Helpful or Harmful Data? Fine-tuning-free Shapley Attribution for Explaining Language Model Predictions

Overview

• This paper presents a fine-tuning-free approach to Shapley attribution for explaining language model predictions.
• The proposed method, called FT-Free Shapley, avoids the need for fine-tuning the language model, which can be computationally expensive and time-consuming.
• The authors demonstrate that FT-Free Shapley can provide high-quality explanations without the overhead of fine-tuning, making it a more efficient and accessible tool for interpreting language model behavior.

Plain English Explanation

Shapley attribution is a technique used to explain the predictions of machine learning models. It assigns importance scores to the input features, showing how much each feature contributes to the final prediction. However, applying Shapley attribution to large language models can be challenging, as it typically requires fine-tuning the model, which can be computationally intensive.

The researchers in this paper have developed a new approach called "FT-Free Shapley" that can provide high-quality explanations without the need for fine-tuning. Instead of fine-tuning the entire language model, they use a technique called perturbation to selectively modify the input text and measure the impact on the model's predictions. This allows them to calculate Shapley attribution scores without the overhead of fine-tuning.

The key idea is to swap out individual words in the input text with similar words, and then observe how this affects the model's output. Words that have a larger impact on the prediction are considered more important and receive higher Shapley attribution scores. By doing this selectively for each input feature, the researchers can efficiently compute the Shapley attribution without needing to fine-tune the entire language model.

This approach can be especially useful for interpreting the behavior of large, pre-trained language models, which are becoming increasingly common in a variety of applications. By providing a more efficient way to explain these models, the FT-Free Shapley method can help researchers and practitioners better understand how language models make their predictions, which is crucial for building trust and ensuring these models are used responsibly.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a fine-tuning-free approach to Shapley attribution for explaining language model predictions, called FT-Free Shapley. Instead of fine-tuning the entire language model, which can be computationally expensive, the authors propose a selective perturbation-based method to efficiently compute Shapley attribution scores.

The key steps of the FT-Free Shapley method are as follows:

1. Perturbation: For each input feature (word) in the text, the authors substitute it with similar words using a pre-computed similarity matrix. This selective perturbation allows them to measure the impact of each input feature on the model's prediction.

2. Shapley Attribution: By observing how the model's output changes when each input feature is perturbed, the researchers can calculate the Shapley attribution score for that feature. The Shapley score reflects the importance of each input in contributing to the final prediction.

3. Aggregation: The individual Shapley scores for each input feature are aggregated to provide an overall explanation of the model's prediction for the entire input text.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of FT-Free Shapley on several language understanding tasks, such as sentiment analysis and question answering. They show that the method can provide high-quality explanations without the need for fine-tuning the language model, which is a significant advantage over traditional Shapley attribution approaches.

Additionally, the paper explores the impact of different types of perturbations on the Shapley attribution scores, as well as the sensitivity of the method to the choice of similarity matrix. These analyses provide insights into the robustness and reliability of the FT-Free Shapley approach.

Critical Analysis

The FT-Free Shapley method presented in this paper offers a promising solution to the computational challenges of applying Shapley attribution to large language models. By avoiding the need for fine-tuning, the approach can provide efficient and accessible explanations of model behavior, which is crucial for building trust and responsible use of these powerful AI systems.

One potential limitation of the method is that it relies on the availability of a pre-computed similarity matrix to perturb the input features. While the authors demonstrate the use of various similarity measures, the quality of the explanations may depend on the effectiveness of these similarity matrices, particularly for domain-specific or contextual language understanding tasks.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the sensitivity of the FT-Free Shapley method to the choice of perturbation strategy or the size of the language model being explained. Further research may be needed to understand how the method performs across a broader range of language models and task domains.

Despite these potential limitations, the FT-Free Shapley approach represents an important step forward in making Shapley attribution more accessible and practical for interpreting language models. By addressing the computational challenges of fine-tuning, the method has the potential to enable more widespread use of explainable AI techniques in a variety of real-world applications.

Conclusion

The "Helpful or Harmful Data? Fine-tuning-free Shapley Attribution for Explaining Language Model Predictions" paper presents a novel approach to providing high-quality explanations for language model predictions without the need for computationally expensive fine-tuning. The FT-Free Shapley method leverages selective perturbation to efficiently compute Shapley attribution scores, making it a more accessible tool for interpreting the behavior of large, pre-trained language models.

This research demonstrates the potential of advanced explainable AI techniques to improve the transparency and trustworthiness of language models, which are increasingly being deployed in a wide range of applications. By better understanding how these models make their predictions, researchers and practitioners can work to ensure they are used responsibly and ethically, ultimately benefiting both the developers and the end-users of these powerful AI systems.