Federated Fine-tuning of Large Language Models under Heterogeneous Tasks and Client Resources
2402.11505
0
0
💬
Abstract
Federated Learning (FL) has recently been applied to the parameter-efficient fine-tuning of Large Language Models (LLMs). While promising, it raises significant challenges due to the heterogeneous resources and data distributions of clients. This study introduces FlexLoRA, a simple yet effective aggregation scheme for LLM fine-tuning, which mitigates the ``bucket effect'' in traditional FL that restricts the potential of clients with ample resources by tying them to the capabilities of the least-resourced participants. FlexLoRA allows for dynamic adjustment of local LoRA ranks, fostering the development of a global model imbued with broader, less task-specific knowledge. By synthesizing a full-size LoRA weight from individual client contributions and employing Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) for weight redistribution, FlexLoRA fully leverages heterogeneous client resources. Involving thousands of clients performing heterogeneous NLP tasks and client resources, our experiments validate the efficacy of FlexLoRA, with the federated global model achieving consistently better improvement over SOTA FL methods in downstream NLP task performance across various heterogeneous distributions. FlexLoRA's practicality is further underscored by our theoretical analysis and its seamless integration with existing LoRA-based FL methods, offering a path toward cross-device, privacy-preserving federated tuning for LLMs.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces FlexLoRA, a new aggregation scheme for fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) using federated learning (FL).
- Federated learning allows LLMs to be personalized for individual users or devices while preserving privacy, but poses challenges due to heterogeneous resources and data distributions across clients.
- FlexLoRA aims to address the "bucket effect" in traditional FL, which limits the potential of clients with abundant resources by tying them to the capabilities of the least-resourced participants.
Plain English Explanation
FlexLoRA: Mitigating the "Bucket Effect" in Federated Tuning of Large Language Models
Federated learning is a way to personalize large language models (LLMs) for individual users or devices without compromising privacy. In this approach, the model is trained on data from many different devices, rather than a central server. However, this poses challenges because the devices often have very different computing power and data available.
The authors introduce FlexLoRA, a new technique to address these challenges. Traditional federated learning can be limited by the "bucket effect" - where the overall model is restricted by the capabilities of the least powerful devices. FlexLoRA allows each device to contribute to the model in proportion to its own resources, rather than being held back by the weakest links.
This is achieved by letting each device dynamically adjust the complexity of its model updates, and then combining these updates into a full-size model. The authors show that this approach outperforms other federated learning methods across a range of natural language processing tasks, while also providing a path for privacy-preserving, cross-device tuning of LLMs.
Technical Explanation
FlexLoRA: Mitigating the "Bucket Effect" in Federated Tuning of Large Language Models
The paper introduces FlexLoRA, a novel aggregation scheme for federated fine-tuning of large language models (LLMs). Federated learning (FL) allows LLMs to be personalized for individual clients while preserving privacy, but poses challenges due to the heterogeneous resources and data distributions of clients.
FlexLoRA mitigates the "bucket effect" in traditional FL, which restricts the potential of clients with ample resources by tying them to the capabilities of the least-resourced participants. It allows for dynamic adjustment of local LoRA ranks, fostering the development of a global model with broader, less task-specific knowledge.
By synthesizing a full-size LoRA weight from individual client contributions and employing Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) for weight redistribution, FlexLoRA fully leverages heterogeneous client resources. Experiments involving thousands of clients performing diverse NLP tasks validate the efficacy of FlexLoRA, with the federated global model achieving better performance than state-of-the-art FL methods across various heterogeneous distributions.
The paper also provides a theoretical analysis and demonstrates FlexLoRA's seamless integration with existing LoRA-based FL methods, offering a path toward cross-device, privacy-preserving federated tuning for LLMs.
Critical Analysis
FlexLoRA: Mitigating the "Bucket Effect" in Federated Tuning of Large Language Models
The paper presents a compelling solution to the "bucket effect" in federated learning, which is a significant challenge for personalizing large language models (LLMs) across heterogeneous devices. By allowing clients to dynamically adjust their model complexity, FlexLoRA effectively leverages the resources of more capable devices without being held back by the least powerful participants.
However, the paper does not address the potential impact of client drift, where the local models diverge over time due to differences in data and tasks. This could limit the effectiveness of the global model aggregation, and is an important area for further research.
Additionally, the paper focuses on NLP tasks, but it would be valuable to see how FlexLoRA performs in other domains, such as computer vision or speech recognition, to assess its broader applicability. SA-FedLoRA and FLoRA are related works that explore similar approaches and could provide useful insights.
Overall, FlexLoRA represents an important step forward in addressing the challenges of federated learning for LLMs, and the authors' theoretical analysis and integration with existing methods suggest a promising path for further development and real-world deployment.
Conclusion
FlexLoRA: Mitigating the "Bucket Effect" in Federated Tuning of Large Language Models
This paper introduces FlexLoRA, a novel aggregation scheme for federated fine-tuning of large language models (LLMs). FlexLoRA addresses the "bucket effect" in traditional federated learning, which limits the potential of clients with abundant resources by tying them to the capabilities of the least-resourced participants.
By allowing dynamic adjustment of local LoRA ranks and synthesizing a full-size LoRA weight from individual client contributions, FlexLoRA effectively leverages heterogeneous client resources to develop a global model with broader, less task-specific knowledge. The authors' experiments demonstrate the efficacy of FlexLoRA, with the federated global model outperforming state-of-the-art FL methods across various heterogeneous distributions.
The paper's theoretical analysis and seamless integration with existing LoRA-based federated learning methods suggest a promising path toward cross-device, privacy-preserving federated tuning of LLMs, with potential applications in personalized language models and other areas where preserving user privacy is critical.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
FDLoRA: Personalized Federated Learning of Large Language Model via Dual LoRA Tuning
Jiaxing QI, Zhongzhi Luan, Shaohan Huang, Carol Fung, Hailong Yang, Depei Qian
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as important components across various fields, yet their training requires substantial computation resources and abundant labeled data. It poses a challenge to robustly training LLMs for individual users (clients). To tackle this challenge, the intuitive idea is to introduce federated learning (FL), which can collaboratively train models on distributed private data. However, existing methods suffer from the challenges of data heterogeneity, system heterogeneity, and model size, resulting in suboptimal performance and high costs. In this work, we proposed a variant of personalized federated learning (PFL) framework, namely FDLoRA, which allows the client to be a single device or a cluster and adopts low-rank adaptation (LoRA) tuning. FDLoRA sets dual LoRA modules on each client to capture personalized and global knowledge, respectively, and only the global LoRA module uploads parameters to the central server to aggregate cross-client knowledge. Finally, an adaptive fusion approach is employed to combine the parameters of the dual LoRAs. This enables FDLoRA to make effective use of private data distributed across different clients, thereby improving performance on the client without incurring high communication and computing costs. We conducted extensive experiments in two practice scenarios. The results demonstrate that FDLoRA outperforms six baselines in terms of performance, stability, robustness, computation cost, and communication cost.
6/13/2024
New!SplitLoRA: A Split Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning Framework for Large Language Models
Zheng Lin, Xuanjie Hu, Yuxin Zhang, Zhe Chen, Zihan Fang, Xianhao Chen, Ang Li, Praneeth Vepakomma, Yue Gao
0
0
The scalability of large language models (LLMs) in handling high-complexity models and large-scale datasets has led to tremendous successes in pivotal domains. While there is an urgent need to acquire more training data for LLMs, a concerning reality is the depletion of high-quality public datasets within a few years. In view of this, the federated learning (FL) LLM fine-tuning paradigm recently has been proposed to facilitate collaborative LLM fine-tuning on distributed private data, where multiple data owners collaboratively fine-tune a shared LLM without sharing raw data. However, the staggering model size of LLMs imposes heavy computing and communication burdens on clients, posing significant barriers to the democratization of the FL LLM fine-tuning paradigm. To address this issue, split learning (SL) has emerged as a promising solution by offloading the primary training workload to a server via model partitioning while exchanging activation/activation's gradients with smaller data sizes rather than the entire LLM. Unfortunately, research on the SL LLM fine-tuning paradigm is still in its nascent stage. To fill this gap, in this paper, we propose the first SL LLM fine-tuning framework, named SplitLoRA. SplitLoRA is built on the split federated learning (SFL) framework, amalgamating the advantages of parallel training from FL and model splitting from SL and thus greatly enhancing the training efficiency. It is worth noting that SplitLoRA is the inaugural open-source benchmark for SL LLM fine-tuning, providing a foundation for research efforts dedicated to advancing SL LLM fine-tuning. Extensive simulations validate that SplitLoRA achieves target accuracy in significantly less time than state-of-the-art LLM fine-tuning frameworks, demonstrating the superior training performance of SplitLoRA. The project page is available at https://fduinc.github.io/splitlora/.
7/2/2024
Differentially Private Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Language Model Using Federated Learning
Xiao-Yang Liu, Rongyi Zhu, Daochen Zha, Jiechao Gao, Shan Zhong, Matt White, Meikang Qiu
0
0
The surge in interest and application of large language models (LLMs) has sparked a drive to fine-tune these models to suit specific applications, such as finance and medical science. However, concerns regarding data privacy have emerged, especially when multiple stakeholders aim to collaboratively enhance LLMs using sensitive data. In this scenario, federated learning becomes a natural choice, allowing decentralized fine-tuning without exposing raw data to central servers. Motivated by this, we investigate how data privacy can be ensured in LLM fine-tuning through practical federated learning approaches, enabling secure contributions from multiple parties to enhance LLMs. Yet, challenges arise: 1) despite avoiding raw data exposure, there is a risk of inferring sensitive information from model outputs, and 2) federated learning for LLMs incurs notable communication overhead. To address these challenges, this article introduces DP-LoRA, a novel federated learning algorithm tailored for LLMs. DP-LoRA preserves data privacy by employing a Gaussian mechanism that adds noise in weight updates, maintaining individual data privacy while facilitating collaborative model training. Moreover, DP-LoRA optimizes communication efficiency via low-rank adaptation, minimizing the transmission of updated weights during distributed training. The experimental results across medical, financial, and general datasets using various LLMs demonstrate that DP-LoRA effectively ensures strict privacy constraints while minimizing communication overhead.
6/4/2024
Federated Fine-Tuning of LLMs on the Very Edge: The Good, the Bad, the Ugly
Herbert Woisetschlager, Alexander Isenko, Shiqiang Wang, Ruben Mayer, Hans-Arno Jacobsen
0
0
Large Language Models (LLM) and foundation models are popular as they offer new opportunities for individuals and businesses to improve natural language processing, interact with data, and retrieve information faster. However, training or fine-tuning LLMs requires a vast amount of data, which can be challenging to access due to legal or technical restrictions and may require private computing resources. Federated Learning (FL) is a solution designed to overcome these challenges and expand data access for deep learning applications. This paper takes a hardware-centric approach to explore how LLMs can be brought to modern edge computing systems. Our study fine-tunes the FLAN-T5 model family, ranging from 80M to 3B parameters, using FL for a text summarization task. We provide a micro-level hardware benchmark, compare the model FLOP utilization to a state-of-the-art data center GPU, and study the network utilization in realistic conditions. Our contribution is twofold: First, we evaluate the current capabilities of edge computing systems and their potential for LLM FL workloads. Second, by comparing these systems with a data-center GPU, we demonstrate the potential for improvement and the next steps toward achieving greater computational efficiency at the edge.
5/3/2024