From Instruction to Insight: Exploring the Functional and Semantic Roles of Text in Interactive Dashboards
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the functional and semantic roles of text in interactive dashboards.
- It investigates how text can be used to provide instructions, convey insights, and support decision-making.
- The researchers conducted user studies to understand the impact of different text-based elements on dashboard usage and comprehension.
Plain English Explanation
Interactive dashboards are visual tools that display data and analytics in a clear, organized way. In this paper, the researchers wanted to understand how the text used in these dashboards can affect how people interact with and interpret the information.
They looked at two main ways text is used in dashboards:
- Instructional text: This includes labels, captions, and other explanations that guide users on how to read and use the dashboard.
- Insight-conveying text: This is text that directly communicates insights, findings, or conclusions drawn from the data.
Through user studies, the researchers explored how these different types of text impact a person's ability to understand the dashboard, draw their own conclusions, and make informed decisions. For example, they found that too much instructional text can actually hinder a user's ability to derive their own insights from the data visualization.
The goal was to provide guidelines and design principles for dashboard creators to strike the right balance between providing guidance and allowing users to discover their own insights.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by reviewing previous research on dashboard design and guidelines, including the importance of clear text-based elements for supporting user tasks and comprehension.
The researchers then conducted a series of user studies to investigate the functional and semantic roles of text in interactive dashboards:
-
Experiment 1: Participants used dashboards with varying amounts of instructional text to complete a series of tasks. The results showed that too much instructional text can actually impede a user's ability to draw their own insights from the data visualizations.
-
Experiment 2: Participants used dashboards that provided either instructional text or insight-conveying text. The findings indicate that insight-conveying text helps users develop a deeper understanding of the data and make more informed decisions.
-
Experiment 3: Participants used dashboards with different placements of insight-conveying text. The results suggest that strategically positioning this type of text alongside relevant visualizations can enhance comprehension and decision-making.
Overall, the paper provides empirical evidence on how the use of text in dashboards can shape the user experience and influence the generation of insights. The authors propose design guidelines to help dashboard creators leverage text in ways that balance instruction and exploration.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a well-designed and rigorous set of user studies to investigate an important issue in dashboard design. The findings offer valuable insights into how text-based elements can be leveraged to support user tasks and decision-making.
However, the research is limited to specific dashboard contexts and user populations. Further studies would be needed to evaluate the generalizability of the design guidelines across different domains, data complexity levels, and user characteristics.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the cognitive mechanisms underlying the observed effects. Understanding the psychological processes and individual differences that mediate the impact of text-based elements could lead to more tailored design recommendations.
Lastly, the authors acknowledge that their experiments focused on static dashboards, while many real-world applications involve dynamic, interactive visualizations. Exploring the roles of text in these more complex, evolving dashboard environments would be an important next step.
Conclusion
This paper makes a significant contribution to our understanding of how text can be strategically employed in interactive dashboards to enhance user experiences and insights. The findings suggest that dashboard designers should carefully consider the balance between instructional text and insight-conveying text to support both guidance and user exploration.
By providing empirical evidence and design guidelines, this research lays the groundwork for further investigations into the cognitive and interactive aspects of text in data visualization systems. Ultimately, these insights can help create dashboards that empower users to derive meaningful insights and make informed decisions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
From Instruction to Insight: Exploring the Functional and Semantic Roles of Text in Interactive Dashboards
Nicole Sultanum, Vidya Setlur
There is increased interest in the interplay between text and visuals in the field of data visualization. However, this attention has predominantly been on the use of text in standalone visualizations or augmenting text stories supported by a series of independent views. In this paper, we shift from the traditional focus on single-chart annotations to characterize the nuanced but crucial communication role of text in the complex environment of interactive dashboards. Through a survey and analysis of 190 dashboards in the wild, plus 13 expert interview sessions with experienced dashboard authors, we highlight the distinctive nature of text as an integral component of the dashboard experience, while delving into the categories, semantic levels, and functional roles of text, and exploring how these text elements are coalesced by dashboard authors to guide and inform dashboard users. Our contributions are: 1) we distill qualitative and quantitative findings from our studies to characterize current practices of text use in dashboards, including a categorization of text-based components and design patterns; 2) we leverage current practices and existing literature to propose, discuss, and validate recommended practices for text in dashboards, embodied as 12 heuristics that underscore the semantic and functional role of text in offering navigational cues, contextualizing data insights, supporting reading order, etc; 3) we reflect on our findings to identify gaps and propose opportunities for data visualization researchers to push the boundaries on text usage for dashboards, from authoring support and interactivity to text generation and content personalization. Our research underscores the significance of elevating text as a first-class citizen in data visualization, and the need to support the inclusion of textual components and their interactive affordances in dashboard design.
Read more8/9/2024
0
DASH: A Bimodal Data Exploration Tool for Interactive Text and Visualizations
Dennis Bromley, Vidya Setlur
Integrating textual content, such as titles, annotations, and captions, with visualizations facilitates comprehension and takeaways during data exploration. Yet current tools often lack mechanisms for integrating meaningful long-form prose with visual data. This paper introduces DASH, a bimodal data exploration tool that supports integrating semantic levels into the interactive process of visualization and text-based analysis. DASH operationalizes a modified version of Lundgard et al.'s semantic hierarchy model that categorizes data descriptions into four levels ranging from basic encodings to high-level insights. By leveraging this structured semantic level framework and a large language model's text generation capabilities, DASH enables the creation of data-driven narratives via drag-and-drop user interaction. Through a preliminary user evaluation, we discuss the utility of DASH's text and chart integration capabilities when participants perform data exploration with the tool.
Read more8/7/2024
📊
0
Co-Designing Unstructured Text Data Visualization Systems
Beck Langstone, Fateme Rajabiyazdi
We present our in-progress work on co-designing a visualization tool for presenting unstructured text. We have conducted a focus group with a variety of professionals who regularly analyze large corpora of unstructured text. Our preliminary insights indicate there is an unmet need to visually explore the dynamics between entities and actors extracted from unstructured text. Additionally, large corpora contain multiple perspectives on the same series of events. There is a need to disentangle these perspectives and visually show the multiple narratives present in the data. In our future work, we will co-design low-fidelity prototypes to create a broad consideration space of possible solutions for visualizing unstructured text.
Read more7/4/2024
0
Intents, Techniques, and Components: a Unified Analysis of Interaction Authoring Tasks in Data Visualization
Hyemi Song, Sai Gopinath, Zhicheng Liu
There is a growing interest in designing tools to support interactivity specification and authoring in data visualization. To develop expressive and flexible tools, we need theories and models that describe the task space of interaction authoring. Although multiple taxonomies and frameworks exist for interactive visualization, they primarily focus on how visualizations are used, not how interactivity is composed. To fill this gap, we conduct an analysis of 592 interaction units from 47 real-world visualization applications. Based on the analysis, we present a unified analysis of interaction authoring tasks across three levels of description: intents, representative techniques, and low-level implementation components. We examine our framework's descriptive, evaluative, and generative powers for critiquing existing interactivity authoring tools and informing new tool development.
Read more9/4/2024