Introduction to Online Nonstochastic Control

Overview

• This paper introduces a new paradigm called "online nonstochastic control" for controlling dynamic systems.
• It applies techniques from online convex optimization and convex relaxations to develop new control methods with provable guarantees.
• The key difference is the objective - instead of aiming to perform as well as an offline optimal strategy, the goal is to minimize regret against the best policy in hindsight.

Plain English Explanation

The paper discusses an emerging approach to controlling dynamic systems called online nonstochastic control. Traditional control methods like optimal control and robust control focus on performing as well as the best possible strategy that could be designed offline.

In contrast, online nonstochastic control has a different goal. The cost functions and model perturbations are chosen by an adversary, so there is no pre-defined optimal policy. Instead, the aim is to do well compared to the best policy that could be identified in hindsight, using a technique called online convex optimization.

This shift in objective allows the use of iterative optimization algorithms that come with mathematical guarantees on regret (how much worse the method performs compared to the best hindsight policy) and computational complexity.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a new paradigm called "online nonstochastic control" for controlling dynamical systems. This approach borrows techniques from the field of online convex optimization and applies them to classical control settings like optimal control and robust control.

The key distinction is the objective function. Traditional control methods aim to perform comparably to an offline optimal strategy, assuming the presence of stochastic noise. In online nonstochastic control, both the cost functions and the perturbations from the assumed dynamical model are chosen adversarially. This means there is no pre-defined optimal policy; instead, the goal is to achieve low regret against the best policy that could be identified in hindsight from a benchmark class.

By framing the problem in this way, the authors are able to leverage techniques from online convex optimization, such as iterative mathematical optimization algorithms. These methods come with theoretical guarantees on regret and computational complexity, providing a principled approach to control in adversarial settings.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising perspective on control of dynamical systems. By shifting the objective from matching an offline optimal strategy to minimizing regret against the best hindsight policy, the authors open the door to new algorithmic approaches with stronger theoretical guarantees.

However, the practical applicability of this framework may be limited by the assumption of adversarial perturbations. In many real-world control settings, the disturbances may not be chosen in such a malicious manner. Additionally, the paper does not explore how the proposed methods would scale to high-dimensional or continuous-time systems, which are common in practical control applications.

Further research would be needed to understand the tradeoffs between the theoretical benefits of online nonstochastic control and its ability to handle realistic control problems. Experimental validation on benchmark control tasks could also help assess the practical viability of this approach.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a new paradigm called "online nonstochastic control" that applies techniques from online convex optimization to classical control settings. By shifting the objective from matching an offline optimal strategy to minimizing regret against the best hindsight policy, the authors develop a principled framework with provable guarantees on regret and computational complexity.

While the theoretical foundations of this approach are promising, further research is needed to understand its practical applicability, especially in high-dimensional or continuous-time control problems. Experimental evaluation and comparison to existing control methods would help clarify the strengths and limitations of online nonstochastic control.

Overall, this work represents an intriguing new direction in the control of dynamical systems, with the potential to spur further advances in this important field.