Fr'echet Video Motion Distance: A Metric for Evaluating Motion Consistency in Videos
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a new metric called Fréchet Video Motion Distance (FVMD) for evaluating the consistency of motion in videos.
- FVMD is inspired by the Fréchet Inception Distance used for evaluating image generation, but adapted for video data.
- The metric aims to capture the perceptual similarity of motion sequences in a video, which is important for applications like video generation and editing.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new way to measure how well the motion in a video matches the desired or expected motion. This is called the Fréchet Video Motion Distance (FVMD).
The idea behind FVMD is to capture the "perceptual similarity" of the motion in a video. In other words, it looks at how closely the actual motion in the video matches the intended or natural-looking motion. This is important for things like creating realistic video animations or editing existing videos to change the motion.
The FVMD metric is inspired by a similar concept used to evaluate the quality of generated images, called the Fréchet Inception Distance. But the authors adapted it specifically for working with video data and motion information.
Technical Explanation
The paper first reviews related work on evaluating video quality and consistency, noting the lack of a dedicated metric for assessing motion.
The authors then introduce the Fréchet Video Motion Distance (FVMD), which is based on modeling the distribution of motion features extracted from video frames using Gaussian distributions. FVMD computes the Fréchet distance between the motion feature distributions of the reference and generated videos.
Experiments show that FVMD correlates well with human perceptual judgments of motion consistency, outperforming previous metrics. The authors also demonstrate the utility of FVMD for tasks like evaluating video generation models and video editing applications.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-motivated and technically sound approach to evaluating motion consistency in videos. The FVMD metric appears to be a significant advancement over previous methods.
However, the authors acknowledge some limitations. FVMD relies on the quality of the motion feature extraction, which could be imperfect. The metric also assumes Gaussian distributions of the motion features, which may not always hold true.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential biases or failure cases of FVMD in depth. Further research could investigate the metric's robustness to different types of motion, video content, and distortions.
Conclusion
This paper presents the Fréchet Video Motion Distance (FVMD), a new metric for evaluating the consistency of motion in videos. FVMD fills an important gap in video analysis by providing a perceptually-aligned way to measure motion quality, with applications in video generation, editing, and beyond. While the metric has some limitations, it represents a valuable contribution to the field of video understanding and analysis.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Fr'echet Video Motion Distance: A Metric for Evaluating Motion Consistency in Videos
Jiahe Liu, Youran Qu, Qi Yan, Xiaohui Zeng, Lele Wang, Renjie Liao
Significant advancements have been made in video generative models recently. Unlike image generation, video generation presents greater challenges, requiring not only generating high-quality frames but also ensuring temporal consistency across these frames. Despite the impressive progress, research on metrics for evaluating the quality of generated videos, especially concerning temporal and motion consistency, remains underexplored. To bridge this research gap, we propose Fr'echet Video Motion Distance (FVMD) metric, which focuses on evaluating motion consistency in video generation. Specifically, we design explicit motion features based on key point tracking, and then measure the similarity between these features via the Fr'echet distance. We conduct sensitivity analysis by injecting noise into real videos to verify the effectiveness of FVMD. Further, we carry out a large-scale human study, demonstrating that our metric effectively detects temporal noise and aligns better with human perceptions of generated video quality than existing metrics. Additionally, our motion features can consistently improve the performance of Video Quality Assessment (VQA) models, indicating that our approach is also applicable to unary video quality evaluation. Code is available at https://github.com/ljh0v0/FMD-frechet-motion-distance.
Read more7/24/2024
0
On the Content Bias in Fr'echet Video Distance
Songwei Ge, Aniruddha Mahapatra, Gaurav Parmar, Jun-Yan Zhu, Jia-Bin Huang
Fr'echet Video Distance (FVD), a prominent metric for evaluating video generation models, is known to conflict with human perception occasionally. In this paper, we aim to explore the extent of FVD's bias toward per-frame quality over temporal realism and identify its sources. We first quantify the FVD's sensitivity to the temporal axis by decoupling the frame and motion quality and find that the FVD increases only slightly with large temporal corruption. We then analyze the generated videos and show that via careful sampling from a large set of generated videos that do not contain motions, one can drastically decrease FVD without improving the temporal quality. Both studies suggest FVD's bias towards the quality of individual frames. We further observe that the bias can be attributed to the features extracted from a supervised video classifier trained on the content-biased dataset. We show that FVD with features extracted from the recent large-scale self-supervised video models is less biased toward image quality. Finally, we revisit a few real-world examples to validate our hypothesis.
Read more4/19/2024
0
Fr'echet Wavelet Distance: A Domain-Agnostic Metric for Image Generation
Lokesh Veeramacheneni (University of Bonn), Moritz Wolter (University of Bonn), Hildegard Kuehne (University of Bonn), Juergen Gall (University of Bonn)
Modern metrics for generative learning like Fr'echet Inception Distance (FID) demonstrate impressive performance. However, they suffer from various shortcomings, like a bias towards specific generators and datasets. To address this problem, we propose the Fr'echet Wavelet Distance (FWD) as a domain-agnostic metric based on Wavelet Packet Transform ($W_p$). FWD provides a sight across a broad spectrum of frequencies in images with a high resolution, along with preserving both spatial and textural aspects. Specifically, we use Wp to project generated and dataset images to packet coefficient space. Further, we compute Fr'echet distance with the resultant coefficients to evaluate the quality of a generator. This metric is general-purpose and dataset-domain agnostic, as it does not rely on any pre-trained network while being more interpretable because of frequency band transparency. We conclude with an extensive evaluation of a wide variety of generators across various datasets that the proposed FWD is able to generalize and improve robustness to domain shift and various corruptions compared to other metrics.
Read more6/11/2024
🎲
0
STREAM: Spatio-TempoRal Evaluation and Analysis Metric for Video Generative Models
Pum Jun Kim, Seojun Kim, Jaejun Yoo
Image generative models have made significant progress in generating realistic and diverse images, supported by comprehensive guidance from various evaluation metrics. However, current video generative models struggle to generate even short video clips, with limited tools that provide insights for improvements. Current video evaluation metrics are simple adaptations of image metrics by switching the embeddings with video embedding networks, which may underestimate the unique characteristics of video. Our analysis reveals that the widely used Frechet Video Distance (FVD) has a stronger emphasis on the spatial aspect than the temporal naturalness of video and is inherently constrained by the input size of the embedding networks used, limiting it to 16 frames. Additionally, it demonstrates considerable instability and diverges from human evaluations. To address the limitations, we propose STREAM, a new video evaluation metric uniquely designed to independently evaluate spatial and temporal aspects. This feature allows comprehensive analysis and evaluation of video generative models from various perspectives, unconstrained by video length. We provide analytical and experimental evidence demonstrating that STREAM provides an effective evaluation tool for both visual and temporal quality of videos, offering insights into area of improvement for video generative models. To the best of our knowledge, STREAM is the first evaluation metric that can separately assess the temporal and spatial aspects of videos. Our code is available at https://github.com/pro2nit/STREAM.
Read more4/1/2024