Improving Group Robustness on Spurious Correlation Requires Preciser Group Inference
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the challenge of group robustness on machine learning models that exhibit spurious correlation
- It proposes a method for more precise group inference to improve group robustness and mitigate the effects of spurious correlation
- The research aims to address limitations in existing approaches that can lead to biased performance for minority groups
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models sometimes learn patterns that are not actually meaningful, known as "spurious correlations." This can cause the models to perform poorly on certain groups, especially minority groups. The paper suggests that improving the way we identify and define these groups, or "group inference," can help make the models more robust and fair across different groups.
The key idea is that by getting a more accurate understanding of the relevant groups, we can better account for the effects of spurious correlation and improve the model's performance on minority groups. This is important because models that rely on spurious correlations can end up discriminating against certain populations, which is a critical issue as machine learning becomes more widely deployed.
The paper builds on previous work that has explored related challenges around group robustness and spurious correlations. It also connects to research on mitigating spurious correlations and dataset-wise attribution methods that can help identify problematic patterns in the data.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a method for "preciser group inference" to improve group robustness on models affected by spurious correlation. The key elements are:
-
Group Identification: The method first aims to more accurately identify the relevant groups in the data, going beyond simplistic demographic categorizations. This involves using techniques like integrated gradients to understand how the model is making decisions.
-
Group-Aware Training: With the refined group definitions, the model is then trained in a way that explicitly accounts for the different groups. This helps the model learn representations that are more robust to the effects of spurious correlation.
-
Evaluation: The paper introduces new evaluation metrics that assess group-level performance more precisely, moving beyond the limitations of standard accuracy measures. This allows for a more nuanced understanding of the model's behavior.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on several benchmark datasets. They show that the preciser group inference method can significantly improve performance on minority groups compared to prior techniques, which tended to overlook the subtleties of how the model was making decisions.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a valuable contribution by highlighting the importance of accurate group inference for improving model robustness and fairness. However, it also acknowledges some limitations:
-
The group identification process relies on gradient-based techniques, which can be sensitive to model architecture and hyperparameters. More research is needed to ensure the reliability and generalizability of these methods.
-
The evaluation metrics proposed, while more comprehensive than standard accuracy, still may not capture all the relevant fairness considerations. There is ongoing debate in the field about the best ways to assess model fairness.
-
The paper focuses on spurious correlations, but there may be other types of dataset biases and confounding factors that also need to be addressed for truly robust and fair machine learning systems. Reactive model correction is one approach that has explored these broader challenges.
Overall, this research represents an important step towards more nuanced and effective techniques for improving group robustness in machine learning. However, as with any complex problem, there is still much work to be done to fully address the various facets of bias and fairness in AI systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel method for "preciser group inference" to enhance group robustness in machine learning models affected by spurious correlation. By more accurately identifying the relevant groups in the data and tailoring the model training process accordingly, the approach can significantly improve performance on minority groups compared to prior techniques.
The research highlights the critical importance of going beyond simplistic group definitions and accounting for the subtleties of how models make decisions. As machine learning becomes more widely deployed, ensuring fairness and robustness across diverse populations is essential. This work represents an important contribution towards that goal, though additional research is still needed to address the broader challenges of bias and fairness in AI.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Improving Group Robustness on Spurious Correlation Requires Preciser Group Inference
Yujin Han, Difan Zou
Standard empirical risk minimization (ERM) models may prioritize learning spurious correlations between spurious features and true labels, leading to poor accuracy on groups where these correlations do not hold. Mitigating this issue often requires expensive spurious attribute (group) labels or relies on trained ERM models to infer group labels when group information is unavailable. However, the significant performance gap in worst-group accuracy between using pseudo group labels and using oracle group labels inspires us to consider further improving group robustness through preciser group inference. Therefore, we propose GIC, a novel method that accurately infers group labels, resulting in improved worst-group performance. GIC trains a spurious attribute classifier based on two key properties of spurious correlations: (1) high correlation between spurious attributes and true labels, and (2) variability in this correlation between datasets with different group distributions. Empirical studies on multiple datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of GIC in inferring group labels, and combining GIC with various downstream invariant learning methods improves worst-group accuracy, showcasing its powerful flexibility. Additionally, through analyzing the misclassifications in GIC, we identify an interesting phenomenon called semantic consistency, which may contribute to better decoupling the association between spurious attributes and labels, thereby mitigating spurious correlation. The code for GIC is available at https://github.com/yujinhanml/GIC.
Read more6/5/2024
0
Out of spuriousity: Improving robustness to spurious correlations without group annotations
Phuong Quynh Le, Jorg Schlotterer, Christin Seifert
Machine learning models are known to learn spurious correlations, i.e., features having strong relations with class labels but no causal relation. Relying on those correlations leads to poor performance in the data groups without these correlations and poor generalization ability. To improve the robustness of machine learning models to spurious correlations, we propose an approach to extract a subnetwork from a fully trained network that does not rely on spurious correlations. The subnetwork is found by the assumption that data points with the same spurious attribute will be close to each other in the representation space when training with ERM, then we employ supervised contrastive loss in a novel way to force models to unlearn the spurious connections. The increase in the worst-group performance of our approach contributes to strengthening the hypothesis that there exists a subnetwork in a fully trained dense network that is responsible for using only invariant features in classification tasks, therefore erasing the influence of spurious features even in the setup of multi spurious attributes and no prior knowledge of attributes labels.
Read more7/23/2024
0
Learning Robust Classifiers with Self-Guided Spurious Correlation Mitigation
Guangtao Zheng, Wenqian Ye, Aidong Zhang
Deep neural classifiers tend to rely on spurious correlations between spurious attributes of inputs and targets to make predictions, which could jeopardize their generalization capability. Training classifiers robust to spurious correlations typically relies on annotations of spurious correlations in data, which are often expensive to get. In this paper, we tackle an annotation-free setting and propose a self-guided spurious correlation mitigation framework. Our framework automatically constructs fine-grained training labels tailored for a classifier obtained with empirical risk minimization to improve its robustness against spurious correlations. The fine-grained training labels are formulated with different prediction behaviors of the classifier identified in a novel spuriousness embedding space. We construct the space with automatically detected conceptual attributes and a novel spuriousness metric which measures how likely a class-attribute correlation is exploited for predictions. We demonstrate that training the classifier to distinguish different prediction behaviors reduces its reliance on spurious correlations without knowing them a priori and outperforms prior methods on five real-world datasets.
Read more5/7/2024
0
Spuriousness-Aware Meta-Learning for Learning Robust Classifiers
Guangtao Zheng, Wenqian Ye, Aidong Zhang
Spurious correlations are brittle associations between certain attributes of inputs and target variables, such as the correlation between an image background and an object class. Deep image classifiers often leverage them for predictions, leading to poor generalization on the data where the correlations do not hold. Mitigating the impact of spurious correlations is crucial towards robust model generalization, but it often requires annotations of the spurious correlations in data -- a strong assumption in practice. In this paper, we propose a novel learning framework based on meta-learning, termed SPUME -- SPUriousness-aware MEta-learning, to train an image classifier to be robust to spurious correlations. We design the framework to iteratively detect and mitigate the spurious correlations that the classifier excessively relies on for predictions. To achieve this, we first propose to utilize a pre-trained vision-language model to extract text-format attributes from images. These attributes enable us to curate data with various class-attribute correlations, and we formulate a novel metric to measure the degree of these correlations' spuriousness. Then, to mitigate the reliance on spurious correlations, we propose a meta-learning strategy in which the support (training) sets and query (test) sets in tasks are curated with different spurious correlations that have high degrees of spuriousness. By meta-training the classifier on these spuriousness-aware meta-learning tasks, our classifier can learn to be invariant to the spurious correlations. We demonstrate that our method is robust to spurious correlations without knowing them a priori and achieves the best on five benchmark datasets with different robustness measures.
Read more6/18/2024