From an Integrated Usability Framework to Lessons on Usability and Performance of Open Government Data Portals: A Comparative Study of European Union and Gulf Cooperation Council Countries

Overview

• The paper proposes an integrated usability framework for evaluating Open Government Data (OGD) portals, focusing on inclusivity, user collaboration, and data exploration.
• The framework is developed and applied to 33 OGD portals from the European Union (EU) and Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries, using a combination of quantitative and qualitative analysis.
• The study identifies best practices, common weaknesses, and provides 19 high-level recommendations for improving the open data ecosystem.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses the challenges faced by Open Government Data (OGD) initiatives, which aim to make government data accessible to the public. Despite the potential benefits, OGD portals often struggle with declining popularity, poor usability, and private interests overshadowing public accessibility.

To address these issues, the researchers developed a framework to evaluate the usability of OGD portals, focusing on inclusivity, user collaboration, and data exploration. They applied this framework to 33 OGD portals from the EU and GCC countries, using a mix of quantitative and qualitative analysis.

The study found that EU portals are generally more competitive, while GCC portals have innovative features. However, both groups could benefit from improvements, such as better multilingual support, more effective communication mechanisms, and enhanced dataset usability.

The researchers also identified trends towards exposing data quality indicators and incorporating advanced functionalities, such as AI systems. The framework developed in this study can serve as a baseline for OGD portal requirements elicitation, helping to create more sustainable, collaborative, and robust OGD portals that contribute to a more transparent and equitable world.

Technical Explanation

The researchers employed a Design Science Research (DSR) approach to develop an integrated usability framework for evaluating OGD portals. The framework focuses on three key aspects: inclusivity, user collaboration, and data exploration.

To apply the framework, the researchers analyzed 33 OGD portals from the EU and GCC countries. The quantitative analysis involved assessing the portals' performance across various metrics, while the qualitative analysis and clustering techniques enabled the identification of best practices and common weaknesses.

The study's key findings include:

• The competitive nature of EU portals and the innovative features of GCC portals
• The need for multilingual support, better communication mechanisms, and improved dataset usability
• Trends towards exposing data quality indicators and incorporating advanced functionalities, such as AI systems

Based on these findings, the researchers provided 19 high-level recommendations for improving the open data ecosystem, which can serve as a baseline for OGD portal requirements elicitation and the development of sustainable, collaborative, and robust OGD portals.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a comprehensive and well-designed study, but it also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research. For example, the researchers note that the framework's effectiveness may vary across different cultural and political contexts, and that the analysis was limited to OGD portals from the EU and GCC countries.

Additionally, while the study highlights the importance of incorporating advanced functionalities, such as AI systems, it does not provide a detailed examination of the potential challenges or ethical considerations associated with these technologies in the context of OGD portals. Further research could explore these issues in greater depth.

Overall, the paper offers a valuable contribution to the field of OGD portal development and provides a solid foundation for future research and improvements in this area.

Conclusion

This study proposes an integrated usability framework for evaluating OGD portals, with a focus on inclusivity, user collaboration, and data exploration. By applying the framework to 33 portals from the EU and GCC countries, the researchers identified best practices, common weaknesses, and provided 19 high-level recommendations for enhancing the open data ecosystem.

The findings highlight the competitive nature of EU portals, the innovative features of GCC portals, and the need for multilingual support, better communication mechanisms, and improved dataset usability. The study also emphasizes emerging trends towards exposing data quality indicators and incorporating advanced functionalities, such as AI systems.

The framework developed in this paper can serve as a baseline for OGD portal requirements elicitation, contributing to the creation of more sustainable, collaborative, and robust OGD portals that promote transparency and equity in society.