A Framework for Leveraging Human Computation Gaming to Enhance Knowledge Graphs for Accuracy Critical Generative AI Applications

Overview

• External knowledge graphs (KGs) can be used to enhance large language models (LLMs) and provide an explainable knowledge base that can be inspected by humans
• This approach may be particularly useful in domains where explainability is critical, like human trafficking data analysis
• However, creating KGs can be challenging as they may miss implicit connections that are obvious to humans
• The GAME-KG framework is introduced to address these challenges by using crowdsourced feedback collected through video games to modify both explicit and implicit connections in KGs

Plain English Explanation

Knowledge graphs (KGs) are structured databases that contain facts and the relationships between them. They can be used to augment large language models (LLMs), which are AI systems trained on vast amounts of text data. This approach can provide an explainable knowledge base that humans can inspect and understand, which may be particularly valuable in sensitive domains like human trafficking data analysis.

However, creating high-quality KGs can be challenging. KGs parsed from documents may include explicit connections (those directly stated in the text), but miss implicit connections that are obvious to a human reader but not directly stated. To address this, the researchers introduce the GAME-KG framework. GAME-KG uses crowdsourced feedback collected through video games to modify both the explicit and implicit connections in the KG. This helps ensure the KG is more comprehensive and accurate, while still being explainable to humans.

Technical Explanation

The researchers propose the GAME-KG framework, which stands for "Gaming for Augmenting Metadata and Enhancing Knowledge Graphs". This is a federated approach that uses crowdsourced feedback from video games to modify both the explicit and implicit connections in a KG.

The researchers demonstrate GAME-KG in two ways:

1. A Unity test scenario from the video game "Dark Shadows" that collects feedback on KGs parsed from U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) press releases on human trafficking
2. An experiment where OpenAI's GPT-4 language model is prompted to answer questions based on a modified and unmodified version of the KG

The initial results suggest that the GAME-KG framework can be an effective way to enhance KGs by capturing both explicit and implicit connections, while still maintaining an explainable set of structured facts verified by humans.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that creating high-quality KGs can be challenging, as they may miss implicit connections that are obvious to humans. The GAME-KG framework is a novel approach to addressing this issue by leveraging crowdsourced feedback from video games.

One potential limitation of the research is the scope of the demonstrations. While the Unity test scenario and GPT-4 experiment provide initial evidence of the framework's effectiveness, further testing on a larger scale and in diverse domains would be helpful to fully evaluate its capabilities and generalizability.

Additionally, the researchers do not deeply explore the potential biases or quality assurance challenges that may arise from the crowdsourcing approach. Careful consideration of these factors would be important to ensure the integrity and reliability of the knowledge graphs produced by GAME-KG.

Overall, the GAME-KG framework represents an interesting and promising approach to enhancing knowledge graphs and providing explainable AI systems. Further research and development in this area could lead to significant advancements in areas like human trafficking data analysis and other domains where transparency and trustworthiness are critical.

Conclusion

The GAME-KG framework introduces a novel approach to enhancing knowledge graphs (KGs) by leveraging crowdsourced feedback from video games. This helps capture both explicit and implicit connections in the KG, resulting in a more comprehensive and explainable knowledge base that can be used to augment large language models (LLMs).

The initial demonstrations suggest GAME-KG has the potential to be an effective tool for domains that require explainable AI, such as human trafficking data analysis. However, further research is needed to fully evaluate the framework's capabilities, address potential biases, and explore its application in diverse settings.

Overall, the GAME-KG framework represents an exciting step forward in the construction of theme-specific knowledge graphs and the alignment of human-generated knowledge graphs with large language models. Continued advancements in this area could lead to significant improvements in the transparency and trustworthiness of AI systems, with far-reaching implications for society.