Heart Murmur and Abnormal PCG Detection via Wavelet Scattering Transform & a 1D-CNN

Overview

• This paper presents an automatic and accurate heart murmur detection system from phonocardiogram (PCG) recordings.
• The researchers utilized two public PCG datasets (CirCor Digiscope 2022 and PCG 2016) to train and test three custom neural networks: a 1D convolutional neural network (CNN), a long short-term memory (LSTM) recurrent neural network (RNN), and a convolutional RNN (C-RNN).
• The key preprocessing steps included denoising, segmentation, re-labeling of noise-only segments, data normalization, and time-frequency analysis using wavelet scattering transform.
• The paper reports that the custom 1D-CNN outperformed the other two neural networks and related work in terms of accuracy, weighted accuracy, F1-score, and AUROC.

Plain English Explanation

Heart murmurs are sounds that can be heard through a stethoscope and provide valuable information about the mechanical activity of the heart. This information can help doctors diagnose various heart valve diseases.

In this study, the researchers developed an automated system to accurately detect heart murmurs from audio recordings called phonocardiograms (PCGs). They used two publicly available datasets of PCG recordings to train and test three different machine learning models: a 1D convolutional neural network (1D-CNN), a long short-term memory recurrent neural network (LSTM-RNN), and a convolutional RNN (C-RNN).

Before training the models, the researchers preprocessed the PCG data, which included steps like removing noise, identifying the different parts of the heart's sound, relabeling some segments, normalizing the data, and analyzing the time-frequency characteristics of the sounds using a mathematical technique called wavelet scattering transform.

The results showed that the custom 1D-CNN model outperformed the other two neural networks as well as previous research in accurately detecting heart murmurs. This suggests that the 1D-CNN architecture is particularly well-suited for this task.

Technical Explanation

The researchers utilized two public PCG datasets from the Physionet online database - the CirCor Digiscope 2022 dataset and the PCG 2016 dataset - to train and test their custom neural network models.

The preprocessing pipeline included several key steps:

1. Denoising: Removing unwanted noise and interference from the raw PCG recordings.
2. Segmentation: Identifying the different components of the heart's sound (e.g., the "lub-dub" sounds).
3. Re-labeling: Correcting the labels for segments that were initially mislabeled as noise.
4. Normalization: Ensuring the data had consistent scaling and characteristics.
5. Time-frequency analysis: Using wavelet scattering transform to extract informative time-frequency features from the PCG segments.

The researchers then conducted four experiments:

• E1: Utilizing the original CirCor Digiscope 2022 dataset.
• E2: Using the CirCor Digiscope 2022 dataset with additional data augmentation.
• E3: Using the cleaned and re-labeled CirCor Digiscope 2022 dataset.
• E4: Evaluating on the PCG 2016 dataset.

The results showed that the custom 1D-CNN model outperformed the LSTM-RNN and C-RNN models across multiple performance metrics, including accuracy, weighted accuracy, F1-score, and AUROC. Furthermore, the 1D-CNN model outperformed related work on the cleaned and re-labeled CirCor Digiscope 2022 dataset (experiment E3).

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive and well-designed approach to the problem of automatic heart murmur detection from PCG recordings. The researchers' attention to data preprocessing and feature engineering is particularly commendable, as these steps can greatly influence the performance of machine learning models.

However, the paper does not provide much insight into the specific architectural choices for the three neural network models or the hyperparameter tuning process. Additionally, the paper could have discussed the potential limitations of the datasets used, such as their size, diversity, and any biases or imbalances that may exist.

Furthermore, while the 1D-CNN model outperformed the other approaches, the paper does not delve into the reasons behind this superior performance. It would be helpful to understand the model's ability to capture the relevant temporal and spectral features of the PCG signals compared to the LSTM-RNN and C-RNN architectures.

Lastly, the paper could have explored the potential clinical implications of their work and discussed how the proposed system could be integrated into real-world healthcare settings, including considerations around privacy, interpretability, and deployment challenges.

Conclusion

This paper presents a promising approach for automated and accurate heart murmur detection from PCG recordings. The custom 1D-CNN model developed by the researchers outperformed related work, demonstrating the effectiveness of this neural network architecture for this task.

The findings of this study have the potential to aid clinicians in the early detection and diagnosis of various heart valve diseases, which can lead to improved patient outcomes. However, further research is needed to address the limitations and explore the practical implications of deploying such a system in real-world healthcare settings.