FiCo-ITR: bridging fine-grained and coarse-grained image-text retrieval for comparative performance analysis
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a new benchmark called FiCo-ITR (Fine-grained and Coarse-grained Image-Text Retrieval) for evaluating the performance of image-text retrieval models.
- FiCo-ITR includes both fine-grained and coarse-grained retrieval tasks to provide a more comprehensive assessment of model capabilities.
- The paper presents a comparative analysis of the performance of several state-of-the-art image-text retrieval models on the FiCo-ITR benchmark.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers have developed a new way to test how well image-text retrieval models work. These models are used to find relevant images given a text description, or vice versa. The new benchmark they created, called FiCo-ITR, includes two types of retrieval tasks:
-
Fine-grained Retrieval: Matching images and text with very specific details, like "a blue car with a spoiler." This tests the model's ability to understand fine-grained visual and linguistic information.
-
Coarse-grained Retrieval: Matching images and text with more general concepts, like "a vehicle." This tests the model's ability to understand broader, higher-level relationships between images and text.
By including both fine-grained and coarse-grained tasks, the FiCo-ITR benchmark provides a more comprehensive evaluation of how well these models can link images and text. The researchers then used this benchmark to compare the performance of several state-of-the-art image-text retrieval models.
Technical Explanation
The FiCo-ITR benchmark consists of two types of image-text retrieval tasks:
-
Fine-grained Retrieval: These tasks require matching images and text with specific visual details, such as object attributes, textures, or spatial relationships. This tests the model's ability to understand and match fine-grained visual and linguistic information.
-
Coarse-grained Retrieval: These tasks involve matching images and text with more general, high-level concepts, such as object categories or scenes. This evaluates the model's capacity to capture broader, semantic-level associations between images and text.
The researchers assembled a dataset that includes both fine-grained and coarse-grained annotations for the same images and text, allowing for a comparative performance analysis. They then benchmarked several state-of-the-art image-text retrieval models on this new FiCo-ITR dataset, examining how the models performed on the different types of retrieval tasks.
Critical Analysis
The FiCo-ITR benchmark provides a more nuanced and comprehensive evaluation of image-text retrieval models compared to previous benchmarks that focused solely on coarse-grained or fine-grained retrieval. By including both types of tasks, the benchmark can reveal insights about a model's strengths and weaknesses in understanding different levels of visual and linguistic information.
However, the paper does acknowledge some limitations of the FiCo-ITR dataset. For example, the fine-grained annotations may not capture the full complexity of real-world visual attributes and interactions. Additionally, the dataset size and diversity may not fully represent the breadth of image-text relationships encountered in practical applications.
Further research could explore ways to expand the dataset or develop more sophisticated evaluation metrics to better assess a model's fine-grained and coarse-grained understanding. Incorporating additional modalities, such as video or 3D data, could also provide a more holistic evaluation of multimodal understanding.
Conclusion
The FiCo-ITR benchmark proposed in this paper represents an important step forward in the evaluation of image-text retrieval models. By incorporating both fine-grained and coarse-grained retrieval tasks, the benchmark can provide a more comprehensive assessment of a model's capabilities in understanding and relating visual and textual information at different levels of granularity. The comparative analysis of state-of-the-art models on this benchmark offers valuable insights that can guide future research and development in this field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
FiCo-ITR: bridging fine-grained and coarse-grained image-text retrieval for comparative performance analysis
Mikel Williams-Lekuona, Georgina Cosma
In the field of Image-Text Retrieval (ITR), recent advancements have leveraged large-scale Vision-Language Pretraining (VLP) for Fine-Grained (FG) instance-level retrieval, achieving high accuracy at the cost of increased computational complexity. For Coarse-Grained (CG) category-level retrieval, prominent approaches employ Cross-Modal Hashing (CMH) to prioritise efficiency, albeit at the cost of retrieval performance. Due to differences in methodologies, FG and CG models are rarely compared directly within evaluations in the literature, resulting in a lack of empirical data quantifying the retrieval performance-efficiency tradeoffs between the two. This paper addresses this gap by introducing the texttt{FiCo-ITR} library, which standardises evaluation methodologies for both FG and CG models, facilitating direct comparisons. We conduct empirical evaluations of representative models from both subfields, analysing precision, recall, and computational complexity across varying data scales. Our findings offer new insights into the performance-efficiency trade-offs between recent representative FG and CG models, highlighting their respective strengths and limitations. These findings provide the foundation necessary to make more informed decisions regarding model selection for specific retrieval tasks and highlight avenues for future research into hybrid systems that leverage the strengths of both FG and CG approaches.
Read more7/30/2024
0
Assessing Brittleness of Image-Text Retrieval Benchmarks from Vision-Language Models Perspective
Mariya Hendriksen, Shuo Zhang, Ridho Reinanda, Mohamed Yahya, Edgar Meij, Maarten de Rijke
Image-text retrieval (ITR), an important task in information retrieval (IR), is driven by pretrained vision-language models (VLMs) that consistently achieve state-of-the-art performance. However, a significant challenge lies in the brittleness of existing ITR benchmarks. In standard datasets for the task, captions often provide broad summaries of scenes, neglecting detailed information about specific concepts. Additionally, the current evaluation setup assumes simplistic binary matches between images and texts and focuses on intra-modality rather than cross-modal relationships, which can lead to misinterpretations of model performance. Motivated by this gap, in this study, we focus on examining the brittleness of the ITR evaluation pipeline with a focus on concept granularity. We start by analyzing two common benchmarks, MS-COCO and Flickr30k, and compare them with their augmented versions, MS-COCO-FG and Flickr30k-FG, given a specified set of linguistic features capturing concept granularity. We discover that Flickr30k-FG and MS COCO-FG consistently achieve higher scores across all the selected features. To investigate the performance of VLMs on coarse and fine-grained datasets, we introduce a taxonomy of perturbations. We apply these perturbations to the selected datasets. We evaluate four state-of-the-art models - ALIGN, AltCLIP, CLIP, and GroupViT - on the standard and fine-grained datasets under zero-shot conditions, with and without the applied perturbations. The results demonstrate that although perturbations generally degrade model performance, the fine-grained datasets exhibit a smaller performance drop than their standard counterparts. Moreover, the relative performance drop across all setups is consistent across all models and datasets, indicating that the issue lies within the benchmarks. We conclude the paper by providing an agenda for improving ITR evaluation pipelines.
Read more7/29/2024
0
CFIR: Fast and Effective Long-Text To Image Retrieval for Large Corpora
Zijun Long, Xuri Ge, Richard Mccreadie, Joemon Jose
Text-to-image retrieval aims to find the relevant images based on a text query, which is important in various use-cases, such as digital libraries, e-commerce, and multimedia databases. Although Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) demonstrate state-of-the-art performance, they exhibit limitations in handling large-scale, diverse, and ambiguous real-world needs of retrieval, due to the computation cost and the injective embeddings they produce. This paper presents a two-stage Coarse-to-Fine Index-shared Retrieval (CFIR) framework, designed for fast and effective large-scale long-text to image retrieval. The first stage, Entity-based Ranking (ER), adapts to long-text query ambiguity by employing a multiple-queries-to-multiple-targets paradigm, facilitating candidate filtering for the next stage. The second stage, Summary-based Re-ranking (SR), refines these rankings using summarized queries. We also propose a specialized Decoupling-BEiT-3 encoder, optimized for handling ambiguous user needs and both stages, which also enhances computational efficiency through vector-based similarity inference. Evaluation on the AToMiC dataset reveals that CFIR surpasses existing MLLMs by up to 11.06% in Recall@1000, while reducing training and retrieval times by 68.75% and 99.79%, respectively. We will release our code to facilitate future research at https://github.com/longkukuhi/CFIR.
Read more4/4/2024
0
Unified Text-to-Image Generation and Retrieval
Leigang Qu, Haochuan Li, Tan Wang, Wenjie Wang, Yongqi Li, Liqiang Nie, Tat-Seng Chua
How humans can efficiently and effectively acquire images has always been a perennial question. A typical solution is text-to-image retrieval from an existing database given the text query; however, the limited database typically lacks creativity. By contrast, recent breakthroughs in text-to-image generation have made it possible to produce fancy and diverse visual content, but it faces challenges in synthesizing knowledge-intensive images. In this work, we rethink the relationship between text-to-image generation and retrieval and propose a unified framework in the context of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). Specifically, we first explore the intrinsic discriminative abilities of MLLMs and introduce a generative retrieval method to perform retrieval in a training-free manner. Subsequently, we unify generation and retrieval in an autoregressive generation way and propose an autonomous decision module to choose the best-matched one between generated and retrieved images as the response to the text query. Additionally, we construct a benchmark called TIGeR-Bench, including creative and knowledge-intensive domains, to standardize the evaluation of unified text-to-image generation and retrieval. Extensive experimental results on TIGeR-Bench and two retrieval benchmarks, i.e., Flickr30K and MS-COCO, demonstrate the superiority and effectiveness of our proposed method.
Read more6/11/2024