Hierarchical Multi-Armed Bandits for the Concurrent Intelligent Tutoring of Concepts and Problems of Varying Difficulty Levels
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores a novel approach to intelligent tutoring systems using hierarchical multi-armed bandits.
- The system aims to concurrently tutor both concepts and problems of varying difficulty levels.
- The key idea is to model the learning process as a hierarchical multi-armed bandit problem, allowing for efficient exploration and exploitation of the best teaching strategies.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new way to create intelligent tutoring systems - computer programs that can adaptively teach students. The core idea is to model the teaching and learning process as a hierarchical multi-armed bandit problem. This allows the system to efficiently explore different teaching strategies and focus on the ones that work best for each student.
Typically, intelligent tutoring systems try to teach either broad concepts or specific problems. This paper's approach can handle both at the same time. It can decide whether to focus on teaching a high-level concept or a more detailed problem, depending on what will be most helpful for the student's current level of understanding.
By framing it as a multi-armed bandit problem, the system can quickly adapt its teaching approach to maximize the student's learning. It learns which strategies work best for each student through an exploration-exploitation tradeoff, similar to how a gambler might choose which slot machines to play. This makes the tutoring more personalized and effective.
Technical Explanation
The paper models the intelligent tutoring process as a hierarchical multi-armed bandit (HMAB) problem. The "arms" of the bandit represent different teaching strategies, such as explaining a high-level concept or working through a specific problem.
The hierarchy captures the relationship between concepts and problems of varying difficulty levels. The system must decide whether to focus on teaching a broad concept or a more detailed problem. This decision is made adaptively based on the student's demonstrated understanding.
The HMAB formulation allows the system to efficiently explore different teaching strategies while also exploiting the ones that are most effective for each student. This is done through a combination of upper confidence bound (UCB) and Thompson sampling methods.
The paper presents theoretical regret bounds for the HMAB approach and demonstrates its empirical performance through simulations and user studies. The results show that the HMAB-based intelligent tutoring system can outperform traditional methods in terms of student learning outcomes.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for using hierarchical multi-armed bandits to create more effective intelligent tutoring systems. The key strength is the ability to adaptively balance teaching of concepts and problems of varying difficulty levels based on student performance.
One potential limitation is the reliance on a specific HMAB formulation, which may not capture all the nuances of the teaching and learning process. The authors acknowledge this and suggest exploring other bandit variants, such as federated or multi-agent bandits, to further improve the model.
Additionally, the paper focuses on simulations and user studies, but real-world deployment and long-term evaluation of the HMAB-based tutoring system would provide valuable insights into its practical effectiveness and scalability.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to intelligent tutoring systems using hierarchical multi-armed bandits. By modeling the teaching and learning process as a HMAB problem, the system can adaptively decide whether to focus on high-level concepts or specific problems based on the student's needs.
The results demonstrate the potential for this approach to outperform traditional tutoring methods in terms of student learning outcomes. While there are opportunities for further refinement and real-world validation, this research represents an important step towards more personalized and effective intelligent tutoring systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Hierarchical Multi-Armed Bandits for the Concurrent Intelligent Tutoring of Concepts and Problems of Varying Difficulty Levels
Blake Castleman, Uzay Macar, Ansaf Salleb-Aouissi
Remote education has proliferated in the twenty-first century, yielding rise to intelligent tutoring systems. In particular, research has found multi-armed bandit (MAB) intelligent tutors to have notable abilities in traversing the exploration-exploitation trade-off landscape for student problem recommendations. Prior literature, however, contains a significant lack of open-sourced MAB intelligent tutors, which impedes potential applications of these educational MAB recommendation systems. In this paper, we combine recent literature on MAB intelligent tutoring techniques into an open-sourced and simply deployable hierarchical MAB algorithm, capable of progressing students concurrently through concepts and problems, determining ideal recommended problem difficulties, and assessing latent memory decay. We evaluate our algorithm using simulated groups of 500 students, utilizing Bayesian Knowledge Tracing to estimate students' content mastery. Results suggest that our algorithm, when turned difficulty-agnostic, significantly boosts student success, and that the further addition of problem-difficulty adaptation notably improves this metric.
Read more8/15/2024
🖼️
0
Causally Abstracted Multi-armed Bandits
Fabio Massimo Zennaro, Nicholas Bishop, Joel Dyer, Yorgos Felekis, Anisoara Calinescu, Michael Wooldridge, Theodoros Damoulas
Multi-armed bandits (MAB) and causal MABs (CMAB) are established frameworks for decision-making problems. The majority of prior work typically studies and solves individual MAB and CMAB in isolation for a given problem and associated data. However, decision-makers are often faced with multiple related problems and multi-scale observations where joint formulations are needed in order to efficiently exploit the problem structures and data dependencies. Transfer learning for CMABs addresses the situation where models are defined on identical variables, although causal connections may differ. In this work, we extend transfer learning to setups involving CMABs defined on potentially different variables, with varying degrees of granularity, and related via an abstraction map. Formally, we introduce the problem of causally abstracted MABs (CAMABs) by relying on the theory of causal abstraction in order to express a rigorous abstraction map. We propose algorithms to learn in a CAMAB, and study their regret. We illustrate the limitations and the strengths of our algorithms on a real-world scenario related to online advertising.
Read more7/18/2024
0
EduQate: Generating Adaptive Curricula through RMABs in Education Settings
Sidney Tio, Dexun Li, Pradeep Varakantham
There has been significant interest in the development of personalized and adaptive educational tools that cater to a student's individual learning progress. A crucial aspect in developing such tools is in exploring how mastery can be achieved across a diverse yet related range of content in an efficient manner. While Reinforcement Learning and Multi-armed Bandits have shown promise in educational settings, existing works often assume the independence of learning content, neglecting the prevalent interdependencies between such content. In response, we introduce Education Network Restless Multi-armed Bandits (EdNetRMABs), utilizing a network to represent the relationships between interdependent arms. Subsequently, we propose EduQate, a method employing interdependency-aware Q-learning to make informed decisions on arm selection at each time step. We establish the optimality guarantee of EduQate and demonstrate its efficacy compared to baseline policies, using students modeled from both synthetic and real-world data.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Multi-agent Multi-armed Bandits with Stochastic Sharable Arm Capacities
Hong Xie, Jinyu Mo, Defu Lian, Jie Wang, Enhong Chen
Motivated by distributed selection problems, we formulate a new variant of multi-player multi-armed bandit (MAB) model, which captures stochastic arrival of requests to each arm, as well as the policy of allocating requests to players. The challenge is how to design a distributed learning algorithm such that players select arms according to the optimal arm pulling profile (an arm pulling profile prescribes the number of players at each arm) without communicating to each other. We first design a greedy algorithm, which locates one of the optimal arm pulling profiles with a polynomial computational complexity. We also design an iterative distributed algorithm for players to commit to an optimal arm pulling profile with a constant number of rounds in expectation. We apply the explore then commit (ETC) framework to address the online setting when model parameters are unknown. We design an exploration strategy for players to estimate the optimal arm pulling profile. Since such estimates can be different across different players, it is challenging for players to commit. We then design an iterative distributed algorithm, which guarantees that players can arrive at a consensus on the optimal arm pulling profile in only M rounds. We conduct experiments to validate our algorithm.
Read more8/21/2024