A Hessian for Gaussian Mixture Likelihoods in Nonlinear Least Squares
2404.05452
0
0
Abstract
This paper proposes a novel Hessian approximation for Maximum a Posteriori estimation problems in robotics involving Gaussian mixture likelihoods. The proposed Hessian leads to better convergence properties. Previous approaches manipulate the Gaussian mixture likelihood into a form that allows the problem to be represented as a nonlinear least squares (NLS) problem. However, they result in an inaccurate Hessian approximation due to additional nonlinearities that are not accounted for in NLS solvers. The proposed Hessian approximation is derived by setting the Hessians of the Gaussian mixture component errors to zero, which is the same starting point as for the Gauss-Newton Hessian approximation for NLS, and using the chain rule to account for additional nonlinearities. The proposed Hessian approximation is more accurate, resulting in improved convergence properties that are demonstrated on simulated and real-world experiments. A method to maintain compatibility with existing solvers, such as ceres, is also presented. Accompanying software and supplementary material can be found at https://github.com/decargroup/hessian_sum_mixtures.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a method for computing the Hessian matrix for Gaussian mixture likelihoods in nonlinear least squares problems.
- The Hessian matrix is a crucial component in many optimization techniques, but its computation can be challenging for complex likelihood functions.
- The authors derive a closed-form expression for the Hessian of Gaussian mixture likelihoods, which can be efficiently computed and incorporated into nonlinear least squares solvers.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a mathematical technique to help optimize complex models. In many fields, scientists and engineers need to find the best set of parameters for their models to match real-world data. This is known as nonlinear least squares optimization.
A key part of this optimization process is calculating the Hessian matrix, which describes how the model's performance changes as the parameters are adjusted. However, computing the Hessian can be very challenging, especially when the model involves a mixture of Gaussian distributions, which are commonly used to represent noisy or uncertain data.
The researchers in this paper have developed a new way to calculate the Hessian for Gaussian mixture models. Their method provides a closed-form expression for the Hessian, meaning it can be computed efficiently and incorporated directly into nonlinear least squares optimization algorithms. This advance can help make these optimization techniques more accurate and reliable, with applications in [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/gaussian-process-regression-soft-inequality-monotonicity-constraints] Gaussian process regression[/link], [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/stochastic-online-optimization-cyber-physical-robotic-systems]robotic systems[/link], and other areas where complex models need to be fitted to real-world data.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on computing the Hessian matrix for Gaussian mixture likelihoods in the context of nonlinear least squares optimization. The Hessian matrix captures the second-order derivatives of the likelihood function with respect to the model parameters, and is a crucial component in many optimization techniques like Newton's method.
The authors derive a closed-form expression for the Hessian of Gaussian mixture likelihoods. This allows the Hessian to be computed efficiently and incorporated into nonlinear least squares solvers, rather than relying on approximate or numerical methods. The key steps in their derivation include:
- Representing the Gaussian mixture likelihood as a sum of individual Gaussian component likelihoods.
- Differentiating the likelihood function to obtain the gradient vector.
- Differentiating the gradient again to obtain the Hessian matrix.
The resulting Hessian expression involves terms related to the means, variances, and mixing weights of the Gaussian components, as well as the data residuals. The authors show that this Hessian can be computed in closed-form, avoiding the need for costly numerical approximations.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a rigorous mathematical treatment of the Hessian computation for Gaussian mixture likelihoods, and demonstrate the utility of their approach through numerical experiments. However, a few caveats and limitations are worth noting:
- The derivation assumes the Gaussian component parameters (means, variances, mixing weights) are known a priori. In practice, these may need to be learned or estimated from data, which could impact the Hessian computation.
- The paper focuses on the Hessian for a single data point. Extending the results to batches of data or online optimization settings [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/stochastic-online-optimization-cyber-physical-robotic-systems]may require further analysis[/link].
- The Gaussian mixture model may not be appropriate for all types of data or applications. [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/modeling-kinematic-uncertainty-tendon-driven-continuum-robots]More flexible probabilistic models[/link] may be needed in some cases.
- The paper does not explore the potential numerical stability or conditioning issues that could arise when computing the Hessian, especially for ill-conditioned problems or high-dimensional parameter spaces.
Overall, the authors have made a valuable contribution by providing a closed-form Hessian expression for Gaussian mixture likelihoods. This result can help improve the efficiency and reliability of nonlinear least squares optimization in a variety of applications. [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/investigating-combinatorial-potential-applicability-random-equation-systems]Further research[/link] on extensions and robustness of this approach would be a natural next step.
Conclusion
This paper presents a new method for efficiently computing the Hessian matrix for Gaussian mixture likelihoods in nonlinear least squares problems. The authors derive a closed-form expression for the Hessian, which can be directly incorporated into optimization algorithms without relying on approximate or numerical techniques.
This advance can help improve the accuracy and reliability of nonlinear least squares optimization in a wide range of applications, from [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/gaussian-process-regression-soft-inequality-monotonicity-constraints]Gaussian process regression[/link] to [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/stochastic-online-optimization-cyber-physical-robotic-systems]robotic systems[/link]. By providing a computationally efficient way to calculate the Hessian, the authors have made an important contribution to the field of nonlinear optimization and its many real-world use cases.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🗣️
Stochastic Hessian Fittings with Lie Groups
Xi-Lin Li
0
0
This paper studies the fitting of Hessian or its inverse for stochastic optimizations using a Hessian fitting criterion from the preconditioned stochastic gradient descent (PSGD) method, which is intimately related to many commonly used second order and adaptive gradient optimizers, e.g., BFGS, Gaussian-Newton and natural gradient descent, AdaGrad, etc. Our analyses reveal the efficiency and reliability differences among a wide range of preconditioner fitting methods, from closed-form to iterative solutions, using Hessian-vector products or stochastic gradients only, with Hessian fittings in the Euclidean space, the manifold of symmetric positive definite (SPL) matrices, to a variety of Lie groups. The most intriguing discovery is that the Hessian fitting itself as an optimization problem is strongly convex under mild conditions with a specific yet general enough Lie group. This discovery turns Hessian fitting into a well behaved optimization problem, and facilitates the designs of highly efficient and elegant Lie group sparse preconditioner fitting methods for large scale stochastic optimizations.
4/16/2024
🚀
An Adaptive Graduated Nonconvexity Loss Function for Robust Nonlinear Least Squares Solutions
Kyungmin Jung, Thomas Hitchcox, James Richard Forbes
0
0
Many problems in robotics, such as estimating the state from noisy sensor data or aligning two point clouds, can be posed and solved as least-squares problems. Unfortunately, vanilla nonminimal solvers for least-squares problems are notoriously sensitive to outliers. As such, various robust loss functions have been proposed to reduce the sensitivity to outliers. Examples of loss functions include pseudo-Huber, Cauchy, and Geman-McClure. Recently, these loss functions have been generalized into a single loss function that enables the best loss function to be found adaptively based on the distribution of the residuals. However, even with the generalized robust loss function, most nonminimal solvers can only be solved locally given a prior state estimate due to the nonconvexity of the problem. The first contribution of this paper is to combine graduated nonconvexity (GNC) with the generalized robust loss function to solve least-squares problems without a prior state estimate and without the need to specify a loss function. Moreover, existing loss functions, including the generalized loss function, are based on Gaussian-like distribution. However, residuals are often defined as the squared norm of a multivariate error and distributed in a Chi-like fashion. The second contribution of this paper is to apply a norm-aware adaptive robust loss function within a GNC framework. The proposed approach enables a GNC formulation of a generalized loss function such that GNC can be readily applied to a wider family of loss functions. Furthermore, simulations and experiments demonstrate that the proposed method is more robust compared to non-GNC counterparts, and yields faster convergence times compared to other GNC formulations.
5/14/2024
📶
Generalized Laplace Approximation
Yinsong Chen, Samson S. Yu, Zhong Li, Chee Peng Lim
0
0
In recent years, the inconsistency in Bayesian deep learning has garnered increasing attention. Tempered or generalized posterior distributions often offer a direct and effective solution to this issue. However, understanding the underlying causes and evaluating the effectiveness of generalized posteriors remain active areas of research. In this study, we introduce a unified theoretical framework to attribute Bayesian inconsistency to model misspecification and inadequate priors. We interpret the generalization of the posterior with a temperature factor as a correction for misspecified models through adjustments to the joint probability model, and the recalibration of priors by redistributing probability mass on models within the hypothesis space using data samples. Additionally, we highlight a distinctive feature of Laplace approximation, which ensures that the generalized normalizing constant can be treated as invariant, unlike the typical scenario in general Bayesian learning where this constant varies with model parameters post-generalization. Building on this insight, we propose the generalized Laplace approximation, which involves a simple adjustment to the computation of the Hessian matrix of the regularized loss function. This method offers a flexible and scalable framework for obtaining high-quality posterior distributions. We assess the performance and properties of the generalized Laplace approximation on state-of-the-art neural networks and real-world datasets.
5/27/2024
🤯
Unbiased Kinetic Langevin Monte Carlo with Inexact Gradients
Neil K. Chada, Benedict Leimkuhler, Daniel Paulin, Peter A. Whalley
0
0
We present an unbiased method for Bayesian posterior means based on kinetic Langevin dynamics that combines advanced splitting methods with enhanced gradient approximations. Our approach avoids Metropolis correction by coupling Markov chains at different discretization levels in a multilevel Monte Carlo approach. Theoretical analysis demonstrates that our proposed estimator is unbiased, attains finite variance, and satisfies a central limit theorem. It can achieve accuracy $epsilon>0$ for estimating expectations of Lipschitz functions in $d$ dimensions with $mathcal{O}(d^{1/4}epsilon^{-2})$ expected gradient evaluations, without assuming warm start. We exhibit similar bounds using both approximate and stochastic gradients, and our method's computational cost is shown to scale independently of the size of the dataset. The proposed method is tested using a multinomial regression problem on the MNIST dataset and a Poisson regression model for soccer scores. Experiments indicate that the number of gradient evaluations per effective sample is independent of dimension, even when using inexact gradients. For product distributions, we give dimension-independent variance bounds. Our results demonstrate that the unbiased algorithm we present can be much more efficient than the ``gold-standard randomized Hamiltonian Monte Carlo.
5/24/2024