Interpretation of Neural Networks is Susceptible to Universal Adversarial Perturbations

Read original: arXiv:2212.03095 - Published 4/23/2024 by Haniyeh Ehsani Oskouie, Farzan Farnia

🧠

Overview

The paper investigates the vulnerability of gradient-based interpretation schemes used to explain neural network classifiers to adversarial perturbations.
It proposes methods to compute a "Universal Perturbation for Interpretation" (UPI) that can effectively alter a neural network's gradient-based interpretation on different samples.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their UPI approaches on standard image datasets.

Plain English Explanation

Neural networks are powerful machine learning models that can achieve high accuracy on a variety of tasks, such as image recognition. However, these models are often criticized for being "black boxes" - it's not always clear how they arrive at their predictions.

To address this, researchers have developed techniques called "gradient-based interpretation schemes" that aim to explain the inner workings of neural networks. These methods analyze the gradient, or the rate of change, of the network's output with respect to its input. By looking at the gradients, we can identify the parts of the input that had the biggest influence on the network's decision.

While these gradient-based interpretation schemes work well on standard datasets, recent research has shown that they can be "fooled" by carefully crafted adversarial perturbations - small, imperceptible changes to the input that cause the network to change its interpretation.

The key insight of this paper is that we can actually find a single, universal perturbation that can alter the gradient-based interpretation of a neural network across a wide range of input samples. The authors call this a "Universal Perturbation for Interpretation" (UPI).

To compute this UPI, the authors propose two approaches: a gradient-based optimization method, and a Principal Component Analysis (PCA)-based method. They show that these UPI approaches can effectively change the gradient-based explanations produced by neural networks on standard image datasets.

This work highlights the fragility of current gradient-based interpretation methods and the need for more robust techniques to explain the inner workings of neural networks. By understanding the limitations of these interpretability methods, we can work towards developing more reliable and trustworthy AI systems.

Technical Explanation

The paper starts by noting that while gradient-based interpretation schemes have been extensively studied in the deep learning literature, recent work has demonstrated their vulnerability to norm-bounded adversarial perturbations - small, carefully crafted changes to the input that can significantly alter the gradient-based feature maps produced by neural networks.

However, the authors argue that these adversarial perturbations are typically designed using knowledge of the specific input sample, and may not perform as well on unknown or constantly changing data points. To address this, the paper introduces the concept of a "Universal Perturbation for Interpretation" (UPI) - a single perturbation that can effectively alter the gradient-based interpretation of a neural network across a significant fraction of test samples.

The authors propose two methods to compute such a UPI:

Gradient-based Optimization: The first approach formulates the problem as an optimization task, where the goal is to find a perturbation that maximizes the change in the gradient-based interpretation across a set of input samples.
PCA-based Approach: The second method uses Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to identify the principal directions in the gradient space that can be used to construct an effective UPI.

The paper presents numerical results demonstrating the effectiveness of these UPI approaches on standard image datasets like CIFAR-10 and ImageNet. The authors show that their UPI methods can significantly alter the gradient-based interpretations produced by neural networks, highlighting the fragility of these widely-used interpretation schemes.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a strong case for the existence of a "Universal Perturbation for Interpretation" (UPI) that can effectively undermine the reliability of gradient-based interpretation schemes for neural networks. By demonstrating the effectiveness of their UPI approaches on standard image datasets, the authors highlight a significant limitation of current interpretability techniques.

However, the paper does not address several important questions and potential limitations of this research:

Generalizability: The experiments in the paper are limited to standard image classification datasets. It's unclear whether the UPI approaches would be equally effective on more complex or diverse datasets, or for different types of neural network architectures and tasks.
Practical Implications: While the paper demonstrates the theoretical existence of a UPI, it doesn't explore the practical implications of such perturbations in real-world applications. For example, how might a UPI affect the trust and reliability of AI systems in critical domains like healthcare or autonomous driving?
Countermeasures: The paper does not discuss potential countermeasures or more robust interpretation schemes that could be developed to mitigate the impact of UPIs. Further research may be needed to address the fragility of gradient-based interpretation methods.
Ethical Considerations: The paper does not address the ethical implications of developing techniques that can effectively "fool" neural network interpretations. Such methods could potentially be misused to undermine the transparency and accountability of AI systems.

Overall, the paper makes an important contribution by highlighting the vulnerability of gradient-based interpretation schemes to universal perturbations. However, additional research is needed to fully understand the practical implications and develop more robust interpretability techniques for neural networks.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates the existence of a "Universal Perturbation for Interpretation" (UPI) that can effectively alter the gradient-based explanations produced by neural network classifiers. By proposing two methods to compute such a UPI, the authors show that current interpretation schemes are vulnerable to carefully crafted perturbations that can undermine their reliability across a wide range of input samples.

This work highlights the need for more robust and trustworthy interpretability techniques in the field of deep learning. As previous research has shown, the fragility of AI systems to adversarial attacks is a significant concern that must be addressed to enable the safe and ethical deployment of these technologies. By understanding the limitations of gradient-based interpretation methods, researchers can work towards developing more reliable and transparent AI systems that can be trusted by users and stakeholders.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🧠

Interpretation of Neural Networks is Susceptible to Universal Adversarial Perturbations

Haniyeh Ehsani Oskouie, Farzan Farnia

Interpreting neural network classifiers using gradient-based saliency maps has been extensively studied in the deep learning literature. While the existing algorithms manage to achieve satisfactory performance in application to standard image recognition datasets, recent works demonstrate the vulnerability of widely-used gradient-based interpretation schemes to norm-bounded perturbations adversarially designed for every individual input sample. However, such adversarial perturbations are commonly designed using the knowledge of an input sample, and hence perform sub-optimally in application to an unknown or constantly changing data point. In this paper, we show the existence of a Universal Perturbation for Interpretation (UPI) for standard image datasets, which can alter a gradient-based feature map of neural networks over a significant fraction of test samples. To design such a UPI, we propose a gradient-based optimization method as well as a principal component analysis (PCA)-based approach to compute a UPI which can effectively alter a neural network's gradient-based interpretation on different samples. We support the proposed UPI approaches by presenting several numerical results of their successful applications to standard image datasets.

4/23/2024

🔎

Universal Adversarial Perturbations for Vision-Language Pre-trained Models

Peng-Fei Zhang, Zi Huang, Guangdong Bai

Vision-language pre-trained (VLP) models have been the foundation of numerous vision-language tasks. Given their prevalence, it be- comes imperative to assess their adversarial robustness, especially when deploying them in security-crucial real-world applications. Traditionally, adversarial perturbations generated for this assessment target specific VLP models, datasets, and/or downstream tasks. This practice suffers from low transferability and additional computation costs when transitioning to new scenarios. In this work, we thoroughly investigate whether VLP models are commonly sensitive to imperceptible perturbations of a specific pattern for the image modality. To this end, we propose a novel black-box method to generate Universal Adversarial Perturbations (UAPs), which is so called the Effective and T ransferable Universal Adversarial Attack (ETU), aiming to mislead a variety of existing VLP models in a range of downstream tasks. The ETU comprehensively takes into account the characteristics of UAPs and the intrinsic cross-modal interactions to generate effective UAPs. Under this regime, the ETU encourages both global and local utilities of UAPs. This benefits the overall utility while reducing interactions between UAP units, improving the transferability. To further enhance the effectiveness and transferability of UAPs, we also design a novel data augmentation method named ScMix. ScMix consists of self-mix and cross-mix data transformations, which can effectively increase the multi-modal data diversity while preserving the semantics of the original data. Through comprehensive experiments on various downstream tasks, VLP models, and datasets, we demonstrate that the proposed method is able to achieve effective and transferrable universal adversarial attacks.

5/10/2024

Structured Gradient-based Interpretations via Norm-Regularized Adversarial Training

Shizhan Gong, Qi Dou, Farzan Farnia

Gradient-based saliency maps have been widely used to explain the decisions of deep neural network classifiers. However, standard gradient-based interpretation maps, including the simple gradient and integrated gradient algorithms, often lack desired structures such as sparsity and connectedness in their application to real-world computer vision models. A frequently used approach to inducing sparsity structures into gradient-based saliency maps is to alter the simple gradient scheme using sparsification or norm-based regularization. A drawback with such post-processing methods is their frequently-observed significant loss in fidelity to the original simple gradient map. In this work, we propose to apply adversarial training as an in-processing scheme to train neural networks with structured simple gradient maps. We show a duality relation between the regularized norms of the adversarial perturbations and gradient-based maps, based on which we design adversarial training loss functions promoting sparsity and group-sparsity properties in simple gradient maps. We present several numerical results to show the influence of our proposed norm-based adversarial training methods on the standard gradient-based maps of standard neural network architectures on benchmark image datasets.

4/9/2024

One Perturbation is Enough: On Generating Universal Adversarial Perturbations against Vision-Language Pre-training Models

Hao Fang, Jiawei Kong, Wenbo Yu, Bin Chen, Jiawei Li, Shutao Xia, Ke Xu

Vision-Language Pre-training (VLP) models trained on large-scale image-text pairs have demonstrated unprecedented capability in many practical applications. However, previous studies have revealed that VLP models are vulnerable to adversarial samples crafted by a malicious adversary. While existing attacks have achieved great success in improving attack effect and transferability, they all focus on instance-specific attacks that generate perturbations for each input sample. In this paper, we show that VLP models can be vulnerable to a new class of universal adversarial perturbation (UAP) for all input samples. Although initially transplanting existing UAP algorithms to perform attacks showed effectiveness in attacking discriminative models, the results were unsatisfactory when applied to VLP models. To this end, we revisit the multimodal alignments in VLP model training and propose the Contrastive-training Perturbation Generator with Cross-modal conditions (C-PGC). Specifically, we first design a generator that incorporates cross-modal information as conditioning input to guide the training. To further exploit cross-modal interactions, we propose to formulate the training objective as a multimodal contrastive learning paradigm based on our constructed positive and negative image-text pairs. By training the conditional generator with the designed loss, we successfully force the adversarial samples to move away from its original area in the VLP model's feature space, and thus essentially enhance the attacks. Extensive experiments show that our method achieves remarkable attack performance across various VLP models and Vision-and-Language (V+L) tasks. Moreover, C-PGC exhibits outstanding black-box transferability and achieves impressive results in fooling prevalent large VLP models including LLaVA and Qwen-VL.

6/11/2024