Interpretable-by-Design Text Understanding with Iteratively Generated Concept Bottleneck

Overview

• Black-box deep neural networks excel at text classification, but their lack of interpretability limits their use in high-stakes domains.
• The paper proposes Text Bottleneck Models (TBM), an interpretable text classification framework that provides both global and local explanations.
• TBM predicts categorical values for a sparse set of salient concepts and uses a linear layer over those concepts to make the final prediction.
• The concepts can be automatically discovered and measured by a Large Language Model without human curation.
• Experiments show TBM can rival the performance of black-box baselines like few-shot GPT-4 and finetuned DeBERTa, though it falls short against finetuned GPT-3.5.
• Human evaluation validates that TBM can generate high-quality, relevant concepts, and the concept measurements align well with human judgments.

Plain English Explanation

Deep neural networks are exceptionally skilled at tasks like classifying text, meaning they can quickly and accurately determine the category or type of a given piece of text. However, these "black-box" models are difficult for humans to understand - it's not clear how they arrive at their conclusions. This lack of interpretability makes them challenging to use in high-stakes domains, like healthcare or finance, where it's important to understand the reasoning behind important decisions.

The researchers propose a new approach called Text Bottleneck Models (TBM) that aims to provide both high performance and interpretability. Instead of directly predicting the output label, TBM first identifies a small set of key concepts that are relevant to the task. It then uses those concept values to make the final prediction through a simple, linear calculation.

The cool part is that TBM can discover these interpretable concepts automatically, without any manual curation by humans. It uses a powerful language model to identify the most important ideas and measure how strongly they are expressed in the input text.

In experiments, TBM was able to match the performance of opaque, black-box models in many text classification tasks. And when humans evaluated the concepts identified by TBM, they found them to be high-quality and closely aligned with their own understanding. This suggests the model's reasoning is indeed interpretable and transparent.

Overall, TBM seems like a promising new approach that could bring the power of deep learning to high-stakes domains, while also making the decision-making process clearer and more accessible.

Technical Explanation

The core idea behind Text Bottleneck Models (TBM) is to create an intrinsically interpretable text classification system. Rather than directly predicting the output label, TBM first predicts a sparse set of categorical concept values and then uses a simple linear layer over those concepts to make the final prediction.

The key steps are:

1. Automatically discover a set of salient concepts using a Large Language Model (LLM).
2. Measure the strength of each concept in the input text using the LLM.
3. Pass the concept values through a linear layer to produce the final classification output.

This architecture provides both global and local interpretability. The concepts themselves offer global insight into the key factors driving the prediction. And the linear layer weights indicate how much each concept contributes to the final output, providing local, example-specific explanations.

Experiments were conducted on 12 diverse text understanding datasets. TBM was able to rival the performance of black-box baselines like few-shot GPT-4 and finetuned DeBERTa, though it fell short against the more powerful finetuned GPT-3.5. Importantly, comprehensive human evaluation showed the concepts generated by TBM were highly relevant and aligned well with human judgments.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a strong case for TBM as a promising new interpretable text classification framework. However, a few caveats and areas for further research are worth noting:

1. While TBM performed well, it still lagged behind the most powerful finetuned language models. Improving its raw performance without sacrificing interpretability could be an important area of future work.

2. The paper does not explore TBM's robustness or sample efficiency compared to black-box models. Understanding how the interpretable architecture affects these properties could be valuable.

3. The human evaluation focused on the relevance and alignment of the discovered concepts. Further research could investigate whether users actually find the explanations provided by TBM to be meaningful and actionable in real-world high-stakes settings.

4. The automatic concept discovery process could potentially surface biased or problematic concepts. Careful examination of the types of concepts learned, and mechanisms to ensure they are ethical and unbiased, may be an important consideration.

Overall, while the paper presents encouraging results, there are still open questions and potential limitations that warrant further exploration as this line of research progresses.

Conclusion

Text Bottleneck Models offer a compelling new approach to text classification that enhances interpretability without major performance tradeoffs. By predicting a sparse set of salient concepts and using them to drive the final prediction, TBM provides both global and local explanations that align well with human understanding.

The ability to automatically discover these interpretable concepts is a key innovation, as it avoids the need for manual curation and makes the framework more broadly applicable. While TBM still has room for improvement, especially in raw classification performance, the promising results suggest it could be a valuable tool for bringing the power of deep learning to high-stakes domains where transparency is crucial.

As AI systems become increasingly ubiquitous, approaches like TBM that prioritize interpretability alongside performance will likely become increasingly important. This research represents an important step forward in that direction.