Riemannian Laplace Approximation with the Fisher Metric

Overview

• Laplace's method is a computationally efficient technique for approximating a target probability distribution with a Gaussian distribution at its mode.
• While this approach is asymptotically exact for Bayesian inference, it can be too crude an approximation for complex target distributions and finite-data posteriors.
• A recent generalization of the Laplace Approximation transforms the Gaussian approximation according to a chosen Riemannian geometry, providing a richer approximation family while retaining computational efficiency.
• However, the properties of this generalized approach depend heavily on the chosen metric, and the metric adopted in previous work results in approximations that are overly narrow and biased even in the limit of infinite data.

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a way to improve upon the standard Laplace Approximation, which is a common method used in Bayesian inference to simplify complex probability distributions. The Laplace Approximation works by replacing the target distribution with a simpler Gaussian (bell-shaped) distribution centered at the mode (peak) of the original distribution.

While the Laplace Approximation is computationally efficient and can be accurate in certain cases, it is often too crude of an approximation, especially for complex target distributions or when working with limited data. The authors introduce a generalized version of the Laplace Approximation that uses a chosen Riemannian geometry to transform the Gaussian approximation, resulting in a richer family of approximations.

However, the authors show that the properties of this generalized approximation depend heavily on the specific metric (or geometry) that is chosen. In fact, the metric used in previous work leads to approximations that are too narrow and biased, even when the amount of data approaches infinity. To address this, the authors develop two new variants of the generalized approximation that are accurate in the limit of infinite data.

Technical Explanation

The paper builds on the Laplace Approximation, which is a widely used technique in Bayesian inference to simplify complex probability distributions. The Laplace Approximation replaces the target distribution with a Gaussian distribution centered at the mode (peak) of the original distribution.

The authors introduce a generalization of the Laplace Approximation that transforms the Gaussian approximation according to a chosen Riemannian geometry, as proposed in previous work. This provides a richer family of approximations while retaining the computational efficiency of the standard Laplace Approximation.

However, the authors show that the properties of this generalized approximation depend heavily on the specific metric (or geometry) that is chosen. They demonstrate that the metric used in previous work results in approximations that are overly narrow and biased, even in the limit of infinite data.

To address this issue, the authors develop two new variants of the generalized approximation that are exact in the limit of infinite data. They provide a detailed theoretical analysis of the properties of these new approximations and demonstrate practical improvements in a range of experiments.

Critical Analysis

The authors provide a thoughtful and rigorous analysis of the limitations of the previously proposed generalized Laplace Approximation and develop new variants that address these shortcomings. By deriving two alternative approximations that are exact in the limit of infinite data, the authors make an important contribution to the field of Bayesian inference.

That said, the paper does not explore the performance of the new approximations in scenarios with finite data, which is arguably the more common and practically relevant case. Additionally, the authors do not discuss the computational overhead or implementation complexity of the new variants compared to the standard Laplace Approximation or the previous generalization.

It would also be valuable for the authors to analyze the sensitivity of the new approximations to the choice of Riemannian metric and provide guidance on how to select an appropriate metric for a given problem. This could help users of the method make more informed decisions when applying it in practice.

Overall, the paper presents a significant theoretical advancement, but further research may be needed to fully understand the practical implications and tradeoffs of the proposed approximation methods.

Conclusion

This paper introduces an important generalization of the widely used Laplace Approximation, which is a computationally efficient technique for simplifying complex probability distributions in Bayesian inference. The authors show that a previous generalization of this method suffers from biases and limitations, and they develop two new variants that are accurate in the limit of infinite data.

While the theoretical analysis and experimental results are compelling, the practical implications of the new approximations require further exploration, particularly regarding their performance with finite data and the sensitivity to the choice of Riemannian metric. Nevertheless, this work represents a significant contribution to the field of Bayesian modeling and inference, providing researchers and practitioners with more powerful tools for working with complex probability distributions.