Large Language Models Enable Automated Formative Feedback in Human-Robot Interaction Tasks
2405.16344
0
0
Abstract
We claim that LLMs can be paired with formal analysis methods to provide accessible, relevant feedback for HRI tasks. While logic specifications are useful for defining and assessing a task, these representations are not easily interpreted by non-experts. Luckily, LLMs are adept at generating easy-to-understand text that explains difficult concepts. By integrating task assessment outcomes and other contextual information into an LLM prompt, we can effectively synthesize a useful set of recommendations for the learner to improve their performance.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores how large language models (LLMs) can be used to provide automated formative feedback in human-robot interaction (HRI) tasks.
- The researchers developed a system that leverages LLMs to analyze user responses to robot prompts and generate tailored feedback to help users improve their performance.
- The system was evaluated in a study where participants completed HRI tasks and received automated feedback from the LLM-based system.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful AI systems that have been trained on vast amounts of text data, allowing them to understand and generate human-like language. In this paper, the researchers explored how LLMs can be used to enhance human-robot interaction (HRI) tasks, such as when a person is interacting with a robot.
The key idea is that an LLM can be used to analyze the responses that a person provides to a robot's prompts or questions, and then generate tailored feedback to help the person improve their performance. For example, if a person is trying to give instructions to a robot on how to complete a task, the LLM could analyze their response and provide feedback on how to make the instructions clearer or more specific.
To test this, the researchers developed a system that integrates an LLM to provide this kind of automated formative feedback during HRI tasks. They then conducted a study where participants completed various HRI tasks and received the automated feedback from the system.
The results of the study suggest that this approach can be effective in helping people improve their performance on HRI tasks, by providing them with timely and personalized feedback that is generated by the LLM. This could have important implications for enhancing human-robot interaction and using LLMs as research assistants to support human learning and skill development.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed a system that integrates large language models (LLMs) to provide automated formative feedback during human-robot interaction (HRI) tasks. The system works by analyzing the textual responses that a person provides to a robot's prompts or questions, and then generating tailored feedback to help the person improve their performance.
The key technical components of the system include:
- LLM-based Feedback Generator: An LLM model that is fine-tuned to analyze user responses and generate appropriate feedback. This component uses techniques from the field of reinforcement learning to learn how to provide effective feedback.
- Interaction Logging and Analysis: A module that records the interactions between the user and the robot, including the user's responses and the feedback provided by the system.
- User Interface: A natural language user interface that allows users to interact with the robot and receive the automated feedback.
The researchers evaluated the system in a user study where participants completed a series of HRI tasks, such as giving instructions to a robot or answering questions about a robot's capabilities. The participants received automated feedback from the LLM-based system, and their performance and learning outcomes were measured.
The results of the study showed that the automated feedback provided by the system was effective in helping participants improve their performance on the HRI tasks. Participants reported that the feedback was relevant and helpful, and their task completion times and accuracy improved over the course of the study.
Critical Analysis
The research presented in this paper demonstrates a promising approach for leveraging large language models to enhance human-robot interaction. The ability to provide automated, personalized feedback to users during HRI tasks could be a valuable tool for supporting skill development and improving task performance.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations and areas for further research. For example, the study was conducted in a controlled laboratory setting, and it's unclear how well the system would perform in more complex, real-world HRI scenarios. Additionally, the paper does not explore potential biases or ethical considerations that may arise from using an LLM-based system to provide feedback to users.
Further research could investigate the long-term effects of this approach on user learning and engagement, as well as explore ways to make the feedback generation more transparent and accountable. Additionally, researchers could investigate ways to integrate LLMs with other AI techniques to provide even more robust and effective feedback in HRI tasks.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach for using large language models to provide automated formative feedback in human-robot interaction tasks. The researchers developed a system that analyzes user responses and generates personalized feedback to help users improve their performance, and their evaluation showed promising results.
While the paper highlights the potential of this approach, it also raises questions about the limitations and broader implications of using LLMs in this context. Overall, this research contributes to the growing body of work on leveraging large language models to enhance human-robot interaction and support human learning and skill development.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
LaMI: Large Language Models for Multi-Modal Human-Robot Interaction
Chao Wang, Stephan Hasler, Daniel Tanneberg, Felix Ocker, Frank Joublin, Antonello Ceravola, Joerg Deigmoeller, Michael Gienger
0
0
This paper presents an innovative large language model (LLM)-based robotic system for enhancing multi-modal human-robot interaction (HRI). Traditional HRI systems relied on complex designs for intent estimation, reasoning, and behavior generation, which were resource-intensive. In contrast, our system empowers researchers and practitioners to regulate robot behavior through three key aspects: providing high-level linguistic guidance, creating atomic actions and expressions the robot can use, and offering a set of examples. Implemented on a physical robot, it demonstrates proficiency in adapting to multi-modal inputs and determining the appropriate manner of action to assist humans with its arms, following researchers' defined guidelines. Simultaneously, it coordinates the robot's lid, neck, and ear movements with speech output to produce dynamic, multi-modal expressions. This showcases the system's potential to revolutionize HRI by shifting from conventional, manual state-and-flow design methods to an intuitive, guidance-based, and example-driven approach. Supplementary material can be found at https://hri-eu.github.io/Lami/
4/12/2024
💬
Apprentices to Research Assistants: Advancing Research with Large Language Models
M. Namvarpour, A. Razi
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools in various research domains. This article examines their potential through a literature review and firsthand experimentation. While LLMs offer benefits like cost-effectiveness and efficiency, challenges such as prompt tuning, biases, and subjectivity must be addressed. The study presents insights from experiments utilizing LLMs for qualitative analysis, highlighting successes and limitations. Additionally, it discusses strategies for mitigating challenges, such as prompt optimization techniques and leveraging human expertise. This study aligns with the 'LLMs as Research Tools' workshop's focus on integrating LLMs into HCI data work critically and ethically. By addressing both opportunities and challenges, our work contributes to the ongoing dialogue on their responsible application in research.
4/10/2024
💬
Large Language Models for Human-Robot Interaction: Opportunities and Risks
Jesse Atuhurra
0
0
The tremendous development in large language models (LLM) has led to a new wave of innovations and applications and yielded research results that were initially forecast to take longer. In this work, we tap into these recent developments and present a meta-study about the potential of large language models if deployed in social robots. We place particular emphasis on the applications of social robots: education, healthcare, and entertainment. Before being deployed in social robots, we also study how these language models could be safely trained to ``understand'' societal norms and issues, such as trust, bias, ethics, cognition, and teamwork. We hope this study provides a resourceful guide to other robotics researchers interested in incorporating language models in their robots.
5/3/2024
Reinforcement Learning Problem Solving with Large Language Models
Sina Gholamian, Domingo Huh
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) encapsulate an extensive amount of world knowledge, and this has enabled their application in various domains to improve the performance of a variety of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. This has also facilitated a more accessible paradigm of conversation-based interactions between humans and AI systems to solve intended problems. However, one interesting avenue that shows untapped potential is the use of LLMs as Reinforcement Learning (RL) agents to enable conversational RL problem solving. Therefore, in this study, we explore the concept of formulating Markov Decision Process-based RL problems as LLM prompting tasks. We demonstrate how LLMs can be iteratively prompted to learn and optimize policies for specific RL tasks. In addition, we leverage the introduced prompting technique for episode simulation and Q-Learning, facilitated by LLMs. We then show the practicality of our approach through two detailed case studies for Research Scientist and Legal Matter Intake workflows.
4/30/2024