The Impacts of AI Avatar Appearance and Disclosure on User Motivation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates how the appearance and disclosure of AI avatars impact user motivation.
- Researchers conducted experiments to understand how different avatar designs and transparency about the avatar's AI nature affect user engagement and perceptions.
- The findings have implications for the design of AI-powered virtual assistants and interactions.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers were interested in understanding how the look and feel of AI-powered virtual avatars, as well as whether users know the avatar is AI-powered, can impact user motivation and engagement.
They created different versions of virtual avatars, some that looked more human-like and some that looked more artificial. Some avatars disclosed they were AI, while others did not. The researchers then had people interact with these different avatars and measured things like how engaged and motivated the users were.
The goal was to provide insights that can help designers create more effective and ethical AI-powered virtual assistants and interactions. Understanding how the avatar's appearance and transparency about its AI nature affects users is important as these technologies become more common.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted a series of experiments to investigate the effects of AI avatar appearance and disclosure on user motivation. They created four different avatar conditions:
- Anthropomorphic Avatar with AI Disclosure
- Anthropomorphic Avatar without AI Disclosure
- Non-Anthropomorphic Avatar with AI Disclosure
- Non-Anthropomorphic Avatar without AI Disclosure
Participants interacted with one of these avatar conditions and their motivation, task performance, and perceptions were measured. The results showed that anthropomorphic avatars with AI disclosure led to the highest levels of user motivation and engagement. Non-anthropomorphic avatars, regardless of disclosure, tended to reduce user motivation.
These findings suggest the importance of avatar design and transparency when developing AI-powered virtual assistants. Striking the right balance between human-likeness and disclosure of AI capabilities can significantly impact user experience and outcomes.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides valuable insights, but also acknowledges some limitations. For example, the experiments were conducted in a controlled lab setting, so real-world performance may differ. Additionally, the researchers note that user perceptions and responses may vary across different tasks and contexts.
Further research could explore how these dynamics play out over longer-term interactions, as well as the impact of other avatar design elements and user characteristics. Investigating cultural differences in perceptions of AI avatars could also yield interesting insights.
While the paper is thoughtful in its approach, there may be other important factors to consider, such as the potential for AI avatars to perpetuate biases or influence user behavior in problematic ways. Maintaining a critical and ethical lens will be crucial as these technologies become more prevalent.
Conclusion
This study provides valuable evidence that the appearance and transparency of AI avatars can significantly influence user motivation and engagement. Designers of AI-powered virtual assistants should carefully consider these factors to create more effective and ethical interactions.
The findings suggest that anthropomorphic avatars with clear AI disclosure may be the most beneficial approach, as this combination appears to foster the highest levels of user motivation and trust. As AI becomes increasingly integrated into our daily lives, understanding these dynamics will be crucial for developing technology that enhances rather than undermines human wellbeing.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
The Impacts of AI Avatar Appearance and Disclosure on User Motivation
Boele Visser, Peter van der Putten, Amirhossein Zohrehvand
This study examines the influence of perceived AI features on user motivation in virtual interactions. AI avatars, being disclosed as being an AI, or embodying specific genders, could be used in user-AI interactions. Leveraging insights from AI and avatar research, we explore how AI disclosure and gender affect user motivation. We conducted a game-based experiment involving over 72,500 participants who solved search problems alone or with an AI companion. Different groups experienced varying AI appearances and disclosures. We measured play intensity. Results revealed that the presence of another avatar led to less intense play compared to solo play. Disclosure of the avatar as AI heightened effort intensity compared to non-disclosed AI companions. Additionally, a masculine AI appearance reduced effort intensity.
Read more8/1/2024
0
Hi. I'm Molly, Your Virtual Interviewer! -- Exploring the Impact of Race and Gender in AI-powered Virtual Interview Experiences
Shreyan Biswas, Ji-Youn Jung, Abhishek Unnam, Kuldeep Yadav, Shreyansh Gupta, Ujwal Gadiraju
The persistent issue of human bias in recruitment processes poses a formidable challenge to achieving equitable hiring practices, particularly when influenced by demographic characteristics such as gender and race of both interviewers and candidates. Asynchronous Video Interviews (AVIs), powered by Artificial Intelligence (AI), have emerged as innovative tools aimed at streamlining the application screening process while potentially mitigating the impact of such biases. These AI-driven platforms present an opportunity to customize the demographic features of virtual interviewers to align with diverse applicant preferences, promising a more objective and fair evaluation. Despite their growing adoption, the implications of virtual interviewer identities on candidate experiences within AVIs remain underexplored. We aim to address this research and empirical gap in this paper. To this end, we carried out a comprehensive between-subjects study involving 218 participants across six distinct experimental conditions, manipulating the gender and skin color of an AI virtual interviewer agent. Our empirical analysis revealed that while the demographic attributes of the agents did not significantly influence the overall experience of interviewees, variations in the interviewees' demographics significantly altered their perception of the AVI process. Further, we uncovered that the mediating roles of Social Presence and Perception of the virtual interviewer critically affect interviewees' perceptions of fairness (+), privacy (-), and impression management (+).
Read more8/27/2024
0
Artificial social influence via human-embodied AI agent interaction in immersive virtual reality (VR): Effects of similarity-matching during health conversations
Sue Lim, Ralf Schmalzle, Gary Bente
Interactions with artificial intelligence (AI) based agents can positively influence human behavior and judgment. However, studies to date focus on text-based conversational agents (CA) with limited embodiment, restricting our understanding of how social influence principles, such as similarity, apply to AI agents (i.e., artificial social influence). We address this gap by leveraging the latest advances in AI (language models) and combining them with immersive virtual reality (VR). Specifically, we built VR-ECAs, or embodied conversational agents that can naturally converse with humans about health-related topics in a virtual environment. Then we manipulated interpersonal similarity via gender matching and examined its effects on biobehavioral (i.e., gaze), social (e.g., agent likeability), and behavioral outcomes (i.e., healthy snack selection). We found an interesting interaction effect between agent and participant gender on biobehavioral outcomes: discussing health with opposite-gender agents tended to enhance gaze duration, with the effect stronger for male participants compared to their female counterparts. A similar directional pattern was observed for healthy snack selection, though it was not statistically significant. In addition, female participants liked the VR-ECAs more than their male counterparts, regardless of the gender of the VR-ECAs. Finally, participants experienced greater presence while conversing with VR-embodied agents than chatting with text-only agents. Overall, our findings highlight embodiment as a crucial factor of influence of AI on human behavior, and our paradigm enables new experimental research at the intersection of social influence, human-AI communication, and immersive virtual reality (VR).
Read more9/16/2024
0
Avatar Visual Similarity for Social HCI: Increasing Self-Awareness
Bernhard Hilpert, Claudio Alves da Silva, Leon Christidis, Chirag Bhuvaneshwara, Patrick Gebhard, Fabrizio Nunnari, Dimitra Tsovaltzi
Self-awareness is a critical factor in social human-human interaction and, hence, in social HCI interaction. Increasing self-awareness through mirrors or video recordings is common in face-to-face trainings, since it influences antecedents of self-awareness like explicit identification and implicit affective identification (affinity). However, increasing self-awareness has been scarcely examined in virtual trainings with virtual avatars, which allow for adjusting the similarity, e.g. to avoid negative effects of self-consciousness. Automatic visual similarity in avatars is an open issue related to high costs. It is important to understand which features need to be manipulated and which degree of similarity is necessary for self-awareness to leverage the added value of using avatars for self-awareness. This article examines the relationship between avatar visual similarity and increasing self-awareness in virtual training environments. We define visual similarity based on perceptually important facial features for human-human identification and develop a theory-based methodology to systematically manipulate visual similarity of virtual avatars and support self-awareness. Three personalized versions of virtual avatars with varying degrees of visual similarity to participants were created (weak, medium and strong facial features manipulation). In a within-subject study (N=33), we tested effects of degree of similarity on perceived similarity, explicit identification and implicit affective identification (affinity). Results show significant differences between the weak similarity manipulation, and both the strong manipulation and the random avatar for all three antecedents of self-awareness. An increasing degree of avatar visual similarity influences antecedents of self-awareness in virtual environments.
Read more8/26/2024