A Framework for Improving the Reliability of Black-box Variational Inference
2203.15945
0
0
🤯
Abstract
Black-box variational inference (BBVI) now sees widespread use in machine learning and statistics as a fast yet flexible alternative to Markov chain Monte Carlo methods for approximate Bayesian inference. However, stochastic optimization methods for BBVI remain unreliable and require substantial expertise and hand-tuning to apply effectively. In this paper, we propose Robust and Automated Black-box VI (RABVI), a framework for improving the reliability of BBVI optimization. RABVI is based on rigorously justified automation techniques, includes just a small number of intuitive tuning parameters, and detects inaccurate estimates of the optimal variational approximation. RABVI adaptively decreases the learning rate by detecting convergence of the fixed--learning-rate iterates, then estimates the symmetrized Kullback--Leibler (KL) divergence between the current variational approximation and the optimal one. It also employs a novel optimization termination criterion that enables the user to balance desired accuracy against computational cost by comparing (i) the predicted relative decrease in the symmetrized KL divergence if a smaller learning were used and (ii) the predicted computation required to converge with the smaller learning rate. We validate the robustness and accuracy of RABVI through carefully designed simulation studies and on a diverse set of real-world model and data examples.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a new framework called Robust and Automated Black-box VI (RABVI) to improve the reliability of black-box variational inference (BBVI), a popular method for approximate Bayesian inference.
- BBVI is a fast and flexible alternative to Markov chain Monte Carlo methods, but the stochastic optimization methods used for BBVI can be unreliable and require substantial expertise to apply effectively.
- RABVI aims to address these issues by automating key aspects of the optimization process and providing more robust convergence detection and termination criteria.
Plain English Explanation
Black-box variational inference (BBVI) is a widely used technique in machine learning and statistics for approximate Bayesian inference. It provides a fast and flexible way to estimate complex probability distributions, which is useful for tasks like data analysis and model building.
However, the optimization methods used for BBVI can be tricky to get right. Researchers and practitioners often need to spend a lot of time and effort tuning the optimization parameters to ensure reliable results. This can be a major barrier to using BBVI effectively.
The new RABVI framework proposed in this paper aims to make BBVI optimization more reliable and easier to use. It includes several innovative techniques to automate key aspects of the optimization process:
- Adaptive learning rate: RABVI can automatically detect when the optimization is converging and then gradually decrease the learning rate to improve accuracy.
- Convergence detection: RABVI monitors the optimization progress and can identify when the variational approximation has become sufficiently accurate, avoiding the need for extensive hand-tuning.
- Termination criterion: RABVI can balance the desired accuracy against the computational cost by comparing the predicted improvement from using a smaller learning rate versus the extra time required.
These techniques are designed to make BBVI optimization more robust and accessible, so that researchers and practitioners can more easily apply it to a wide range of real-world problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes the Robust and Automated Black-box VI (RABVI) framework to improve the reliability and usability of black-box variational inference (BBVI). BBVI is a popular method for approximate Bayesian inference that uses stochastic optimization to fit a variational approximation to the true posterior distribution.
RABVI introduces several key innovations to address the unreliability and need for extensive hand-tuning that often plague BBVI optimization:
-
Adaptive learning rate: RABVI adaptively decreases the learning rate over the course of optimization by detecting convergence of the fixed-learning-rate iterates. This helps ensure accurate estimation of the optimal variational approximation.
-
Convergence detection: RABVI estimates the symmetrized Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between the current variational approximation and the optimal one. This provides a principled way to detect when the optimization has converged sufficiently.
-
Termination criterion: RABVI employs a novel criterion that enables the user to balance desired accuracy against computational cost. It compares the predicted relative decrease in the symmetrized KL divergence if a smaller learning rate were used, versus the predicted extra computation required to converge with the smaller rate.
The authors validate RABVI's robustness and accuracy through carefully designed simulation studies and real-world model/data examples. They demonstrate that RABVI can reliably optimize BBVI models without the need for extensive hand-tuning, in contrast to standard BBVI optimization methods.
Critical Analysis
The RABVI framework proposed in this paper represents a significant advance in making black-box variational inference (BBVI) more reliable and accessible for practical use. The automated techniques for adaptive learning rate adjustment, convergence detection, and optimization termination criteria are well-justified and appear to be effective based on the empirical results.
One potential limitation is that the framework still requires the user to specify a few tuning parameters, such as the initial learning rate and the desired accuracy/computation trade-off. While these parameters are fewer and more intuitive than in standard BBVI optimization, there may still be some trial-and-error required to find the best settings for a particular problem.
Additionally, the paper focuses on BBVI, but the techniques could potentially be extended to other variational inference methods as well. It would be interesting to see how RABVI performs in the context of other variational Bayes approaches, such as those designed for robust optimization or with log-concave posteriors.
Overall, the RABVI framework represents an important advancement in making sophisticated Bayesian inference techniques more accessible and practical for a wide range of applications in machine learning and statistics.
Conclusion
This paper proposes the Robust and Automated Black-box VI (RABVI) framework, which aims to improve the reliability and usability of black-box variational inference (BBVI) for approximate Bayesian inference. RABVI introduces several key innovations, including adaptive learning rate adjustment, convergence detection, and a novel optimization termination criterion.
The empirical results demonstrate that RABVI can optimize BBVI models effectively without the need for extensive hand-tuning, in contrast to standard BBVI optimization methods. This represents an important advancement in making sophisticated Bayesian inference techniques more accessible and practical for a wide range of applications in machine learning and statistics.
While RABVI still requires some user-specified tuning parameters, it is a significant step forward in automating the BBVI optimization process. Further research could explore extending the RABVI techniques to other variational inference methods and addressing any remaining limitations or potential areas for improvement.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Batch and match: black-box variational inference with a score-based divergence
Diana Cai, Chirag Modi, Loucas Pillaud-Vivien, Charles C. Margossian, Robert M. Gower, David M. Blei, Lawrence K. Saul
0
0
Most leading implementations of black-box variational inference (BBVI) are based on optimizing a stochastic evidence lower bound (ELBO). But such approaches to BBVI often converge slowly due to the high variance of their gradient estimates and their sensitivity to hyperparameters. In this work, we propose batch and match (BaM), an alternative approach to BBVI based on a score-based divergence. Notably, this score-based divergence can be optimized by a closed-form proximal update for Gaussian variational families with full covariance matrices. We analyze the convergence of BaM when the target distribution is Gaussian, and we prove that in the limit of infinite batch size the variational parameter updates converge exponentially quickly to the target mean and covariance. We also evaluate the performance of BaM on Gaussian and non-Gaussian target distributions that arise from posterior inference in hierarchical and deep generative models. In these experiments, we find that BaM typically converges in fewer (and sometimes significantly fewer) gradient evaluations than leading implementations of BBVI based on ELBO maximization.
6/13/2024
🤯
Efficient Mixture Learning in Black-Box Variational Inference
Alexandra Hotti, Oskar Kviman, Ricky Mol'en, V'ictor Elvira, Jens Lagergren
0
0
Mixture variational distributions in black box variational inference (BBVI) have demonstrated impressive results in challenging density estimation tasks. However, currently scaling the number of mixture components can lead to a linear increase in the number of learnable parameters and a quadratic increase in inference time due to the evaluation of the evidence lower bound (ELBO). Our two key contributions address these limitations. First, we introduce the novel Multiple Importance Sampling Variational Autoencoder (MISVAE), which amortizes the mapping from input to mixture-parameter space using one-hot encodings. Fortunately, with MISVAE, each additional mixture component incurs a negligible increase in network parameters. Second, we construct two new estimators of the ELBO for mixtures in BBVI, enabling a tremendous reduction in inference time with marginal or even improved impact on performance. Collectively, our contributions enable scalability to hundreds of mixture components and provide superior estimation performance in shorter time, with fewer network parameters compared to previous Mixture VAEs. Experimenting with MISVAE, we achieve astonishing, SOTA results on MNIST. Furthermore, we empirically validate our estimators in other BBVI settings, including Bayesian phylogenetic inference, where we improve inference times for the SOTA mixture model on eight data sets.
6/12/2024
🤯
Variance Control for Black Box Variational Inference Using The James-Stein Estimator
Dominic B. Dayta
0
0
Black Box Variational Inference is a promising framework in a succession of recent efforts to make Variational Inference more ``black box. However, in basic version it either fails to converge due to instability or requires some fine-tuning of the update steps prior to execution that hinder it from being completely general purpose. We propose a method for regulating its parameter updates by reframing stochastic gradient ascent as a multivariate estimation problem. We examine the properties of the James-Stein estimator as a replacement for the arithmetic mean of Monte Carlo estimates of the gradient of the evidence lower bound. The proposed method provides relatively weaker variance reduction than Rao-Blackwellization, but offers a tradeoff of being simpler and requiring no fine tuning on the part of the analyst. Performance on benchmark datasets also demonstrate a consistent performance at par or better than the Rao-Blackwellized approach in terms of model fit and time to convergence.
5/10/2024
💬
Linear Convergence of Black-Box Variational Inference: Should We Stick the Landing?
Kyurae Kim, Yian Ma, Jacob R. Gardner
0
0
We prove that black-box variational inference (BBVI) with control variates, particularly the sticking-the-landing (STL) estimator, converges at a geometric (traditionally called linear) rate under perfect variational family specification. In particular, we prove a quadratic bound on the gradient variance of the STL estimator, one which encompasses misspecified variational families. Combined with previous works on the quadratic variance condition, this directly implies convergence of BBVI with the use of projected stochastic gradient descent. For the projection operator, we consider a domain with triangular scale matrices, which the projection onto is computable in $Theta(d)$ time, where $d$ is the dimensionality of the target posterior. We also improve existing analysis on the regular closed-form entropy gradient estimators, which enables comparison against the STL estimator, providing explicit non-asymptotic complexity guarantees for both.
4/24/2024