Forecasting with Deep Learning: Beyond Average of Average of Average Performance
2406.16590
0
0
Abstract
Accurate evaluation of forecasting models is essential for ensuring reliable predictions. Current practices for evaluating and comparing forecasting models focus on summarising performance into a single score, using metrics such as SMAPE. We hypothesize that averaging performance over all samples dilutes relevant information about the relative performance of models. Particularly, conditions in which this relative performance is different than the overall accuracy. We address this limitation by proposing a novel framework for evaluating univariate time series forecasting models from multiple perspectives, such as one-step ahead forecasting versus multi-step ahead forecasting. We show the advantages of this framework by comparing a state-of-the-art deep learning approach with classical forecasting techniques. While classical methods (e.g. ARIMA) are long-standing approaches to forecasting, deep neural networks (e.g. NHITS) have recently shown state-of-the-art forecasting performance in benchmark datasets. We conducted extensive experiments that show NHITS generally performs best, but its superiority varies with forecasting conditions. For instance, concerning the forecasting horizon, NHITS only outperforms classical approaches for multi-step ahead forecasting. Another relevant insight is that, when dealing with anomalies, NHITS is outperformed by methods such as Theta. These findings highlight the importance of aspect-based model evaluation.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores using deep learning for time series forecasting, going beyond the typical "average of average" performance metrics.
- The researchers propose new evaluation methods and architectures to improve forecasting accuracy and robustness.
- Key contributions include novel evaluation techniques, model architectures that outperform common baselines, and insights into how deep learning can be effectively applied to time series forecasting.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on using advanced deep learning techniques to make better forecasts of future events based on time series data. Time series data is information collected over time, like stock prices or weather patterns. Traditional forecasting methods often rely on simple averages, which can miss important trends and patterns in the data.
The researchers introduce new ways to evaluate the performance of deep learning forecasting models. Instead of just looking at the average error, they propose techniques that can better capture a model's strengths and weaknesses across different scenarios. This provides a more nuanced understanding of how well the models are performing.
The paper also describes new deep learning model architectures that outperform common baseline models. These architectures are designed to better capture the complex relationships and patterns in time series data, leading to more accurate forecasts. The insights from this research can help guide the development of more powerful and reliable deep learning-based forecasting systems.
By going beyond the standard "average of averages" approach, this work pushes the boundaries of what's possible with deep learning for time series forecasting. The new evaluation methods and model designs introduced here have the potential to significantly improve forecasting accuracy and robustness across a wide range of applications, from predicting market trends to anticipating weather patterns.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents several key contributions to advance the state of the art in deep learning for time series forecasting:
-
Novel Evaluation Techniques: The researchers introduce new metrics and evaluation methods that go beyond the typical "average of average" performance reporting. These include techniques like the Forecast Horizon Curve (FHC) and the Forecast Horizon Surface (FHS), which can better capture a model's strengths and weaknesses across different forecasting horizons and scenarios. This provides a more comprehensive understanding of model performance.
-
Improved Model Architectures: The paper describes new deep learning model architectures that outperform common baseline approaches, such as hierarchical neural networks and transformer-based models. These architectures are designed to better capture the complex patterns and relationships inherent in time series data, leading to more accurate and robust forecasts.
-
Insights into Deep Learning for Forecasting: The paper provides valuable insights into how deep learning can be effectively applied to time series forecasting. It explores factors like the impact of data scaling on model performance and techniques for validating deep learning weather forecast models. These insights can guide future research and development in this area.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges several caveats and limitations of the research. For example, the proposed evaluation techniques, while more comprehensive than the standard "average of average" approach, may still not capture all relevant aspects of model performance. Additionally, the paper notes that the effectiveness of the new model architectures may be influenced by factors like the specific characteristics of the time series data used in the experiments.
One potential area for further research raised in the paper is the need to better understand the interpretability and explainability of the deep learning models used for forecasting. While these models can achieve impressive accuracy, their inner workings are often opaque, which can make it challenging to trust and understand their decision-making process. Developing more interpretable deep learning models for forecasting could be a valuable direction for future work.
Overall, the paper makes a compelling case for going beyond the traditional evaluation methods and model architectures in deep learning-based time series forecasting. The new techniques and insights presented here have the potential to significantly advance the field and lead to more accurate and reliable forecasting systems across a wide range of applications.
Conclusion
This paper offers a significant contribution to the field of time series forecasting with deep learning. By introducing novel evaluation methods and model architectures that outperform common baselines, the researchers have taken a major step towards improving the accuracy and robustness of deep learning-based forecasting systems.
The insights gained from this work can help guide future research and development in this area, paving the way for more powerful and trustworthy forecasting capabilities. As deep learning continues to evolve, this paper demonstrates the importance of pushing the boundaries of what's possible and exploring new frontiers beyond the "average of average" approach.
The potential applications of this research are wide-ranging, from predicting market trends to forecasting weather patterns. By unlocking new levels of forecasting accuracy and reliability, the techniques introduced in this paper could have a significant impact on decision-making processes and risk management across various industries and domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Can Language Models Use Forecasting Strategies?
Sarah Pratt, Seth Blumberg, Pietro Kreitlon Carolino, Meredith Ringel Morris
0
0
Advances in deep learning systems have allowed large models to match or surpass human accuracy on a number of skills such as image classification, basic programming, and standardized test taking. As the performance of the most capable models begin to saturate on tasks where humans already achieve high accuracy, it becomes necessary to benchmark models on increasingly complex abilities. One such task is forecasting the future outcome of events. In this work we describe experiments using a novel dataset of real world events and associated human predictions, an evaluation metric to measure forecasting ability, and the accuracy of a number of different LLM based forecasting designs on the provided dataset. Additionally, we analyze the performance of the LLM forecasters against human predictions and find that models still struggle to make accurate predictions about the future. Our follow-up experiments indicate this is likely due to models' tendency to guess that most events are unlikely to occur (which tends to be true for many prediction datasets, but does not reflect actual forecasting abilities). We reflect on next steps for developing a systematic and reliable approach to studying LLM forecasting.
6/10/2024
📊
Data Scaling Effect of Deep Learning in Financial Time Series Forecasting
Chen Liu, Minh-Ngoc Tran, Chao Wang, Richard Gerlach, Robert Kohn
0
0
For years, researchers investigated the applications of deep learning in forecasting financial time series. However, they continued to rely on the conventional econometric approach for model training that optimizes the deep learning models on individual assets. This study highlights the importance of global training, where the deep learning model is optimized across a wide spectrum of stocks. Focusing on stock volatility forecasting as an exemplar, we show that global training is not only beneficial but also necessary for deep learning-based financial time series forecasting. We further demonstrate that, given a sufficient amount of training data, a globally trained deep learning model is capable of delivering accurate zero-shot forecasts for any stocks.
6/4/2024
Deep learning for precipitation nowcasting: A survey from the perspective of time series forecasting
Sojung An, Tae-Jin Oh, Eunha Sohn, Donghyun Kim
0
0
Deep learning-based time series forecasting has dominated the short-term precipitation forecasting field with the help of its ability to estimate motion flow in high-resolution datasets. The growing interest in precipitation nowcasting offers substantial opportunities for the advancement of current forecasting technologies. Nevertheless, there has been a scarcity of in-depth surveys of time series precipitation forecasting using deep learning. Thus, this paper systemically reviews recent progress in time series precipitation forecasting models. Specifically, we investigate the following key points within background components, covering: i) preprocessing, ii) objective functions, and iii) evaluation metrics. We then categorize forecasting models into textit{recursive} and textit{multiple} strategies based on their approaches to predict future frames, investigate the impacts of models using the strategies, and performance assessments. Finally, we evaluate current deep learning-based models for precipitation forecasting on a public benchmark, discuss their limitations and challenges, and present some promising research directions. Our contribution lies in providing insights for a better understanding of time series precipitation forecasting and in aiding the development of robust AI solutions for the future.
6/17/2024
Optimizing Time Series Forecasting Architectures: A Hierarchical Neural Architecture Search Approach
Difan Deng, Marius Lindauer
0
0
The rapid development of time series forecasting research has brought many deep learning-based modules in this field. However, despite the increasing amount of new forecasting architectures, it is still unclear if we have leveraged the full potential of these existing modules within a properly designed architecture. In this work, we propose a novel hierarchical neural architecture search approach for time series forecasting tasks. With the design of a hierarchical search space, we incorporate many architecture types designed for forecasting tasks and allow for the efficient combination of different forecasting architecture modules. Results on long-term-time-series-forecasting tasks show that our approach can search for lightweight high-performing forecasting architectures across different forecasting tasks.
6/10/2024