Gradient Clipping Improves AdaGrad when the Noise Is Heavy-Tailed
2406.04443
0
0
Abstract
Methods with adaptive stepsizes, such as AdaGrad and Adam, are essential for training modern Deep Learning models, especially Large Language Models. Typically, the noise in the stochastic gradients is heavy-tailed for the later ones. Gradient clipping provably helps to achieve good high-probability convergence for such noises. However, despite the similarity between AdaGrad/Adam and Clip-SGD, the high-probability convergence of AdaGrad/Adam has not been studied in this case. In this work, we prove that AdaGrad (and its delayed version) can have provably bad high-probability convergence if the noise is heavy-tailed. To fix this issue, we propose a new version of AdaGrad called Clip-RAdaGradD (Clipped Reweighted AdaGrad with Delay) and prove its high-probability convergence bounds with polylogarithmic dependence on the confidence level for smooth convex/non-convex stochastic optimization with heavy-tailed noise. Our empirical evaluations, including NLP model fine-tuning, highlight the superiority of clipped versions of AdaGrad/Adam in handling the heavy-tailed noise.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the performance of the AdaGrad optimization algorithm under heavy-tailed noise conditions.
- The authors propose an approach called "gradient clipping" to improve the robustness of AdaGrad in such scenarios.
- The paper provides theoretical analysis and empirical results demonstrating the benefits of gradient clipping for AdaGrad when the noise distribution has heavy tails.
Plain English Explanation
Optimization algorithms like AdaGrad are commonly used in machine learning to train models. These algorithms update the model's parameters based on the gradients (a measure of how the model's output changes with respect to its inputs) computed during training.
However, when the training data contains "heavy-tailed noise" - meaning that large, infrequent deviations from the average are more common than a normal distribution would suggest - the gradients can become unstable, leading to poor performance of the optimization algorithm.
The authors of this paper propose a simple technique called "gradient clipping" to address this issue. Gradient clipping puts a limit on the maximum size of the gradients used to update the model's parameters, preventing the optimizer from being overly influenced by rare, extreme gradients caused by the heavy-tailed noise.
Through both theoretical analysis and empirical experiments, the authors show that applying gradient clipping can significantly improve the performance of AdaGrad when the training data has heavy-tailed noise.
Technical Explanation
The paper analyzes the behavior of the AdaGrad optimization algorithm under heavy-tailed noise conditions, where the gradients can become unstable and lead to poor algorithm performance.
The authors propose a simple modification to AdaGrad called "gradient clipping" that puts a limit on the maximum magnitude of the gradients used to update the model's parameters. This helps to mitigate the negative impact of rare, extreme gradients caused by the heavy-tailed noise distribution.
The authors provide a theoretical analysis of the convergence properties of gradient-clipped AdaGrad, drawing connections to prior work on the convergence analysis of adaptive gradient methods under refined assumptions. They show that gradient clipping can provably improve the robustness of AdaGrad to heavy-tailed noise.
The paper also includes empirical results on both synthetic and real-world datasets, demonstrating the benefits of gradient clipping for AdaGrad in the presence of heavy-tailed noise. These findings align with other research on boosting the robustness of distributed learning by clipping gradients.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough theoretical and empirical analysis of the proposed gradient clipping technique for improving the robustness of AdaGrad to heavy-tailed noise. The authors acknowledge that the effectiveness of gradient clipping may depend on the specific problem and noise characteristics, and encourage further research to understand its broader applicability.
One potential limitation is that the paper only considers the AdaGrad optimizer, and it would be interesting to see if the benefits of gradient clipping extend to other adaptive gradient methods as well. The paper "Regularized Gradient Clipping Provably Trains Wide and Deep Neural Networks" explores the use of gradient clipping in the context of training large neural networks.
Additionally, the authors focus on the theoretical analysis of gradient-clipped AdaGrad, but more empirical exploration of its performance in diverse real-world settings could provide further insights into its practical utility.
Conclusion
This paper presents a simple yet effective technique called gradient clipping to improve the performance of the AdaGrad optimization algorithm under heavy-tailed noise conditions. The authors provide a thorough theoretical analysis and empirical validation of the benefits of gradient clipping for AdaGrad.
The findings of this work contribute to a better understanding of the robustness of optimization algorithms and can inform the design of more reliable and stable machine learning systems, especially in scenarios where the training data may contain heavy-tailed noise. The proposed gradient clipping approach can serve as a useful tool for practitioners looking to improve the performance of their models in such challenging environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
➖
High-probability Convergence Bounds for Nonlinear Stochastic Gradient Descent Under Heavy-tailed Noise
Aleksandar Armacki, Pranay Sharma, Gauri Joshi, Dragana Bajovic, Dusan Jakovetic, Soummya Kar
0
0
We study high-probability convergence guarantees of learning on streaming data in the presence of heavy-tailed noise. In the proposed scenario, the model is updated in an online fashion, as new information is observed, without storing any additional data. To combat the heavy-tailed noise, we consider a general framework of nonlinear stochastic gradient descent (SGD), providing several strong results. First, for non-convex costs and component-wise nonlinearities, we establish a convergence rate arbitrarily close to $mathcal{O}left(t^{-frac{1}{4}}right)$, whose exponent is independent of noise and problem parameters. Second, for strongly convex costs and a broader class of nonlinearities, we establish convergence of the last iterate to the optimum, with a rate $mathcal{O}left(t^{-zeta} right)$, where $zeta in (0,1)$ depends on problem parameters, noise and nonlinearity. As we show analytically and numerically, $zeta$ can be used to inform the preferred choice of nonlinearity for given problem settings. Compared to state-of-the-art, who only consider clipping, require bounded noise moments of order $eta in (1,2]$, and establish convergence rates whose exponents go to zero as $eta rightarrow 1$, we provide high-probability guarantees for a much broader class of nonlinearities and symmetric density noise, with convergence rates whose exponents are bounded away from zero, even when the noise has finite first moment only. Moreover, in the case of strongly convex functions, we demonstrate analytically and numerically that clipping is not always the optimal nonlinearity, further underlining the value of our general framework.
4/22/2024
Clip Body and Tail Separately: High Probability Guarantees for DPSGD with Heavy Tails
Haichao Sha, Yang Cao, Yong Liu, Yuncheng Wu, Ruixuan Liu, Hong Chen
0
0
Differentially Private Stochastic Gradient Descent (DPSGD) is widely utilized to preserve training data privacy in deep learning, which first clips the gradients to a predefined norm and then injects calibrated noise into the training procedure. Existing DPSGD works typically assume the gradients follow sub-Gaussian distributions and design various clipping mechanisms to optimize training performance. However, recent studies have shown that the gradients in deep learning exhibit a heavy-tail phenomenon, that is, the tails of the gradient have infinite variance, which may lead to excessive clipping loss to the gradients with existing DPSGD mechanisms. To address this problem, we propose a novel approach, Discriminative Clipping~(DC)-DPSGD, with two key designs. First, we introduce a subspace identification technique to distinguish between body and tail gradients. Second, we present a discriminative clipping mechanism that applies different clipping thresholds for body and tail gradients to reduce the clipping loss. Under the non-convex condition, ourtech{} reduces the empirical gradient norm from {${mathbb{O}left(log^{max(0,theta-1)}(T/delta)log^{2theta}(sqrt{T})right)}$} to {${mathbb{O}left(log(sqrt{T})right)}$} with heavy-tailed index $thetageq 1/2$, iterations $T$, and arbitrary probability $delta$. Extensive experiments on four real-world datasets demonstrate that our approach outperforms three baselines by up to 9.72% in terms of accuracy.
5/29/2024
A Clipped Trip: the Dynamics of SGD with Gradient Clipping in High-Dimensions
Noah Marshall, Ke Liang Xiao, Atish Agarwala, Elliot Paquette
0
0
The success of modern machine learning is due in part to the adaptive optimization methods that have been developed to deal with the difficulties of training large models over complex datasets. One such method is gradient clipping: a practical procedure with limited theoretical underpinnings. In this work, we study clipping in a least squares problem under streaming SGD. We develop a theoretical analysis of the learning dynamics in the limit of large intrinsic dimension-a model and dataset dependent notion of dimensionality. In this limit we find a deterministic equation that describes the evolution of the loss. We show that with Gaussian noise clipping cannot improve SGD performance. Yet, in other noisy settings, clipping can provide benefits with tuning of the clipping threshold. In these cases, clipping biases updates in a way beneficial to training which cannot be recovered by SGD under any schedule. We conclude with a discussion about the links between high-dimensional clipping and neural network training.
6/18/2024
🔗
Convergence Analysis of Adaptive Gradient Methods under Refined Smoothness and Noise Assumptions
Devyani Maladkar, Ruichen Jiang, Aryan Mokhtari
0
0
Adaptive gradient methods are arguably the most successful optimization algorithms for neural network training. While it is well-known that adaptive gradient methods can achieve better dimensional dependence than stochastic gradient descent (SGD) under favorable geometry for stochastic convex optimization, the theoretical justification for their success in stochastic non-convex optimization remains elusive. In this paper, we aim to close this gap by analyzing the convergence rates of AdaGrad measured by the $ell_1$-norm of the gradient. Specifically, when the objective has $L$-Lipschitz gradient and the stochastic gradient variance is bounded by $sigma^2$, we prove a worst-case convergence rate of $tilde{mathcal{O}}(frac{sqrt{d}L}{sqrt{T}} + frac{sqrt{d} sigma}{T^{1/4}})$, where $d$ is the dimension of the problem.We also present a lower bound of ${Omega}(frac{sqrt{d}}{sqrt{T}})$ for minimizing the gradient $ell_1$-norm in the deterministic setting, showing the tightness of our upper bound in the noiseless case. Moreover, under more fine-grained assumptions on the smoothness structure of the objective and the gradient noise and under favorable gradient $ell_1/ell_2$ geometry, we show that AdaGrad can potentially shave a factor of $sqrt{d}$ compared to SGD. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first result for adaptive gradient methods that demonstrates a provable gain over SGD in the non-convex setting.
6/10/2024