Houston we have a Divergence: A Subgroup Performance Analysis of ASR Models
2404.07226
0
0
Abstract
The Fearless Steps APOLLO Community Resource provides unparalleled opportunities to explore the potential of multi-speaker team communications from NASA Apollo missions. This study focuses on discovering the characteristics that make Apollo recordings more or less intelligible to Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) methods. We extract, for each audio recording, interpretable metadata on recordings (signal-to-noise ratio, spectral flatness, presence of pauses, sentence duration), transcript (number of words spoken, speaking rate), or known a priori (speaker). We identify subgroups of audio recordings based on combinations of these metadata and compute each subgroup's performance (e.g., Word Error Rate) and the difference in performance (''divergence'') w.r.t the overall population. We then apply the Whisper model in different sizes, trained on English-only or multilingual datasets, in zero-shot or after fine-tuning. We conduct several analyses to (i) automatically identify and describe the most problematic subgroups for a given model, (ii) examine the impact of fine-tuning w.r.t. zero-shot at the subgroup level, (iii) understand the effect of model size on subgroup performance, and (iv) analyze if multilingual models are more sensitive than monolingual to subgroup performance disparities. The insights enhance our understanding of subgroup-specific performance variations, paving the way for advancements in optimizing ASR systems for Earth-to-space communications.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the performance of Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) models on different demographic subgroups.
- The researchers investigate how well pre-trained and fine-tuned ASR models perform on speech data from diverse populations.
- The goal is to identify potential biases and disparities in model performance across subgroups, which is crucial for developing fair and inclusive speech recognition systems.
Plain English Explanation
Speech recognition technology has become increasingly prevalent in our daily lives, from voice assistants to transcription services. However, recent research has raised concerns about the potential biases and disparities in the performance of these Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) models. This paper aims to shed light on this issue by conducting a comprehensive analysis of how well pre-trained and fine-tuned ASR models perform on speech data from different demographic groups.
The researchers recognize that speech recognition systems need to work well for people of all backgrounds, regardless of factors like age, gender, or accent. By investigating the performance of ASR models on diverse subgroups, they hope to identify any areas where the models may struggle, which could lead to unfair or inaccurate results for certain individuals or communities. This is an important step towards developing more inclusive and equitable speech recognition technology, as highlighted in similar research.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a subgroup performance analysis of ASR models, comparing the accuracy of pre-trained and fine-tuned models across different demographic factors. The researchers used a large, diverse speech dataset to evaluate the models, analyzing their performance on subgroups defined by attributes such as age, gender, and accent.
To assess the models, the team used standard speech recognition metrics like Word Error Rate (WER) and Character Error Rate (CER). By breaking down the results for each subgroup, they were able to identify areas where the models struggled, such as with certain accents or age groups. The findings provide valuable insights into the potential biases and limitations of these ASR systems, which can inform future research and development efforts, as seen in related work.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research. For instance, the dataset used may not fully capture the diversity of real-world speech data, and the subgroup definitions could be refined further. Additionally, the researchers suggest exploring more advanced techniques, such as speech quality assessment, to better understand the causes of performance disparities.
While the findings highlight important issues, it's worth noting that the paper does not delve into the root causes of the observed biases or propose specific solutions. Deeper investigation into the factors driving the performance gaps, as well as the development of targeted mitigation strategies, could be valuable next steps.
Conclusion
This research sheds light on a critical issue in the field of Automatic Speech Recognition: the potential for biases and disparities in model performance across demographic subgroups. By conducting a comprehensive analysis of pre-trained and fine-tuned ASR models, the authors have identified areas where the technology may fall short in serving diverse populations.
The insights from this study can inform the development of more inclusive and equitable speech recognition systems, which is crucial for ensuring that these powerful tools benefit people of all backgrounds equally. As the authors suggest, continued research and innovation in this area, such as the work described in this technical report, will be essential for realizing the full potential of speech technology while addressing the complex challenges of bias and fairness.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Twists, Humps, and Pebbles: Multilingual Speech Recognition Models Exhibit Gender Performance Gaps
Giuseppe Attanasio, Beatrice Savoldi, Dennis Fucci, Dirk Hovy
0
0
Current automatic speech recognition (ASR) models are designed to be used across many languages and tasks without substantial changes. However, this broad language coverage hides performance gaps within languages, for example, across genders. Our study systematically evaluates the performance of two widely used multilingual ASR models on three datasets, encompassing 19 languages from eight language families and two speaking conditions. Our findings reveal clear gender disparities, with the advantaged group varying across languages and models. Surprisingly, those gaps are not explained by acoustic or lexical properties. However, probing internal model states reveals a correlation with gendered performance gap. I.e., the easier it is to distinguish speaker gender in a language using probes, the more the gap reduces, favoring female speakers. Our results show that gender disparities persist even in state-of-the-art models. Our findings have implications for the improvement of multilingual ASR systems, underscoring the importance of accessibility to training data and nuanced evaluation to predict and mitigate gender gaps. We release all code and artifacts at https://github.com/g8a9/multilingual-asr-gender-gap.
6/21/2024
🛸
Enabling ASR for Low-Resource Languages: A Comprehensive Dataset Creation Approach
Ara Yeroyan (Data Science Department, American University of Armenia), Nikolay Karpov (Nvidia, NeMo Conversational AI team)
0
0
In recent years, automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems have significantly improved, especially in languages with a vast amount of transcribed speech data. However, ASR systems tend to perform poorly for low-resource languages with fewer resources, such as minority and regional languages. This study introduces a novel pipeline designed to generate ASR training datasets from audiobooks, which typically feature a single transcript associated with hours-long audios. The common structure of these audiobooks poses a unique challenge due to the extensive length of audio segments, whereas optimal ASR training requires segments ranging from 4 to 15 seconds. To address this, we propose a method for effectively aligning audio with its corresponding text and segmenting it into lengths suitable for ASR training. Our approach simplifies data preparation for ASR systems in low-resource languages and demonstrates its application through a case study involving the Armenian language. Our method, which is portable to many low-resource languages, not only mitigates the issue of data scarcity but also enhances the performance of ASR models for underrepresented languages.
6/4/2024
🤯
HypR: A comprehensive study for ASR hypothesis revising with a reference corpus
Yi-Wei Wang, Ke-Han Lu, Kuan-Yu Chen
0
0
With the development of deep learning, automatic speech recognition (ASR) has made significant progress. To further enhance the performance of ASR, revising recognition results is one of the lightweight but efficient manners. Various methods can be roughly classified into N-best reranking modeling and error correction modeling. The former aims to select the hypothesis with the lowest error rate from a set of candidates generated by ASR for a given input speech. The latter focuses on detecting recognition errors in a given hypothesis and correcting these errors to obtain an enhanced result. However, we observe that these studies are hardly comparable to each other, as they are usually evaluated on different corpora, paired with different ASR models, and even use different datasets to train the models. Accordingly, we first concentrate on providing an ASR hypothesis revising (HypR) dataset in this study. HypR contains several commonly used corpora (AISHELL-1, TED-LIUM 2, and LibriSpeech) and provides 50 recognition hypotheses for each speech utterance. The checkpoint models of ASR are also published. In addition, we implement and compare several classic and representative methods, showing the recent research progress in revising speech recognition results. We hope that the publicly available HypR dataset can become a reference benchmark for subsequent research and promote this field of research to an advanced level.
6/14/2024
To Distill or Not to Distill? On the Robustness of Robust Knowledge Distillation
Abdul Waheed, Karima Kadaoui, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
0
0
Arabic is known to present unique challenges for Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR). On one hand, its rich linguistic diversity and wide range of dialects complicate the development of robust, inclusive models. On the other, current multilingual ASR models are compute-intensive and lack proper comprehensive evaluations. In light of these challenges, we distill knowledge from large teacher models into smaller student variants that are more efficient. We also introduce a novel human-annotated dataset covering five under-represented Arabic dialects for evaluation. We further evaluate both our models and existing SoTA multilingual models on both standard available benchmarks and our new dialectal data. Our best-distilled model's overall performance ($45.0$% WER) surpasses that of a SoTA model twice its size (SeamlessM4T-large-v2, WER=$47.0$%) and its teacher model (Whisper-large-v2, WER=$55.1$%), and its average performance on our new dialectal data ($56.9$% WER) outperforms all other models. To gain more insight into the poor performance of these models on dialectal data, we conduct an error analysis and report the main types of errors the different models tend to make. The GitHub repository for the project is available at url{https://github.com/UBC-NLP/distill-whisper-ar}.
6/10/2024