Feature Inference Attack on Shapley Values
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel attack called "Feature Inference Attack on Shapley Values" that aims to infer the input features of a machine learning model by exploiting the model's Shapley value explanations.
- Shapley values are a popular technique used to explain the predictions of complex machine learning models by quantifying the contribution of each input feature to the final output.
- The proposed attack leverages the Shapley values to recover information about the original input features, potentially compromising the model's privacy and security.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a new way to potentially "hack" into the inner workings of machine learning models. It focuses on a technique called Shapley values, which is a method used to explain how different input features contribute to a model's final prediction.
The researchers found that by carefully analyzing the Shapley values, they could potentially infer information about the original input features used to train the model. This could be a problem because machine learning models are often used to make important decisions, and we want to make sure the models' predictions are reliable and secure.
The attack proposed in the paper shows that Shapley values, while useful for explaining models, could also be exploited by bad actors to gain unauthorized access to sensitive information about the model's inputs. This could have serious implications for the privacy and security of machine learning systems, especially in applications where the input data is confidential or proprietary.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a "Feature Inference Attack on Shapley Values" that attempts to recover information about the input features of a machine learning model by analyzing the Shapley value explanations produced by the model.
Shapley values are a popular technique used to explain the predictions of complex machine learning models. They quantify the contribution of each input feature to the final output, providing a way to understand how the model is making its decisions. The researchers show that this information can be leveraged to infer details about the original input features, potentially compromising the privacy and security of the model.
The proposed attack involves constructing a set of carefully crafted inputs and analyzing the corresponding Shapley values to recover information about the true input features. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of this attack through experiments on several benchmark datasets and machine learning models, including linear regression, decision trees, and neural networks.
The results indicate that the Feature Inference Attack can successfully recover a significant amount of information about the input features, even in the presence of noise or other obfuscation techniques. This highlights the need for further research into the security and privacy implications of model explanation methods like Shapley values.
Critical Analysis
The paper raises important concerns about the potential security and privacy risks associated with model interpretability techniques like Shapley values. While Shapley values can be useful for explaining model behavior, the authors show that this information can also be exploited by adversaries to recover sensitive details about the input data.
One limitation of the research is that it focuses on a specific attack scenario and does not explore potential countermeasures or defense mechanisms. The authors acknowledge that further work is needed to understand the broader implications of this attack and develop strategies to mitigate the risks.
Additionally, the paper does not address the trade-offs between model interpretability and security. While providing more transparent explanations of model decisions can be valuable, this transparency may also introduce new vulnerabilities that need to be carefully considered.
Overall, the "Feature Inference Attack on Shapley Values" highlights the importance of carefully evaluating the security and privacy implications of model interpretation techniques. As the use of machine learning continues to grow, it will be crucial to develop robust safeguards to protect sensitive information and ensure the trustworthiness of these systems.
Conclusion
The paper presents a novel attack that exploits Shapley value explanations to infer information about the input features of a machine learning model. This finding raises significant concerns about the security and privacy implications of model interpretability techniques, as the authors demonstrate that the transparency provided by Shapley values can also be a potential vulnerability.
While the research focuses on a specific attack scenario, it underscores the need for a more comprehensive understanding of the trade-offs between model interpretability and security. As machine learning systems become increasingly ubiquitous, it will be crucial to develop strategies to mitigate the risks identified in this paper and ensure the trustworthiness and reliability of these technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Feature Inference Attack on Shapley Values
Xinjian Luo, Yangfan Jiang, Xiaokui Xiao
As a solution concept in cooperative game theory, Shapley value is highly recognized in model interpretability studies and widely adopted by the leading Machine Learning as a Service (MLaaS) providers, such as Google, Microsoft, and IBM. However, as the Shapley value-based model interpretability methods have been thoroughly studied, few researchers consider the privacy risks incurred by Shapley values, despite that interpretability and privacy are two foundations of machine learning (ML) models. In this paper, we investigate the privacy risks of Shapley value-based model interpretability methods using feature inference attacks: reconstructing the private model inputs based on their Shapley value explanations. Specifically, we present two adversaries. The first adversary can reconstruct the private inputs by training an attack model based on an auxiliary dataset and black-box access to the model interpretability services. The second adversary, even without any background knowledge, can successfully reconstruct most of the private features by exploiting the local linear correlations between the model inputs and outputs. We perform the proposed attacks on the leading MLaaS platforms, i.e., Google Cloud, Microsoft Azure, and IBM aix360. The experimental results demonstrate the vulnerability of the state-of-the-art Shapley value-based model interpretability methods used in the leading MLaaS platforms and highlight the significance and necessity of designing privacy-preserving model interpretability methods in future studies. To our best knowledge, this is also the first work that investigates the privacy risks of Shapley values.
Read more7/17/2024
0
Fooling SHAP with Output Shuffling Attacks
Jun Yuan, Aritra Dasgupta
Explainable AI~(XAI) methods such as SHAP can help discover feature attributions in black-box models. If the method reveals a significant attribution from a ``protected feature'' (e.g., gender, race) on the model output, the model is considered unfair. However, adversarial attacks can subvert the detection of XAI methods. Previous approaches to constructing such an adversarial model require access to underlying data distribution, which may not be possible in many practical scenarios. We relax this constraint and propose a novel family of attacks, called shuffling attacks, that are data-agnostic. The proposed attack strategies can adapt any trained machine learning model to fool Shapley value-based explanations. We prove that Shapley values cannot detect shuffling attacks. However, algorithms that estimate Shapley values, such as linear SHAP and SHAP, can detect these attacks with varying degrees of effectiveness. We demonstrate the efficacy of the attack strategies by comparing the performance of linear SHAP and SHAP using real-world datasets.
Read more8/14/2024
0
Error Analysis of Shapley Value-Based Model Explanations: An Informative Perspective
Ningsheng Zhao, Jia Yuan Yu, Krzysztof Dzieciolowski, Trang Bui
Shapley value attribution (SVA) is an increasingly popular explainable AI (XAI) method, which quantifies the contribution of each feature to the model's output. However, recent work has shown that most existing methods to implement SVAs have some drawbacks, resulting in biased or unreliable explanations that fail to correctly capture the true intrinsic relationships between features and model outputs. Moreover, the mechanism and consequences of these drawbacks have not been discussed systematically. In this paper, we propose a novel error theoretical analysis framework, in which the explanation errors of SVAs are decomposed into two components: observation bias and structural bias. We further clarify the underlying causes of these two biases and demonstrate that there is a trade-off between them. Based on this error analysis framework, we develop two novel concepts: over-informative and underinformative explanations. We demonstrate how these concepts can be effectively used to understand potential errors of existing SVA methods. In particular, for the widely deployed assumption-based SVAs, we find that they can easily be under-informative due to the distribution drift caused by distributional assumptions. We propose a measurement tool to quantify such a distribution drift. Finally, our experiments illustrate how different existing SVA methods can be over- or under-informative. Our work sheds light on how errors incur in the estimation of SVAs and encourages new less error-prone methods.
Read more5/31/2024
0
Helpful or Harmful Data? Fine-tuning-free Shapley Attribution for Explaining Language Model Predictions
Jingtan Wang, Xiaoqiang Lin, Rui Qiao, Chuan-Sheng Foo, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low
The increasing complexity of foundational models underscores the necessity for explainability, particularly for fine-tuning, the most widely used training method for adapting models to downstream tasks. Instance attribution, one type of explanation, attributes the model prediction to each training example by an instance score. However, the robustness of instance scores, specifically towards dataset resampling, has been overlooked. To bridge this gap, we propose a notion of robustness on the sign of the instance score. We theoretically and empirically demonstrate that the popular leave-one-out-based methods lack robustness, while the Shapley value behaves significantly better, but at a higher computational cost. Accordingly, we introduce an efficient fine-tuning-free approximation of the Shapley value (FreeShap) for instance attribution based on the neural tangent kernel. We empirically demonstrate that FreeShap outperforms other methods for instance attribution and other data-centric applications such as data removal, data selection, and wrong label detection, and further generalize our scale to large language models (LLMs). Our code is available at https://github.com/JTWang2000/FreeShap.
Read more6/10/2024