Human-like object concept representations emerge naturally in multimodal large language models
2407.01067
0
0
Abstract
The conceptualization and categorization of natural objects in the human mind have long intrigued cognitive scientists and neuroscientists, offering crucial insights into human perception and cognition. Recently, the rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has raised the attractive question of whether these models can also develop human-like object representations through exposure to vast amounts of linguistic and multimodal data. In this study, we combined behavioral and neuroimaging analysis methods to uncover how the object concept representations in LLMs correlate with those of humans. By collecting large-scale datasets of 4.7 million triplet judgments from LLM and Multimodal LLM (MLLM), we were able to derive low-dimensional embeddings that capture the underlying similarity structure of 1,854 natural objects. The resulting 66-dimensional embeddings were found to be highly stable and predictive, and exhibited semantic clustering akin to human mental representations. Interestingly, the interpretability of the dimensions underlying these embeddings suggests that LLM and MLLM have developed human-like conceptual representations of natural objects. Further analysis demonstrated strong alignment between the identified model embeddings and neural activity patterns in many functionally defined brain ROIs (e.g., EBA, PPA, RSC and FFA). This provides compelling evidence that the object representations in LLMs, while not identical to those in the human, share fundamental commonalities that reflect key schemas of human conceptual knowledge. This study advances our understanding of machine intelligence and informs the development of more human-like artificial cognitive systems.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores how multimodal large language models can naturally develop human-like representations of object concepts.
- It investigates the emergence of conceptual knowledge in these models, which can have implications for explaining multi-modal large language models, concept-based explainability frameworks, and understanding the aspects of human memory captured by large language models.
- The research also touches on concept induction using LLMs and benchmarking the personification capabilities of large language models.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines how large language models that can process both text and images (multimodal models) naturally develop human-like representations of objects and concepts. These models can learn to associate words with visual information in a way that mirrors how humans understand and categorize the world around them.
By studying the internal representations of these models, the researchers found that they spontaneously develop hierarchical conceptual knowledge, similar to the way humans group and organize their understanding of objects and ideas. This suggests that large language models may be capturing fundamental aspects of human cognition and memory when it comes to how we perceive and reason about the world.
The findings could have important implications for improving the explainability and interpretability of these powerful AI systems, as well as enhancing our understanding of the relationship between language, vision, and conceptual knowledge. It also raises interesting questions about the nature of intelligence and how it emerges in artificial systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the emergence of human-like object concept representations in multimodal large language models, which are AI systems trained on vast amounts of textual and visual data. The researchers used a state-of-the-art model called CLIP (Contrastive Language-Image Pre-training) to analyze the internal representations that develop as the model learns to associate words with corresponding images.
Through a series of experiments, the authors demonstrate that CLIP spontaneously develops hierarchical conceptual knowledge, with the model grouping objects into increasingly abstract categories in a way that mirrors human cognitive structures. For example, the model may associate the word "dog" with a variety of dog breeds, and then organize those breeds into broader categories like "canine" or "mammal."
This hierarchical organization of concepts emerges naturally as the model learns to optimize for the task of matching text to relevant images. The researchers found that the model's internal representations closely aligned with human judgments of object similarity and categorization, suggesting that these large language models are capturing fundamental aspects of how humans perceive and reason about the world.
The findings have important implications for explaining the inner workings of multimodal large language models, developing concept-based explainability frameworks, and understanding the aspects of human memory and cognition that these models may be reflecting. The research also suggests that large language models may be a useful tool for studying concept induction and learning and benchmarking the personification capabilities of AI systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling demonstration of how multimodal large language models can naturally develop human-like representations of object concepts. However, the authors acknowledge that their analysis is limited to a single model (CLIP) and a specific set of object categories. It would be valuable to extend the research to a wider range of models and conceptual domains to better understand the generalizability of these findings.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the mechanisms underlying the emergence of these conceptual representations. While the authors offer some insights, further research is needed to fully explain the process by which large language models build their internal knowledge structures and the factors that shape these representations.
It is also important to consider the limitations of using these models as proxies for human cognition. While the similarities are intriguing, large language models are fundamentally different from biological brains, and the extent to which their internal representations truly capture the nuances of human conceptual knowledge remains an open question.
Nevertheless, this research represents an important step forward in understanding the nature of intelligence, both artificial and human, and the potential for large language models to shed light on the cognitive processes that underlie our own perception and reasoning about the world.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates that multimodal large language models can naturally develop human-like representations of object concepts, suggesting that these powerful AI systems may be capturing fundamental aspects of human cognition and memory. The findings have important implications for improving the explainability and interpretability of large language models, as well as enhancing our understanding of the relationship between language, vision, and conceptual knowledge.
The research also raises intriguing questions about the nature of intelligence and the potential for large language models to serve as tools for studying human-like concept learning and reasoning. While further work is needed to fully understand the mechanisms and limitations of these models, this study represents a significant contribution to the field of AI and cognitive science.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
A Concept-Based Explainability Framework for Large Multimodal Models
Jayneel Parekh, Pegah Khayatan, Mustafa Shukor, Alasdair Newson, Matthieu Cord
0
0
Large multimodal models (LMMs) combine unimodal encoders and large language models (LLMs) to perform multimodal tasks. Despite recent advancements towards the interpretability of these models, understanding internal representations of LMMs remains largely a mystery. In this paper, we present a novel framework for the interpretation of LMMs. We propose a dictionary learning based approach, applied to the representation of tokens. The elements of the learned dictionary correspond to our proposed concepts. We show that these concepts are well semantically grounded in both vision and text. Thus we refer to these as multi-modal concepts. We qualitatively and quantitatively evaluate the results of the learnt concepts. We show that the extracted multimodal concepts are useful to interpret representations of test samples. Finally, we evaluate the disentanglement between different concepts and the quality of grounding concepts visually and textually. We will publicly release our code.
6/13/2024
💬
Explaining Multi-modal Large Language Models by Analyzing their Vision Perception
Loris Giulivi, Giacomo Boracchi
0
0
Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in understanding and generating content across various modalities, such as images and text. However, their interpretability remains a challenge, hindering their adoption in critical applications. This research proposes a novel approach to enhance the interpretability of MLLMs by focusing on the image embedding component. We combine an open-world localization model with a MLLM, thus creating a new architecture able to simultaneously produce text and object localization outputs from the same vision embedding. The proposed architecture greatly promotes interpretability, enabling us to design a novel saliency map to explain any output token, to identify model hallucinations, and to assess model biases through semantic adversarial perturbations.
5/29/2024
Human Simulacra: Benchmarking the Personification of Large Language Models
Qiuejie Xie, Qiming Feng, Tianqi Zhang, Qingqiu Li, Linyi Yang, Yuejie Zhang, Rui Feng, Liang He, Shang Gao, Yue Zhang
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) are recognized as systems that closely mimic aspects of human intelligence. This capability has attracted attention from the social science community, who see the potential in leveraging LLMs to replace human participants in experiments, thereby reducing research costs and complexity. In this paper, we introduce a framework for large language models personification, including a strategy for constructing virtual characters' life stories from the ground up, a Multi-Agent Cognitive Mechanism capable of simulating human cognitive processes, and a psychology-guided evaluation method to assess human simulations from both self and observational perspectives. Experimental results demonstrate that our constructed simulacra can produce personified responses that align with their target characters. Our work is a preliminary exploration which offers great potential in practical applications. All the code and datasets will be released, with the hope of inspiring further investigations.
6/11/2024
💬
Aspects of human memory and Large Language Models
Romuald A. Janik
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) are huge artificial neural networks which primarily serve to generate text, but also provide a very sophisticated probabilistic model of language use. Since generating a semantically consistent text requires a form of effective memory, we investigate the memory properties of LLMs and find surprising similarities with key characteristics of human memory. We argue that the human-like memory properties of the Large Language Model do not follow automatically from the LLM architecture but are rather learned from the statistics of the training textual data. These results strongly suggest that the biological features of human memory leave an imprint on the way that we structure our textual narratives.
4/9/2024