Impacts of Color and Texture Distortions on Earth Observation Data in Deep Learning
2403.04385
0
0
Abstract
Land cover classification and change detection are two important applications of remote sensing and Earth observation (EO) that have benefited greatly from the advances of deep learning. Convolutional and transformer-based U-net models are the state-of-the-art architectures for these tasks, and their performances have been boosted by an increased availability of large-scale annotated EO datasets. However, the influence of different visual characteristics of the input EO data on a model's predictions is not well understood. In this work we systematically examine model sensitivities with respect to several color- and texture-based distortions on the input EO data during inference, given models that have been trained without such distortions. We conduct experiments with multiple state-of-the-art segmentation networks for land cover classification and show that they are in general more sensitive to texture than to color distortions. Beyond revealing intriguing characteristics of widely used land cover classification models, our results can also be used to guide the development of more robust models within the EO domain.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the impacts of color and texture distortions on the performance of deep learning models for Earth observation data analysis.
- The researchers explore how various image processing techniques, such as color jittering and texture augmentation, can affect the accuracy and robustness of deep learning models in tasks like land cover classification and change detection.
- The findings provide valuable insights for practitioners working with Earth observation data and highlight the importance of considering data quality and preprocessing when developing deep learning-based solutions.
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning models have become increasingly popular for analyzing satellite and aerial imagery, known as Earth observation data. These models can be used for tasks like classifying land cover types or detecting changes over time. However, the quality of the input data can significantly impact the performance of these models.
In this study, the researchers investigated how different types of image distortions, such as changes in color and texture, can affect the accuracy and robustness of deep learning models for Earth observation tasks. They applied various image processing techniques, like color jittering and texture augmentation, to the input data and measured the impact on model performance.
The findings suggest that these image distortions can have a significant impact on the models, either improving or degrading their performance depending on the specific task and distortion. For example, adding texture-based distortions may help models become more robust to real-world variations in Earth observation data, while color changes can negatively impact tasks like land cover classification.
These insights are crucial for practitioners developing deep learning-based solutions for Earth observation applications. By understanding the sensitivity of their models to data quality and preprocessing, they can make more informed decisions about model architecture, training, and deployment to ensure robust and reliable performance in real-world scenarios.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted a comprehensive study to understand the impacts of color and texture distortions on the performance of deep learning models for Earth observation data analysis. They applied various image processing techniques, including color jittering, texture augmentation, and combinations of these distortions, to the input data and evaluated the models' performance on land cover classification and change detection tasks.
The experiments were carried out using popular deep learning architectures, such as U-Net and ResNet, on publicly available Earth observation datasets. The researchers measured the models' accuracy, F1-score, and other relevant metrics to quantify the impact of the different distortions.
The results showed that the effects of color and texture distortions were task-dependent. For land cover classification, the models were more sensitive to color changes, with significant performance degradation observed when certain color jittering techniques were applied. In contrast, texture-based distortions tended to improve the models' robustness and generalization capabilities, particularly for change detection tasks.
The researchers hypothesized that the texture distortions helped the models learn more generalizable features, making them better equipped to handle real-world variations in Earth observation data. However, the combination of color and texture distortions did not always lead to the best performance, highlighting the complexity of balancing these trade-offs.
The findings from this study provide valuable insights for researchers and practitioners working with deep learning for Earth observation applications. By understanding the sensitivity of their models to data quality and preprocessing, they can make more informed decisions about model design, training, and deployment to ensure robust and reliable performance in real-world scenarios.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and well-designed study on the impacts of color and texture distortions on deep learning models for Earth observation data analysis. The researchers have carefully considered various image processing techniques and their effects on different tasks, offering valuable insights for the community.
One potential limitation of the study is the relatively narrow scope of the tasks and datasets used. The experiments were focused on land cover classification and change detection, which, while important, do not cover the full breadth of Earth observation applications. Expanding the research to include a wider range of tasks, such as semantic segmentation or object detection, could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the impacts of data distortions.
Additionally, the study does not delve deeply into the underlying reasons for the observed performance changes. While the researchers provide some hypotheses, a more thorough investigation into the mechanisms by which color and texture distortions affect model behavior could further strengthen the insights and guide future research.
Another area for potential improvement is the consideration of real-world data challenges, such as sensor-specific artifacts, atmospheric effects, and other sources of noise and distortion. Incorporating these aspects into the experimental design could make the findings more directly applicable to practical Earth observation applications.
Despite these minor limitations, the paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of deep learning for Earth observation, highlighting the importance of data quality and preprocessing for model performance and robustness. The insights from this study can inform the development of more resilient and reliable deep learning-based solutions for a wide range of Earth observation tasks.
Conclusion
This paper provides a comprehensive investigation into the impacts of color and texture distortions on the performance of deep learning models for Earth observation data analysis. The researchers found that these image processing techniques can have significant and task-dependent effects on model accuracy and robustness, with color changes negatively impacting land cover classification and texture-based distortions improving change detection performance.
These findings offer valuable insights for practitioners working with deep learning for Earth observation applications. By understanding the sensitivity of their models to data quality and preprocessing, they can make more informed decisions about model design, training, and deployment to ensure robust and reliable performance in real-world scenarios. The research also highlights the need for further exploration of the underlying mechanisms behind these performance changes and the consideration of a wider range of Earth observation tasks and data challenges.
Overall, this study contributes to the growing body of research on the challenges and opportunities in applying deep learning to Earth observation data, ultimately helping to advance the field and unlock the full potential of these powerful techniques for a wide range of environmental and geospatial applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Impact Assessment of Missing Data in Model Predictions for Earth Observation Applications
Francisco Mena, Diego Arenas, Marcela Charfuelan, Marlon Nuske, Andreas Dengel
0
0
Earth observation (EO) applications involving complex and heterogeneous data sources are commonly approached with machine learning models. However, there is a common assumption that data sources will be persistently available. Different situations could affect the availability of EO sources, like noise, clouds, or satellite mission failures. In this work, we assess the impact of missing temporal and static EO sources in trained models across four datasets with classification and regression tasks. We compare the predictive quality of different methods and find that some are naturally more robust to missing data. The Ensemble strategy, in particular, achieves a prediction robustness up to 100%. We evidence that missing scenarios are significantly more challenging in regression than classification tasks. Finally, we find that the optical view is the most critical view when it is missing individually.
5/14/2024
Data Augmentation in Earth Observation: A Diffusion Model Approach
Tiago Sousa, Beno^it Ries, Nicolas Guelfi
0
0
The scarcity of high-quality Earth Observation (EO) imagery poses a significant challenge, despite its critical role in enabling precise analysis and informed decision-making across various sectors. This scarcity is primarily due to atmospheric conditions, seasonal variations, and limited geographical coverage, which complicates the application of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in EO. Data augmentation, a widely used technique in AI that involves generating additional data mainly through parameterized image transformations, has been employed to increase the volume and diversity of data. However, this method often falls short in generating sufficient diversity across key semantic axes, adversely affecting the accuracy of EO applications. To address this issue, we propose a novel four-stage approach aimed at improving the diversity of augmented data by integrating diffusion models. Our approach employs meta-prompts for instruction generation, harnesses general-purpose vision-language models for generating rich captions, fine-tunes an Earth Observation diffusion model, and iteratively augments data. We conducted extensive experiments using four different data augmentation techniques, and our approach consistently demonstrated improvements, outperforming the established augmentation methods, revealing its effectiveness in generating semantically rich and diverse EO images.
6/11/2024
Detecting Out-Of-Distribution Earth Observation Images with Diffusion Models
Georges Le Bellier (CEDRIC - VERTIGO, CNAM), Nicolas Audebert (CEDRIC - VERTIGO, CNAM, IGN)
0
0
Earth Observation imagery can capture rare and unusual events, such as disasters and major landscape changes, whose visual appearance contrasts with the usual observations. Deep models trained on common remote sensing data will output drastically different features for these out-of-distribution samples, compared to those closer to their training dataset. Detecting them could therefore help anticipate changes in the observations, either geographical or environmental. In this work, we show that the reconstruction error of diffusion models can effectively serve as unsupervised out-of-distribution detectors for remote sensing images, using them as a plausibility score. Moreover, we introduce ODEED, a novel reconstruction-based scorer using the probability-flow ODE of diffusion models. We validate it experimentally on SpaceNet 8 with various scenarios, such as classical OOD detection with geographical shift and near-OOD setups: pre/post-flood and non-flooded/flooded image recognition. We show that our ODEED scorer significantly outperforms other diffusion-based and discriminative baselines on the more challenging near-OOD scenarios of flood image detection, where OOD images are close to the distribution tail. We aim to pave the way towards better use of generative models for anomaly detection in remote sensing.
4/22/2024
🤖
EarthNets: Empowering AI in Earth Observation
Zhitong Xiong, Fahong Zhang, Yi Wang, Yilei Shi, Xiao Xiang Zhu
0
0
Earth observation (EO), aiming at monitoring the state of planet Earth using remote sensing data, is critical for improving our daily lives and living environment. With a growing number of satellites in orbit, an increasing number of datasets with diverse sensors and research domains are being published to facilitate the research of the remote sensing community. This paper presents a comprehensive review of more than 500 publicly published datasets, including research domains like agriculture, land use and land cover, disaster monitoring, scene understanding, vision-language models, foundation models, climate change, and weather forecasting. We systematically analyze these EO datasets from four aspects: volume, resolution distributions, research domains, and the correlation between datasets. Based on the dataset attributes, we propose to measure, rank, and select datasets to build a new benchmark for model evaluation. Furthermore, a new platform for EO, termed EarthNets, is released to achieve a fair and consistent evaluation of deep learning methods on remote sensing data. EarthNets supports standard dataset libraries and cutting-edge deep learning models to bridge the gap between the remote sensing and machine learning communities. Based on this platform, extensive deep-learning methods are evaluated on the new benchmark. The insightful results are beneficial to future research. The platform and dataset collections are publicly available at https://earthnets.github.io.
4/4/2024