Fisher-Rao distance and pullback SPD cone distances between multivariate normal distributions

Read original: arXiv:2307.10644 - Published 6/11/2024 by Frank Nielsen

🖼️

Overview

Multivariate normal distributions are commonly used in various scientific fields, such as diffusion tensor imaging, computer vision, radar signal processing, and machine learning.
To process these normal data sets for tasks like filtering, classification, or clustering, it's important to define proper notions of dissimilarity between normal distributions and the paths connecting them.
The Fisher-Rao distance, defined as the Riemannian geodesic distance induced by the Fisher information metric, is a principled metric distance, but its closed-form expression is known only for a few particular cases.
This paper presents a fast and robust method to approximate the Fisher-Rao distance between multivariate normal distributions, as well as a class of distances based on diffeomorphic embeddings of the normal manifold into a submanifold of the higher-dimensional symmetric positive-definite cone.

Plain English Explanation

Imagine you have a collection of different data sets, each representing a normal distribution. These data sets could come from various scientific fields, such as medical imaging, computer vision, or signal processing.

To work with these normal data sets, you need to be able to compare them and find the distances between them. This is important for tasks like filtering, classification, or clustering the data.

One way to measure the distance between normal distributions is the Fisher-Rao distance, which is a mathematical way of quantifying the differences between them. However, this distance is not easy to calculate in most cases, except for a few specific situations.

In this paper, the researchers developed a new way to quickly and accurately approximate the Fisher-Rao distance between normal distributions. They also introduced a different class of distances that are based on embedding the normal distributions into a higher-dimensional space, called the symmetric positive-definite cone. This new distance is easier to compute than the Fisher-Rao distance, as it only requires finding the extreme eigenvalues of some matrices.

The researchers showed how these new distance measures can be used for clustering normal data sets, which is an important task in many scientific and machine learning applications.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents two key contributions:

Fast and Robust Fisher-Rao Distance Approximation: The authors report a method to accurately approximate the Fisher-Rao distance between multivariate normal distributions. The Fisher-Rao distance is a Riemannian geodesic distance induced by the Fisher information metric, but its closed-form expression is known only for a few specific cases. The proposed approximation technique allows for arbitrarily fine approximation of this distance.
Diffeomorphic Embedding and Hilbert Cone Distance: The authors introduce a class of distances based on diffeomorphic embeddings of the normal manifold into a submanifold of the higher-dimensional symmetric positive-definite (SPD) cone. They show that the projective Hilbert distance on the SPD cone yields a metric on the embedded normal submanifold. By pulling back this cone distance and its associated straight-line Hilbert cone geodesics, they obtain a distance and smooth paths between normal distributions. Compared to the Fisher-Rao distance approximation, this Hilbert cone distance is computationally more efficient, as it only requires computing the extreme minimal and maximal eigenvalues of matrices.

The researchers demonstrate how these distance measures can be used for clustering tasks involving multivariate normal data sets, which are common in many scientific and machine learning applications.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a robust and efficient method for approximating the Fisher-Rao distance between multivariate normal distributions, as well as a novel class of distances based on diffeomorphic embeddings into the symmetric positive-definite cone. These contributions are valuable, as they address the challenge of defining appropriate dissimilarity measures and paths between normal distributions, which is crucial for downstream processing and analysis tasks.

One potential limitation of the research is that the paper does not provide a comprehensive comparison of the proposed methods with other existing approaches, such as the Riemannian Laplace approximation of the Fisher metric or Gaussian random field approximations via Stein's method. A more thorough evaluation and comparison of the computational efficiency, accuracy, and practical implications of the different distance measures would be helpful for researchers and practitioners to better understand the trade-offs and choose the most appropriate method for their specific applications.

Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential limitations or caveats of the proposed approaches. For example, it would be valuable to understand the sensitivity of the methods to factors such as the dimensionality of the normal distributions, the degree of overlap between the distributions, or the presence of outliers in the data. Approximations to the Fisher information metric in deep generative models have also been an active area of research, and a comparison to such methods could provide additional insights.

Overall, the paper makes valuable contributions to the field of dissimilarity measures between normal distributions, and the proposed techniques have the potential to be widely applicable in various scientific and machine learning domains. Further research and evaluation of the methods' limitations and practical implications would strengthen the impact of this work.

Conclusion

This paper presents two key advancements in the field of dissimilarity measures between multivariate normal distributions:

A fast and robust method to approximate the Fisher-Rao distance, which is a principled Riemannian metric for comparing normal distributions.
A class of distances based on diffeomorphic embeddings of the normal manifold into the symmetric positive-definite cone, which offers computational advantages over the Fisher-Rao distance approximation.

These contributions are significant, as they provide researchers and practitioners with powerful tools for processing and analyzing normal data sets in a wide range of scientific and machine learning applications, such as stereographic spherical-sliced Wasserstein distances. The paper demonstrates how these distance measures can be used for clustering tasks, but their potential impact extends to other areas, such as filtering, classification, and visualization of multivariate normal data.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🖼️

Fisher-Rao distance and pullback SPD cone distances between multivariate normal distributions

Frank Nielsen

Data sets of multivariate normal distributions abound in many scientific areas like diffusion tensor imaging, structure tensor computer vision, radar signal processing, machine learning, just to name a few. In order to process those normal data sets for downstream tasks like filtering, classification or clustering, one needs to define proper notions of dissimilarities between normals and paths joining them. The Fisher-Rao distance defined as the Riemannian geodesic distance induced by the Fisher information metric is such a principled metric distance which however is not known in closed-form excepts for a few particular cases. In this work, we first report a fast and robust method to approximate arbitrarily finely the Fisher-Rao distance between multivariate normal distributions. Second, we introduce a class of distances based on diffeomorphic embeddings of the normal manifold into a submanifold of the higher-dimensional symmetric positive-definite cone corresponding to the manifold of centered normal distributions. We show that the projective Hilbert distance on the cone yields a metric on the embedded normal submanifold and we pullback that cone distance with its associated straight line Hilbert cone geodesics to obtain a distance and smooth paths between normal distributions. Compared to the Fisher-Rao distance approximation, the pullback Hilbert cone distance is computationally light since it requires to compute only the extreme minimal and maximal eigenvalues of matrices. Finally, we show how to use those distances in clustering tasks.

6/11/2024

Approximation and bounding techniques for the Fisher-Rao distances between parametric statistical models

Frank Nielsen

The Fisher-Rao distance between two probability distributions of a statistical model is defined as the Riemannian geodesic distance induced by the Fisher information metric. In order to calculate the Fisher-Rao distance in closed-form, we need (1) to elicit a formula for the Fisher-Rao geodesics, and (2) to integrate the Fisher length element along those geodesics. We consider several numerically robust approximation and bounding techniques for the Fisher-Rao distances: First, we report generic upper bounds on Fisher-Rao distances based on closed-form 1D Fisher-Rao distances of submodels. Second, we describe several generic approximation schemes depending on whether the Fisher-Rao geodesics or pregeodesics are available in closed-form or not. In particular, we obtain a generic method to guarantee an arbitrarily small additive error on the approximation provided that Fisher-Rao pregeodesics and tight lower and upper bounds are available. Third, we consider the case of Fisher metrics being Hessian metrics, and report generic tight upper bounds on the Fisher-Rao distances using techniques of information geometry. Uniparametric and biparametric statistical models always have Fisher Hessian metrics, and in general a simple test allows to check whether the Fisher information matrix yields a Hessian metric or not. Fourth, we consider elliptical distribution families and show how to apply the above techniques to these models. We also propose two new distances based either on the Fisher-Rao lengths of curves serving as proxies of Fisher-Rao geodesics, or based on the Birkhoff/Hilbert projective cone distance. Last, we consider an alternative group-theoretic approach for statistical transformation models based on the notion of maximal invariant which yields insights on the structures of the Fisher-Rao distance formula which may be used fruitfully in applications.

5/24/2024

❗

Variance Norms for Kernelized Anomaly Detection

Thomas Cass, Lukas Gonon, Nikita Zozoulenko

We present a unified theory for Mahalanobis-type anomaly detection on Banach spaces, using ideas from Cameron-Martin theory applied to non-Gaussian measures. This approach leads to a basis-free, data-driven notion of anomaly distance through the so-called variance norm of a probability measure, which can be consistently estimated using empirical measures. Our framework generalizes the classical $mathbb{R}^d$, functional $(L^2[0,1])^d$, and kernelized settings, including the general case of non-injective covariance operator. We prove that the variance norm depends solely on the inner product in a given Hilbert space, and hence that the kernelized Mahalanobis distance can naturally be recovered by working on reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces. Using the variance norm, we introduce the notion of a kernelized nearest-neighbour Mahalanobis distance for semi-supervised anomaly detection. In an empirical study on 12 real-world datasets, we demonstrate that the kernelized nearest-neighbour Mahalanobis distance outperforms the traditional kernelized Mahalanobis distance for multivariate time series anomaly detection, using state-of-the-art time series kernels such as the signature, global alignment, and Volterra reservoir kernels. Moreover, we provide an initial theoretical justification of nearest-neighbour Mahalanobis distances by developing concentration inequalities in the finite-dimensional Gaussian case.

7/17/2024

🛸

Riemannian Laplace Approximation with the Fisher Metric

Hanlin Yu, Marcelo Hartmann, Bernardo Williams, Mark Girolami, Arto Klami

Laplace's method approximates a target density with a Gaussian distribution at its mode. It is computationally efficient and asymptotically exact for Bayesian inference due to the Bernstein-von Mises theorem, but for complex targets and finite-data posteriors it is often too crude an approximation. A recent generalization of the Laplace Approximation transforms the Gaussian approximation according to a chosen Riemannian geometry providing a richer approximation family, while still retaining computational efficiency. However, as shown here, its properties depend heavily on the chosen metric, indeed the metric adopted in previous work results in approximations that are overly narrow as well as being biased even at the limit of infinite data. We correct this shortcoming by developing the approximation family further, deriving two alternative variants that are exact at the limit of infinite data, extending the theoretical analysis of the method, and demonstrating practical improvements in a range of experiments.

4/30/2024