Ground-truth effects in learning-based fiber orientation distribution estimation in neonatal brains
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the effects of ground-truth data on the performance of learning-based fiber orientation distribution (FOD) estimation in neonatal brains.
- The researchers used two common FOD estimation techniques, SS3T-CSD and MSMT-CSD, and evaluated their performance on neonatal data with ground-truth FODs derived from diffusion MRI scans.
- They explored how the age domain shift between neonatal and adult data impacts the accuracy of these learning-based approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at how well machine learning models can estimate the internal structure of the brain in newborns, known as the fiber orientation distribution (FOD). Two common techniques, SS3T-CSD and MSMT-CSD, were tested on newborn brain data where the true FOD was known from medical scans.
The researchers found that the accuracy of these machine learning models decreased when applied to newborn brains, likely because the models were trained on adult brain data which is quite different from newborn brains. This "age domain shift" issue is an important challenge that needs to be addressed to make these techniques work well for infants and young children.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates the performance of two common fiber orientation distribution (FOD) estimation techniques, SS3T-CSD and MSMT-CSD, on neonatal brain data. These learning-based approaches have shown promise in adult brain imaging, but their accuracy can be affected by differences between the training data (often from adults) and the target neonatal population.
The researchers used neonatal diffusion MRI data with known ground-truth FODs to assess the SS3T-CSD and MSMT-CSD models. They found that the models exhibited significant performance degradation when applied to neonatal brains compared to adult brains, likely due to the age domain shift between the training and test data. This highlights the importance of considering the target population characteristics when developing and deploying learning-based FOD estimation techniques.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides valuable insights into the challenges of applying learning-based FOD estimation techniques to neonatal brains. The authors acknowledge that their study is limited to a relatively small dataset and that further research is needed to fully understand the impact of age domain shift on these methods.
One potential limitation is that the ground-truth FOD data used in the evaluation was also derived from diffusion MRI, which has its own inherent uncertainties and limitations. It would be interesting to see how the models perform against an even more reliable ground-truth, such as post-mortem histological data.
Additionally, the paper does not explore potential solutions to address the age domain shift problem, such as transfer learning or domain adaptation techniques. Investigating such approaches could help improve the applicability of learning-based FOD estimation in neonatal populations.
Conclusion
This paper highlights an important challenge in the field of learning-based fiber orientation distribution estimation: the impact of age domain shift between training and target populations. The researchers found that two commonly used techniques, SS3T-CSD and MSMT-CSD, exhibited significant performance degradation when applied to neonatal brains compared to adult brains.
This work underscores the need to carefully consider the target population characteristics when developing and deploying these types of machine learning models for medical applications. Further research is needed to address the age domain shift problem and improve the reliability of learning-based FOD estimation in neonatal and pediatric populations, which could have important implications for early brain development studies and clinical decision-making.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Ground-truth effects in learning-based fiber orientation distribution estimation in neonatal brains
Rizhong Lin, Hamza Kebiri, Ali Gholipour, Yufei Chen, Jean-Philippe Thiran, Davood Karimi, Meritxell Bach Cuadra
Diffusion Magnetic Resonance Imaging (dMRI) is a non-invasive method for depicting brain microstructure in vivo. Fiber orientation distributions (FODs) are mathematical representations extensively used to map white matter fiber configurations. Recently, FOD estimation with deep neural networks has seen growing success, in particular, those of neonates estimated with fewer diffusion measurements. These methods are mostly trained on target FODs reconstructed with multi-shell multi-tissue constrained spherical deconvolution (MSMT-CSD), which might not be the ideal ground truth for developing brains. Here, we investigate this hypothesis by training a state-of-the-art model based on the U-Net architecture on both MSMT-CSD and single-shell three-tissue constrained spherical deconvolution (SS3T-CSD). Our results suggest that SS3T-CSD might be more suited for neonatal brains, given that the ratio between single and multiple fiber-estimated voxels with SS3T-CSD is more realistic compared to MSMT-CSD. Additionally, increasing the number of input gradient directions significantly improves performance with SS3T-CSD over MSMT-CSD. Finally, in an age domain-shift setting, SS3T-CSD maintains robust performance across age groups, indicating its potential for more accurate neonatal brain imaging.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Diffusion Model-based FOD Restoration from High Distortion in dMRI
Shuo Huang, Lujia Zhong, Yonggang Shi
Fiber orientation distributions (FODs) is a popular model to represent the diffusion MRI (dMRI) data. However, imaging artifacts such as susceptibility-induced distortion in dMRI can cause signal loss and lead to the corrupted reconstruction of FODs, which prohibits successful fiber tracking and connectivity analysis in affected brain regions such as the brain stem. Generative models, such as the diffusion models, have been successfully applied in various image restoration tasks. However, their application on FOD images poses unique challenges since FODs are 4-dimensional data represented by spherical harmonics (SPHARM) with the 4-th dimension exhibiting order-related dependency. In this paper, we propose a novel diffusion model for FOD restoration that can recover the signal loss caused by distortion artifacts. We use volume-order encoding to enhance the ability of the diffusion model to generate individual FOD volumes at all SPHARM orders. Moreover, we add cross-attention features extracted across all SPHARM orders in generating every individual FOD volume to capture the order-related dependency across FOD volumes. We also condition the diffusion model with low-distortion FODs surrounding high-distortion areas to maintain the geometric coherence of the generated FODs. We trained and tested our model using data from the UK Biobank (n = 1315). On a test set with ground truth (n = 43), we demonstrate the high accuracy of the generated FODs in terms of root mean square errors of FOD volumes and angular errors of FOD peaks. We also apply our method to a test set with large distortion in the brain stem area (n = 1172) and demonstrate the efficacy of our method in restoring the FOD integrity and, hence, greatly improving tractography performance in affected brain regions.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Streamline tractography of the fetal brain in utero with machine learning
Weide Liu, Camilo Calixto, Simon K. Warfield, Davood Karimi
Diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (dMRI) is the only non-invasive tool for studying white matter tracts and structural connectivity of the brain. These assessments rely heavily on tractography techniques, which reconstruct virtual streamlines representing white matter fibers. Much effort has been devoted to improving tractography methodology for adult brains, while tractography of the fetal brain has been largely neglected. Fetal tractography faces unique difficulties due to low dMRI signal quality, immature and rapidly developing brain structures, and paucity of reference data. This work presents the first machine learning model for fetal tractography. The model input consists of five sources of information: (1) Fiber orientation, inferred from a diffusion tensor fit to the dMRI signal; (2) Directions of recent propagation steps; (3) Global spatial information, encoded as distances to keypoints in the brain cortex; (4) Tissue segmentation information; and (5) Prior information about the expected local fiber orientations supplied with an atlas. In order to mitigate the local tensor estimation error, a large spatial context around the current point in the diffusion tensor image is encoded using convolutional and attention neural network modules. Moreover, the diffusion tensor information at a hypothetical next point is included in the model input. Filtering rules based on anatomically constrained tractography are applied to prune implausible streamlines. We trained the model on manually-refined whole-brain fetal tractograms and validated the trained model on an independent set of 11 test scans with gestational ages between 23 and 36 weeks. Results show that our proposed method achieves superior performance across all evaluated tracts. The new method can significantly advance the capabilities of dMRI for studying normal and abnormal brain development in utero.
Read more8/27/2024
0
Detailed delineation of the fetal brain in diffusion MRI via multi-task learning
Davood Karimi, Camilo Calixto, Haykel Snoussi, Maria Camila Cortes-Albornoz, Clemente Velasco-Annis, Caitlin Rollins, Camilo Jaimes, Ali Gholipour, Simon K. Warfield
Diffusion-weighted MRI is increasingly used to study the normal and abnormal development of fetal brain in-utero. Recent studies have shown that dMRI can offer invaluable insights into the neurodevelopmental processes in the fetal stage. However, because of the low data quality and rapid brain development, reliable analysis of fetal dMRI data requires dedicated computational methods that are currently unavailable. The lack of automated methods for fast, accurate, and reproducible data analysis has seriously limited our ability to tap the potential of fetal brain dMRI for medical and scientific applications. In this work, we developed and validated a unified computational framework to (1) segment the brain tissue into white matter, cortical/subcortical gray matter, and cerebrospinal fluid, (2) segment 31 distinct white matter tracts, and (3) parcellate the brain's cortex and delineate the deep gray nuclei and white matter structures into 96 anatomically meaningful regions. We utilized a set of manual, semi-automatic, and automatic approaches to annotate 97 fetal brains. Using these labels, we developed and validated a multi-task deep learning method to perform the three computations. Our evaluations show that the new method can accurately carry out all three tasks, achieving a mean Dice similarity coefficient of 0.865 on tissue segmentation, 0.825 on white matter tract segmentation, and 0.819 on parcellation. The proposed method can greatly advance the field of fetal neuroimaging as it can lead to substantial improvements in fetal brain tractography, tract-specific analysis, and structural connectivity assessment.
Read more9/14/2024