Banerjee, Konstantinos Kamnitsas
Models for segmentation of brain lesions in multi-modal MRI are commonly trained for a specific pathology using a single database with a predefined set of MRI modalities, determined by a protocol for the specific disease. This work explores the following open questions: Is it feasible to train a model using multiple databases that contain varying sets of MRI modalities and annotations for different brain pathologies? Will this joint learning benefit performance on the sets of modalities and pathologies available during training? Will it enable analysis of new databases with different sets of modalities and pathologies? We develop and compare different methods and show that promising results can be achieved with appropriate, simple and practical alterations to the model and training framework. We experiment with 7 databases containing 5 types of brain pathologies and different sets of MRI modalities. Results demonstrate, for the first time, that joint training on multi-modal MRI databases with different brain pathologies and sets of modalities is feasible and offers practical benefits. It enables a single model to segment pathologies encountered during training in diverse sets of modalities, while facilitating segmentation of new types of pathologies such as via follow-up fine-tuning. The insights this study provides into the potential and limitations of this paradigm should prove useful for guiding future advances in the direction. Code and pretrained models: https://github.com/WenTXuL/MultiUnet
Read more5/30/2024
0
Multi-Modal Federated Learning for Cancer Staging over Non-IID Datasets with Unbalanced Modalities
Kasra Borazjani, Naji Khosravan, Leslie Ying, Seyyedali Hosseinalipour
The use of machine learning (ML) for cancer staging through medical image analysis has gained substantial interest across medical disciplines. When accompanied by the innovative federated learning (FL) framework, ML techniques can further overcome privacy concerns related to patient data exposure. Given the frequent presence of diverse data modalities within patient records, leveraging FL in a multi-modal learning framework holds considerable promise for cancer staging. However, existing works on multi-modal FL often presume that all data-collecting institutions have access to all data modalities. This oversimplified approach neglects institutions that have access to only a portion of data modalities within the system. In this work, we introduce a novel FL architecture designed to accommodate not only the heterogeneity of data samples, but also the inherent heterogeneity/non-uniformity of data modalities across institutions. We shed light on the challenges associated with varying convergence speeds observed across different data modalities within our FL system. Subsequently, we propose a solution to tackle these challenges by devising a distributed gradient blending and proximity-aware client weighting strategy tailored for multi-modal FL. To show the superiority of our method, we conduct experiments using The Cancer Genome Atlas program (TCGA) datalake considering different cancer types and three modalities of data: mRNA sequences, histopathological image data, and clinical information. Our results further unveil the impact and severity of class-based vs type-based heterogeneity across institutions on the model performance, which widens the perspective to the notion of data heterogeneity in multi-modal FL literature.
Read more7/15/2024
0
Fed-MUnet: Multi-modal Federated Unet for Brain Tumor Segmentation
Ruojun Zhou, Lisha Qu, Lei Zhang, Ziming Li, Hongwei Yu, Bing Luo
Deep learning-based techniques have been widely utilized for brain tumor segmentation using both single and multi-modal Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) images. Most current studies focus on centralized training due to the intrinsic challenge of data sharing across clinics. To mitigate privacy concerns, researchers have introduced Federated Learning (FL) methods to brain tumor segmentation tasks. However, currently such methods are focusing on single modal MRI, with limited study on multi-modal MRI. The challenges include complex structure, large-scale parameters, and overfitting issues of the FL based methods using multi-modal MRI. To address the above challenges, we propose a novel multi-modal FL framework for brain tumor segmentation (Fed-MUnet) that is suitable for FL training. We evaluate our approach with the BraTS2022 datasets, which are publicly available. The experimental results demonstrate that our framework achieves FL nature of distributed learning and privacy preserving. For the enhancing tumor, tumor core and whole tumor, the mean of five major metrics were 87.5%, 90.6% and 92.2%, respectively, which were higher than SOTA methods while preserving privacy. In terms of parameters count, quantity of floating-point operations (FLOPs) and inference, Fed-MUnet is Pareto optimal compared with the state-of-the-art segmentation backbone while achieves higher performance and tackles privacy issue. Our codes are open-sourced at https://github.com/Arnold-Jun/Fed-MUnet.
Read more9/4/2024