JANET: Joint Adaptive predictioN-region Estimation for Time-series

Read original: arXiv:2407.06390 - Published 7/10/2024 by Eshant English, Eliot Wong-Toi, Matteo Fontana, Stephan Mandt, Padhraic Smyth, Christoph Lippert
Total Score

0

JANET: Joint Adaptive predictioN-region Estimation for Time-series

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • JANET is a method for jointly estimating adaptive prediction regions for time-series models.
  • It aims to improve on existing techniques by providing more accurate and reliable prediction intervals.
  • The method leverages conformal prediction to generate distribution-free prediction regions that adapt to the underlying data.

Plain English Explanation

JANET: Joint Adaptive predictioN-region Estimation for Time-series is a new approach for forecasting the future values of a time series. Traditional forecasting methods often struggle to provide reliable estimates of the uncertainty around their predictions. JANET addresses this by using a technique called "conformal prediction" to construct prediction regions - ranges of values that are likely to contain the true future observation with a specified level of confidence.

The key innovation of JANET is that it can jointly estimate multiple prediction regions for a time series, rather than just a single interval. This allows the method to better capture complex dependencies and heterogeneity in the data. For example, JANET could provide separate prediction regions for the lower, middle, and upper parts of the distribution of possible future values.

Additionally, JANET's prediction regions can adapt to changes in the underlying time series, becoming wider or narrower as the uncertainty in the data fluctuates over time. This adaptive behavior helps JANET remain reliable and accurate even as the patterns in the data evolve.

By providing more informative and robust prediction intervals, JANET has the potential to improve decision-making and risk assessment in a variety of time-series applications, from financial forecasting to energy demand planning to healthcare monitoring.

Technical Explanation

JANET is a novel method for constructing joint adaptive prediction regions for time-series forecasting. The key components of the approach are:

  1. Conformal Prediction: JANET leverages the conformal prediction framework to generate distribution-free prediction regions that are guaranteed to have the desired coverage probability, even for complex, non-Gaussian data.

  2. Joint Modeling: Rather than estimating a single prediction interval, JANET jointly models multiple prediction regions corresponding to different quantiles of the target distribution. This allows it to better capture dependencies and heterogeneity in the time series.

  3. Adaptive Regions: The prediction regions estimated by JANET can adapt to changes in the underlying data distribution over time. This helps maintain reliable coverage as the patterns in the time series evolve.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of JANET through extensive experiments on both synthetic and real-world time-series datasets, comparing it to a range of existing forecasting methods. The results show that JANET can provide significantly more accurate and reliable prediction intervals than alternative techniques.

Critical Analysis

The authors of the JANET paper have made a convincing case for the advantages of their joint adaptive prediction region approach. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research that could be explored:

  1. Computational Complexity: Jointly modeling multiple prediction regions may increase the computational burden compared to simpler forecasting methods. The authors should investigate the scalability of JANET as the number of target quantiles grows.

  2. Sensitivity to Model Misspecification: Like other conformal prediction methods, JANET relies on an underlying forecasting model to generate the raw predictions. If this base model is poorly specified, it could negatively impact the quality of the final prediction regions. Further research is needed on JANET's robustness to model misspecification.

  3. Interpretability: While the adaptive and multi-modal nature of JANET's prediction regions is a strength, it may also reduce the interpretability of the forecasts. Techniques for enhancing the interpretability of the method's outputs could broaden its applicability.

  4. Extensions to Multivariate Time Series: The current JANET formulation is focused on univariate time series. Extending the approach to the multivariate setting could unlock new applications in areas like portfolio optimization and supply chain management.

Overall, JANET represents a promising advance in time-series forecasting that warrants further investigation and refinement. As with any research, a critical, open-minded perspective is important to fully understand the method's capabilities and limitations.

Conclusion

JANET is a novel time-series forecasting technique that can jointly estimate adaptive, distribution-free prediction regions. By leveraging conformal prediction, the method is able to provide reliable uncertainty quantification that adapts to changes in the underlying data.

The key strengths of JANET are its ability to model complex, heterogeneous time series and its potential to improve decision-making in a wide range of application domains. While the method has some limitations that require further exploration, the authors have demonstrated its effectiveness through extensive empirical evaluation.

As forecasting techniques continue to advance, tools like JANET that can provide accurate, well-calibrated prediction intervals will become increasingly valuable for supporting robust, data-driven decision-making. The ideas behind JANET represent an important step forward in the field of time-series analysis.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

JANET: Joint Adaptive predictioN-region Estimation for Time-series
Total Score

0

JANET: Joint Adaptive predictioN-region Estimation for Time-series

Eshant English, Eliot Wong-Toi, Matteo Fontana, Stephan Mandt, Padhraic Smyth, Christoph Lippert

Conformal prediction provides machine learning models with prediction sets that offer theoretical guarantees, but the underlying assumption of exchangeability limits its applicability to time series data. Furthermore, existing approaches struggle to handle multi-step ahead prediction tasks, where uncertainty estimates across multiple future time points are crucial. We propose JANET (Joint Adaptive predictioN-region Estimation for Time-series), a novel framework for constructing conformal prediction regions that are valid for both univariate and multivariate time series. JANET generalises the inductive conformal framework and efficiently produces joint prediction regions with controlled K-familywise error rates, enabling flexible adaptation to specific application needs. Our empirical evaluation demonstrates JANET's superior performance in multi-step prediction tasks across diverse time series datasets, highlighting its potential for reliable and interpretable uncertainty quantification in sequential data.

Read more

7/10/2024

🔮

Total Score

0

Joint Prediction Regions for time-series models

Eshant English

Machine Learning algorithms are notorious for providing point predictions but not prediction intervals. There are many applications where one requires confidence in predictions and prediction intervals. Stringing together, these intervals give rise to joint prediction regions with the desired significance level. It is an easy task to compute Joint Prediction regions (JPR) when the data is IID. However, the task becomes overly difficult when JPR is needed for time series because of the dependence between the observations. This project aims to implement Wolf and Wunderli's method for constructing JPRs and compare it with other methods (e.g. NP heuristic, Joint Marginals). The method under study is based on bootstrapping and is applied to different datasets (Min Temp, Sunspots), using different predictors (e.g. ARIMA and LSTM). One challenge of applying the method under study is to derive prediction standard errors for models, it cannot be obtained analytically. A novel method to estimate prediction standard error for different predictors is also devised. Finally, the method is applied to a synthetic dataset to find empirical averages and empirical widths and the results from the Wolf and Wunderli paper are consolidated. The experimental results show a narrowing of width with strong predictors like neural nets, widening of width with increasing forecast horizon H and decreasing significance level alpha, controlling the width with parameter k in K-FWE, and loss of information using Joint Marginals.

Read more

5/28/2024

🔮

Total Score

0

Multi-Modal Conformal Prediction Regions with Simple Structures by Optimizing Convex Shape Templates

Renukanandan Tumu, Matthew Cleaveland, Rahul Mangharam, George J. Pappas, Lars Lindemann

Conformal prediction is a statistical tool for producing prediction regions for machine learning models that are valid with high probability. A key component of conformal prediction algorithms is a emph{non-conformity score function} that quantifies how different a model's prediction is from the unknown ground truth value. Essentially, these functions determine the shape and the size of the conformal prediction regions. While prior work has gone into creating score functions that produce multi-model prediction regions, such regions are generally too complex for use in downstream planning and control problems. We propose a method that optimizes parameterized emph{shape template functions} over calibration data, which results in non-conformity score functions that produce prediction regions with minimum volume. Our approach results in prediction regions that are emph{multi-modal}, so they can properly capture residuals of distributions that have multiple modes, and emph{practical}, so each region is convex and can be easily incorporated into downstream tasks, such as a motion planner using conformal prediction regions. Our method applies to general supervised learning tasks, while we illustrate its use in time-series prediction. We provide a toolbox and present illustrative case studies of F16 fighter jets and autonomous vehicles, showing an up to $68%$ reduction in prediction region area compared to a circular baseline region.

Read more

6/26/2024

🔮

Total Score

0

Self-Consistent Conformal Prediction

Lars van der Laan, Ahmed M. Alaa

In decision-making guided by machine learning, decision-makers may take identical actions in contexts with identical predicted outcomes. Conformal prediction helps decision-makers quantify uncertainty in point predictions of outcomes, allowing for better risk management for actions. Motivated by this perspective, we introduce textit{Self-Consistent Conformal Prediction} for regression, which combines two post-hoc approaches -- Venn-Abers calibration and conformal prediction -- to provide calibrated point predictions and compatible prediction intervals that are valid conditional on model predictions. Our procedure can be applied post-hoc to any black-box model to provide predictions and inferences with finite-sample prediction-conditional guarantees. Numerical experiments show our approach strikes a balance between interval efficiency and conditional validity.

Read more

4/23/2024