Improved Canonicalization for Model Agnostic Equivariance
2405.14089
0
0
📈
Abstract
This work introduces a novel approach to achieving architecture-agnostic equivariance in deep learning, particularly addressing the limitations of traditional equivariant architectures and the inefficiencies of the existing architecture-agnostic methods. Building equivariant models using traditional methods requires designing equivariant versions of existing models and training them from scratch, a process that is both impractical and resource-intensive. Canonicalization has emerged as a promising alternative for inducing equivariance without altering model architecture, but it suffers from the need for highly expressive and expensive equivariant networks to learn canonical orientations accurately. We propose a new method that employs any non-equivariant network for canonicalization. Our method uses contrastive learning to efficiently learn a unique canonical orientation and offers more flexibility for the choice of canonicalization network. We empirically demonstrate that this approach outperforms existing methods in achieving equivariance for large pretrained models and significantly speeds up the canonicalization process, making it up to 2 times faster.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a novel approach to achieving architecture-agnostic equivariance in deep learning
- Addresses limitations of traditional equivariant architectures and inefficiencies of existing architecture-agnostic methods
- Proposes a new method that employs any non-equivariant network for canonicalization, using contrastive learning to efficiently learn a unique canonical orientation
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning models are often designed to be equivariant, meaning they produce outputs that transform in a predictable way when the input is transformed. Traditional equivariant architectures require designing specialized models from scratch, which is impractical and resource-intensive. Canonicalization has emerged as a more flexible approach, but it relies on expensive equivariant networks to learn canonical orientations accurately.
This paper introduces a new method that uses any non-equivariant network for canonicalization. By employing contrastive learning, the model can efficiently learn a unique canonical orientation without the need for specialized equivariant architectures. This approach offers more flexibility in the choice of canonicalization network and outperforms existing methods in achieving equivariance for large pre-trained models, while also significantly speeding up the canonicalization process, making it up to 2 times faster.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel architecture-agnostic approach to inducing equivariance in deep learning models. Traditional equivariant architectures, such as those discussed in Unifying O(3)-Equivariant Neural Networks: Design, Theory, and Applications, require designing specialized versions of existing models and training them from scratch, which is both impractical and resource-intensive.
Canonicalization has emerged as a promising alternative, where a model learns to map inputs to a canonical orientation, allowing for the use of any non-equivariant network. However, existing canonicalization methods rely on highly expressive and expensive equivariant networks to learn the canonical orientations accurately.
The proposed method uses contrastive learning to efficiently learn a unique canonical orientation, allowing the use of any non-equivariant network for canonicalization. This approach offers more flexibility in the choice of canonicalization network and outperforms existing methods in achieving equivariance for large pre-trained models. The authors demonstrate that their method can significantly speed up the canonicalization process, making it up to 2 times faster than previous approaches.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to achieving architecture-agnostic equivariance in deep learning. The key advantage of the proposed method is its flexibility in the choice of canonicalization network, which allows for the use of any non-equivariant network, rather than requiring specialized equivariant architectures.
One potential limitation mentioned in the paper is the need for a sufficiently expressive non-equivariant network to learn the canonical orientations accurately. While the authors show that their method outperforms existing approaches, the performance may still be dependent on the capacity and architecture of the canonicalization network.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential trade-offs between the speed and accuracy of the canonicalization process. Further research could investigate the optimal balance between these two factors, particularly for different applications and model sizes.
It would also be valuable to examine the generalization of the proposed method to a wider range of equivariance groups, beyond the examples provided in the paper, and to explore its performance on more diverse datasets and tasks.
Conclusion
This research introduces a novel architecture-agnostic approach to achieving equivariance in deep learning, which addresses the limitations of traditional equivariant architectures and the inefficiencies of existing canonicalization methods. By employing contrastive learning to efficiently learn canonical orientations using any non-equivariant network, the proposed method offers more flexibility and significantly faster canonicalization compared to previous approaches.
The findings of this work have the potential to simplify the design and training of equivariant deep learning models, making them more accessible and practical for a wider range of applications. Further research could explore the broader implications of this method and its adaptability to different equivariance groups and problem domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🎯
A Canonization Perspective on Invariant and Equivariant Learning
George Ma, Yifei Wang, Derek Lim, Stefanie Jegelka, Yisen Wang
0
0
In many applications, we desire neural networks to exhibit invariance or equivariance to certain groups due to symmetries inherent in the data. Recently, frame-averaging methods emerged to be a unified framework for attaining symmetries efficiently by averaging over input-dependent subsets of the group, i.e., frames. What we currently lack is a principled understanding of the design of frames. In this work, we introduce a canonization perspective that provides an essential and complete view of the design of frames. Canonization is a classic approach for attaining invariance by mapping inputs to their canonical forms. We show that there exists an inherent connection between frames and canonical forms. Leveraging this connection, we can efficiently compare the complexity of frames as well as determine the optimality of certain frames. Guided by this principle, we design novel frames for eigenvectors that are strictly superior to existing methods -- some are even optimal -- both theoretically and empirically. The reduction to the canonization perspective further uncovers equivalences between previous methods. These observations suggest that canonization provides a fundamental understanding of existing frame-averaging methods and unifies existing equivariant and invariant learning methods.
5/30/2024
Approximately Equivariant Neural Processes
Matthew Ashman, Cristiana Diaconu, Adrian Weller, Wessel Bruinsma, Richard E. Turner
0
0
Equivariant deep learning architectures exploit symmetries in learning problems to improve the sample efficiency of neural-network-based models and their ability to generalise. However, when modelling real-world data, learning problems are often not exactly equivariant, but only approximately. For example, when estimating the global temperature field from weather station observations, local topographical features like mountains break translation equivariance. In these scenarios, it is desirable to construct architectures that can flexibly depart from exact equivariance in a data-driven way. In this paper, we develop a general approach to achieving this using existing equivariant architectures. Our approach is agnostic to both the choice of symmetry group and model architecture, making it widely applicable. We consider the use of approximately equivariant architectures in neural processes (NPs), a popular family of meta-learning models. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on a number of synthetic and real-world regression experiments, demonstrating that approximately equivariant NP models can outperform both their non-equivariant and strictly equivariant counterparts.
6/21/2024
✨
The Lie Derivative for Measuring Learned Equivariance
Nate Gruver, Marc Finzi, Micah Goldblum, Andrew Gordon Wilson
0
0
Equivariance guarantees that a model's predictions capture key symmetries in data. When an image is translated or rotated, an equivariant model's representation of that image will translate or rotate accordingly. The success of convolutional neural networks has historically been tied to translation equivariance directly encoded in their architecture. The rising success of vision transformers, which have no explicit architectural bias towards equivariance, challenges this narrative and suggests that augmentations and training data might also play a significant role in their performance. In order to better understand the role of equivariance in recent vision models, we introduce the Lie derivative, a method for measuring equivariance with strong mathematical foundations and minimal hyperparameters. Using the Lie derivative, we study the equivariance properties of hundreds of pretrained models, spanning CNNs, transformers, and Mixer architectures. The scale of our analysis allows us to separate the impact of architecture from other factors like model size or training method. Surprisingly, we find that many violations of equivariance can be linked to spatial aliasing in ubiquitous network layers, such as pointwise non-linearities, and that as models get larger and more accurate they tend to display more equivariance, regardless of architecture. For example, transformers can be more equivariant than convolutional neural networks after training.
6/19/2024
🖼️
Learning Probabilistic Symmetrization for Architecture Agnostic Equivariance
Jinwoo Kim, Tien Dat Nguyen, Ayhan Suleymanzade, Hyeokjun An, Seunghoon Hong
0
0
We present a novel framework to overcome the limitations of equivariant architectures in learning functions with group symmetries. In contrary to equivariant architectures, we use an arbitrary base model such as an MLP or a transformer and symmetrize it to be equivariant to the given group by employing a small equivariant network that parameterizes the probabilistic distribution underlying the symmetrization. The distribution is end-to-end trained with the base model which can maximize performance while reducing sample complexity of symmetrization. We show that this approach ensures not only equivariance to given group but also universal approximation capability in expectation. We implement our method on various base models, including patch-based transformers that can be initialized from pretrained vision transformers, and test them for a wide range of symmetry groups including permutation and Euclidean groups and their combinations. Empirical tests show competitive results against tailored equivariant architectures, suggesting the potential for learning equivariant functions for diverse groups using a non-equivariant universal base architecture. We further show evidence of enhanced learning in symmetric modalities, like graphs, when pretrained from non-symmetric modalities, like vision. Code is available at https://github.com/jw9730/lps.
4/16/2024