Improved Decision Module Selection for Hierarchical Inference in Resource-Constrained Edge Devices

Read original: arXiv:2406.09424 - Published 6/17/2024 by Adarsh Prasad Behera, Roberto Morabito, Joerg Widmer, Jaya Prakash Champati

🤯

Overview

The paper explores a hierarchical inference (HI) approach to balance inference accuracy, data processing, and offloading cost for resource-constrained edge devices.
HI involves executing simple inferences locally on edge devices, while offloading complex inferences to central servers.
This approach is particularly useful for IoT sensors and microcontrollers running tinyML inference.
The paper proposes and evaluates three distinct HI techniques for image classification tasks.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses a method called hierarchical inference (HI) that helps address the challenges faced by resource-constrained edge devices, such as IoT sensors and microcontrollers, when running deep learning models. These devices often struggle to perform complex machine learning tasks due to their limited processing power and memory.

The HI approach involves a tiered system where simple data samples are processed and inferred on the edge device itself, while more complex data is offloaded to central servers for processing. This helps balance the tradeoffs between inference accuracy, data processing, and the cost of offloading computations.

Compared to other strategies like local inference, edge server offloading, and split inference, the HI approach proves to be more efficient for scenarios involving resource-constrained edge devices running tinyML models.

Technical Explanation

The paper explores three distinct HI approaches for image classification tasks:

Simple Offloading: All images are first processed on the edge device, and only those that the device is unable to classify with high confidence are offloaded to the central server.
Adaptive Offloading: The system dynamically determines which images should be processed locally or offloaded, based on the current workload and resource constraints of the edge device.
Hierarchical Offloading: Images are first processed by a lightweight model on the edge device, and only those that the lightweight model is unable to classify are then offloaded to the central server for processing by a more complex model.

The researchers evaluate the performance of these three HI approaches and compare them to other inference strategies, such as local inference, edge server offloading, and split inference. The evaluation metrics include inference accuracy, data processing latency, and offloading cost.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of the proposed HI approaches, highlighting their benefits in terms of improved inference accuracy, reduced data processing latency, and lower offloading costs compared to other strategies. However, the researchers also acknowledge some limitations and areas for further research:

The performance of the HI approaches may be sensitive to the specific characteristics of the edge devices and the complexity of the machine learning tasks.
The optimal partitioning of the inference task between the edge device and central server may need to be dynamic and adaptive, based on real-time resource constraints and workload.
Additional research is needed to explore the trade-offs between inference accuracy, latency, and offloading cost in more depth and develop more sophisticated HI techniques.

Overall, the paper presents a promising approach to address the challenges of running machine learning models on resource-constrained edge devices, but further research and refinement may be necessary to fully realize its potential.

Conclusion

The paper introduces the hierarchical inference (HI) paradigm as an effective method for balancing inference accuracy, data processing, and offloading cost in scenarios involving resource-constrained edge devices running tinyML models. The proposed HI approaches, including simple offloading, adaptive offloading, and hierarchical offloading, demonstrate improved performance compared to other inference strategies, such as local inference, edge server offloading, and split inference. While the paper highlights the potential benefits of the HI approach, it also acknowledges the need for further research to address the limitations and explore more advanced techniques for optimizing inference tasks on edge devices.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤯

Improved Decision Module Selection for Hierarchical Inference in Resource-Constrained Edge Devices

Adarsh Prasad Behera, Roberto Morabito, Joerg Widmer, Jaya Prakash Champati

The Hierarchical Inference (HI) paradigm employs a tiered processing: the inference from simple data samples are accepted at the end device, while complex data samples are offloaded to the central servers. HI has recently emerged as an effective method for balancing inference accuracy, data processing, transmission throughput, and offloading cost. This approach proves particularly efficient in scenarios involving resource-constrained edge devices, such as IoT sensors and micro controller units (MCUs), tasked with executing tinyML inference. Notably, it outperforms strategies such as local inference execution, inference offloading to edge servers or cloud facilities, and split inference (i.e., inference execution distributed between two endpoints). Building upon the HI paradigm, this work explores different techniques aimed at further optimizing inference task execution. We propose and discuss three distinct HI approaches and evaluate their utility for image classification.

6/17/2024

Exploring the Boundaries of On-Device Inference: When Tiny Falls Short, Go Hierarchical

Adarsh Prasad Behera, Paulius Daubaris, I~naki Bravo, Jos'e Gallego, Roberto Morabito, Joerg Widmer, Jaya Prakash Varma Champati

On-device inference holds great potential for increased energy efficiency, responsiveness, and privacy in edge ML systems. However, due to less capable ML models that can be embedded in resource-limited devices, use cases are limited to simple inference tasks such as visual keyword spotting, gesture recognition, and predictive analytics. In this context, the Hierarchical Inference (HI) system has emerged as a promising solution that augments the capabilities of the local ML by offloading selected samples to an edge server or cloud for remote ML inference. Existing works demonstrate through simulation that HI improves accuracy. However, they do not account for the latency and energy consumption on the device, nor do they consider three key heterogeneous dimensions that characterize ML systems: hardware, network connectivity, and models. In contrast, this paper systematically compares the performance of HI with on-device inference based on measurements of accuracy, latency, and energy for running embedded ML models on five devices with different capabilities and three image classification datasets. For a given accuracy requirement, the HI systems we designed achieved up to 73% lower latency and up to 77% lower device energy consumption than an on-device inference system. The key to building an efficient HI system is the availability of small-size, reasonably accurate on-device models whose outputs can be effectively differentiated for samples that require remote inference. Despite the performance gains, HI requires on-device inference for all samples, which adds a fixed overhead to its latency and energy consumption. Therefore, we design a hybrid system, Early Exit with HI (EE-HI), and demonstrate that compared to HI, EE-HI reduces the latency by up to 59.7% and lowers the device's energy consumption by up to 60.4%.

7/17/2024

🤯

Decentralized LLM Inference over Edge Networks with Energy Harvesting

Aria Khoshsirat, Giovanni Perin, Michele Rossi

Large language models have significantly transformed multiple fields with their exceptional performance in natural language tasks, but their deployment in resource-constrained environments like edge networks presents an ongoing challenge. Decentralized techniques for inference have emerged, distributing the model blocks among multiple devices to improve flexibility and cost effectiveness. However, energy limitations remain a significant concern for edge devices. We propose a sustainable model for collaborative inference on interconnected, battery-powered edge devices with energy harvesting. A semi-Markov model is developed to describe the states of the devices, considering processing parameters and average green energy arrivals. This informs the design of scheduling algorithms that aim to minimize device downtimes and maximize network throughput. Through empirical evaluations and simulated runs, we validate the effectiveness of our approach, paving the way for energy-efficient decentralized inference over edge networks.

8/29/2024

Adaptive Device-Edge Collaboration on DNN Inference in AIoT: A Digital Twin-Assisted Approach

Shisheng Hu, Mushu Li, Jie Gao, Conghao Zhou, Xuemin Shen

Device-edge collaboration on deep neural network (DNN) inference is a promising approach to efficiently utilizing network resources for supporting artificial intelligence of things (AIoT) applications. In this paper, we propose a novel digital twin (DT)-assisted approach to device-edge collaboration on DNN inference that determines whether and when to stop local inference at a device and upload the intermediate results to complete the inference on an edge server. Instead of determining the collaboration for each DNN inference task only upon its generation, multi-step decision-making is performed during the on-device inference to adapt to the dynamic computing workload status at the device and the edge server. To enhance the adaptivity, a DT is constructed to evaluate all potential offloading decisions for each DNN inference task, which provides augmented training data for a machine learning-assisted decision-making algorithm. Then, another DT is constructed to estimate the inference status at the device to avoid frequently fetching the status information from the device, thus reducing the signaling overhead. We also derive necessary conditions for optimal offloading decisions to reduce the offloading decision space. Simulation results demon-strate the outstanding performance of our DT-assisted approach in terms of balancing the tradeoff among inference accuracy, delay, and energy consumption.

5/29/2024