On Gradient-like Explanation under a Black-box Setting: When Black-box Explanations Become as Good as White-box
2308.09381
0
0
🌐
Abstract
Attribution methods shed light on the explainability of data-driven approaches such as deep learning models by uncovering the most influential features in a to-be-explained decision. While determining feature attributions via gradients delivers promising results, the internal access required for acquiring gradients can be impractical under safety concerns, thus limiting the applicability of gradient-based approaches. In response to such limited flexibility, this paper presents methodAbr~(gradient-estimation-based explanation), an approach that produces gradient-like explanations through only query-level access. The proposed approach holds a set of fundamental properties for attribution methods, which are mathematically rigorously proved, ensuring the quality of its explanations. In addition to the theoretical analysis, with a focus on image data, the experimental results empirically demonstrate the superiority of the proposed method over state-of-the-art black-box methods and its competitive performance compared to methods with full access.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new approach called methodAbr that can generate gradient-like explanations for model decisions without requiring internal access to the model.
- Gradient-based explanation methods are promising, but they require being able to compute gradients, which can be difficult or impossible in some cases.
- The proposed methodAbr approach overcomes this limitation by producing similar explanations using only query-level access to the model.
Plain English Explanation
Understanding how complex machine learning models, like deep neural networks, make decisions is an important challenge. Attribution methods can help by identifying the most influential features that contribute to a particular prediction. Gradient-based attribution methods work well, but they require being able to access the internal workings of the model, which is not always possible due to safety or security concerns.
The new methodAbr approach presented in this paper can generate similar gradient-like explanations without needing that internal access. It works by analyzing the model's responses to carefully chosen inputs to estimate the gradients, rather than computing them directly. This makes the approach more flexible and widely applicable.
The paper shows that methodAbr satisfies important properties for a good attribution method, and demonstrates that it performs well compared to other black-box explanation techniques, especially for image data.
Technical Explanation
The key idea behind methodAbr is to estimate the gradients that would be used in a gradient-based attribution method, but to do so using only query access to the model, rather than requiring internal access.
The approach works by selecting a set of carefully chosen input perturbations around the input of interest. It then analyzes the model's responses to those perturbed inputs to estimate the gradients. This allows methodAbr to generate gradient-like explanations without needing to access the model's internal parameters or architecture.
The paper provides a rigorous mathematical analysis to show that methodAbr satisfies several desirable properties for attribution methods, such as sensitivity to important features and robustness to irrelevant features.
Experimentally, the authors evaluate methodAbr on image classification tasks and compare it to other black-box explanation techniques, as well as methods that require full internal model access like LIME and Integrated Gradients. The results show that methodAbr can match or outperform these other approaches in terms of explanation quality.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the methodAbr approach, providing a rigorous theoretical analysis and strong experimental results. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
- The paper focuses on image data, so it's unclear how well the method would generalize to other types of data, such as text or tabular data.
- The experimental evaluation is limited to a small number of image classification tasks, so more comprehensive testing on a wider range of models and datasets would be helpful to fully assess the method's capabilities.
- The paper does not discuss the computational efficiency of methodAbr compared to other techniques, which could be an important practical consideration.
Overall, the methodAbr approach seems promising and the paper provides a solid foundation for further research and development in this area of model explainability.
Conclusion
This paper introduces methodAbr, a new method for generating gradient-like explanations of model decisions without requiring internal access to the model. By estimating gradients using only query-level access, methodAbr overcomes a key limitation of traditional gradient-based attribution methods, making them more widely applicable.
The theoretical analysis and experimental results presented in the paper demonstrate the effectiveness of the methodAbr approach, especially for image data. This work represents an important step forward in the quest for more explainable and transparent machine learning models, which is crucial for building public trust and ensuring the responsible deployment of these powerful technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📉
T-Explainer: A Model-Agnostic Explainability Framework Based on Gradients
Evandro S. Ortigossa, F'abio F. Dias, Brian Barr, Claudio T. Silva, Luis Gustavo Nonato
0
0
The development of machine learning applications has increased significantly in recent years, motivated by the remarkable ability of learning-powered systems to discover and generalize intricate patterns hidden in massive datasets. Modern learning models, while powerful, often exhibit a level of complexity that renders them opaque black boxes, resulting in a notable lack of transparency that hinders our ability to decipher their decision-making processes. Opacity challenges the interpretability and practical application of machine learning, especially in critical domains where understanding the underlying reasons is essential for informed decision-making. Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) rises to meet that challenge, unraveling the complexity of black boxes by providing elucidating explanations. Among the various XAI approaches, feature attribution/importance XAI stands out for its capacity to delineate the significance of input features in the prediction process. However, most existing attribution methods have limitations, such as instability, when divergent explanations may result from similar or even the same instance. In this work, we introduce T-Explainer, a novel local additive attribution explainer based on Taylor expansion endowed with desirable properties, such as local accuracy and consistency, while stable over multiple runs. We demonstrate T-Explainer's effectiveness through benchmark experiments with well-known attribution methods. In addition, T-Explainer is developed as a comprehensive XAI framework comprising quantitative metrics to assess and visualize attribution explanations.
4/26/2024
🤯
Gradient strikes back: How filtering out high frequencies improves explanations
Sabine Muzellec, Thomas Fel, Victor Boutin, L'eo and'eol, Rufin VanRullen, Thomas Serre
0
0
Attribution methods correspond to a class of explainability methods (XAI) that aim to assess how individual inputs contribute to a model's decision-making process. We have identified a significant limitation in one type of attribution methods, known as ``white-box methods. Although highly efficient, as we will show, these methods rely on a gradient signal that is often contaminated by high-frequency artifacts. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a new approach called FORGrad. This simple method effectively filters out these high-frequency artifacts using optimal cut-off frequencies tailored to the unique characteristics of each model architecture. Our findings show that FORGrad consistently enhances the performance of already existing white-box methods, enabling them to compete effectively with more accurate yet computationally demanding black-box methods. We anticipate that our research will foster broader adoption of simpler and more efficient white-box methods for explainability, offering a better balance between faithfulness and computational efficiency.
6/11/2024
Selective Explanations
Lucas Monteiro Paes, Dennis Wei, Flavio P. Calmon
0
0
Feature attribution methods explain black-box machine learning (ML) models by assigning importance scores to input features. These methods can be computationally expensive for large ML models. To address this challenge, there has been increasing efforts to develop amortized explainers, where a machine learning model is trained to predict feature attribution scores with only one inference. Despite their efficiency, amortized explainers can produce inaccurate predictions and misleading explanations. In this paper, we propose selective explanations, a novel feature attribution method that (i) detects when amortized explainers generate low-quality explanations and (ii) improves these explanations using a technique called explanations with initial guess. Our selective explanation method allows practitioners to specify the fraction of samples that receive explanations with initial guess, offering a principled way to bridge the gap between amortized explainers and their high-quality counterparts.
5/31/2024
🗣️
Causality-Aware Local Interpretable Model-Agnostic Explanations
Martina Cinquini, Riccardo Guidotti
0
0
A main drawback of eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) approaches is the feature independence assumption, hindering the study of potential variable dependencies. This leads to approximating black box behaviors by analyzing the effects on randomly generated feature values that may rarely occur in the original samples. This paper addresses this issue by integrating causal knowledge in an XAI method to enhance transparency and enable users to assess the quality of the generated explanations. Specifically, we propose a novel extension to a widely used local and model-agnostic explainer, which encodes explicit causal relationships within the data surrounding the instance being explained. Extensive experiments show that our approach overcomes the original method in terms of faithfully replicating the black-box model's mechanism and the consistency and reliability of the generated explanations.
4/16/2024